Abstract:Abstract With climate change threatening agricultural productivity and global food demand increasing, it is important to better understand which farm management practices will maximize crop yields in various climatic conditions. To assess the effectiveness of agricultural practices, researchers often turn to randomized field experiments, which are reliable for identifying causal effects but are often limited in scope and therefore lack external validity. Recently, researchers have also leveraged large observational datasets from satellites and other sources, which can lead to conclusions biased by confounding variables or systematic measurement errors. Because experimental and observational datasets have complementary strengths, in this paper we propose a method that uses a combination of experimental and observational data in the same analysis. As a case study, we focus on the causal effect of crop rotation on corn (maize) and soybean yields in the Midwestern United States. We find that, in terms of root mean squared error, our hybrid method performs 13% better than using experimental data alone and 26% better than using the observational data alone in the task of predicting the effect of rotation on corn yield at held-out experimental sites. Further, the causal estimates based on our method suggest that benefits of crop rotations on corn yield are lower in years and locations with high temperatures whereas the benefits of crop rotations on soybean yield are higher in years and locations with high temperatures. In particular, we estimated that the benefit of rotation on corn yields (and soybean yields) was 0.85 t ha −1 (0.24 t ha −1 ) on average for the top quintile of temperatures, 1.03 t ha −1 (0.21 t ha −1 ) on average for the whole dataset, and 1.19 t ha −1 (0.16 t ha −1 ) on average for the bottom quintile of temperatures. This association between temperatures and rotation benefits is consistent with the hypothesis that the benefit of the corn-soybean rotation on soybean yield is largely driven by pest pressure reductions while the benefit of the corn-soybean rotation on corn yields is largely driven by nitrogen availability.

Experimental Designs and Estimation Methods for On‐Farm Research: A Simulation Study of Corn Yields at Field Scale

Assessment of design and analysis frameworks for on-farm experimentation through a simulation study of wheat yield in Japan

Corn Yield Response to Plant Density and Nitrogen: Spatial Models and Yield Distribution

Assessing performance of empirical models for forecasting crop responses to variable fertilizer rates using on-farm precision experimentation

Examples of strategies to analyze spatial and temporal yield variability using crop models

Spatial Panel Models of Crop Yield Response to Weather: Econometric Specification Strategies and Prediction Performance

Modeling Long-Term Corn Yield Response to Nitrogen Rate and Crop Rotation

Exploring the Use of High-Resolution Satellite Images to Estimate Corn Silage Yield Within Field

Performance of Spatial Effect Model in Analysis of Field Experiment

Study on Spatial Variability of Crop Yield and Soil Properties

Extension and Evaluation of Intercropping Field Trials Using Spatial Models

Spatial Variability and Its Statistical Control in Field Experiment

Economic Analysis of Spatial‐Temporal Patterns in Corn and Soybean Response to Nitrogen and Phosphorus

Use of Repeated Measures Data Analysis for Field Trials with Annual and Perennial Crops

Characterizing and Classifying Variability in Corn Yield Response to Nitrogen Fertilization on Subfield and Field Scales

Combining randomized field experiments with observational satellite data to assess the benefits of crop rotations on yields

Predicting site-specific economic optimal nitrogen rate using machine learning methods and on-farm precision experimentation

Spatial and Temporal Variability of Spring Barley Yield and Quality Quantified by Crop Simulation Model

Evaluating Management Zone Optimal Nitrogen Rates with a Crop Growth Model

Spatial Variability of Soil Properties, Corn Quality and Yield in Two Illinois, Usa Fields: Implications for Precision Corn Management

Potential Impact of Precision Nitrogen Management on Corn Yield, Protein Content, and Test Weight