Illness Expectations Assessment in People with Asthma: A Tool for Explicit and Implicit Beliefs
Francesco Pagnini,Eleonora Volpato,Silvia Dell’Orto,Cesare Cavalera,MariaFrancesca Spina,Paolo Banfi
DOI: https://doi.org/10.2147/JAA.S307763
2021-05-04
Journal of Asthma and Allergy
Abstract:Francesco Pagnini, 1, 2 Eleonora Volpato, 1, 3 Silvia Dell'Orto, 1 Cesare Cavalera, 1 MariaFrancesca Spina, 3 Paolo Banfi 3 1 Department of Psychology, Università Cattolica del Sacro Cuore, Milan, Italy; 2 Department of Psychology, Harvard University, Cambridge, MA, USA; 3 Pneumological Rehabilitation, IRCCS Fondazione Don Carlo Gnocchi, Milan, Italy Correspondence: Francesco Pagnini Department of Psychology, Università Cattolica del Sacro Cuore, Via Nirone, 15, CAP, Milan, 20123, Italy Tel +39 339 1942425 Email Background: Illness expectations are cognitive schemas, both explicit and implicit, describing how symptoms are expected to be in the future. They can be particularly relevant to disease in a mind/body framework. Asthma is a condition in which the psychological aspects can highly influence the body, but no study has directly explored these specific expectations, and no dedicated assessment tools are available. Methods: We developed a questionnaire to assess the illness expectations, together with an ad hoc version of the Implicit Association Test (IAT). We tested its factorial structure, and the internal and test–retest validity, recruiting a sample of 183 asthmatic people. We also explored the convergent validity and the correlations with objective and subjective clinical assessments. Results: Data suggested a three-factorial structure of the questionnaire into expectations about future symptoms, change in current health status, and rigidity of these expectations. The questionnaire showed good psychometric properties and strong associations with the other considered outcomes, including implicit expectations. The implicit evaluation, however, lacked test–retest reliability. Conclusion: The questionnaire is a valid tool to assess illness expectations in people with asthma. The two expectation scales are highly related, and the implicit expectations are moderately associated with the explicit ones. The lack of stability related to IAT results may reflect a lack of stability of the implicit expectations. The implications for the mind/body framework still need to be fully explored. Keywords: illness expectations, mind/body connection, asthma, placebo, nocebo A person living with a chronic condition generally develops expectations about the future course of their illness. This expectation is a cognitive schema describing how the illness and its symptoms are anticipated to be in the future, 1 and they may be explicit – directly accessible to the declarative knowledge, or implicit – outside of the conscious awareness. 2 These expectations can shape different health behaviors 3 and are important mediators of the placebo/nocebo response. 4 Therefore, illness expectations can be particularly relevant for the progression of the disease, with the potential for influencing it either through direct (placebo-related) or indirect (behavior-related) pathways. 1 The Illness Expectation model also suggests that the rigidity level of these expectations may further influence their impact on symptoms. 1 The assessment of these schemas, in particular the implicit ones, has been sometimes overlooked by researchers, with few psychological instruments to reliably assess these constructs. Given the peculiarities of each chronic condition, different instruments could be developed for specific clinical conditions. Asthma is a chronic and often debilitating inflammatory disease affecting almost 10 billion people in the European Union, with a prevalence estimated at around 8.2%. 5 It is characterized by recurrent attacks of breathlessness and wheezing, variable expiratory airflow limitation, chronic airway inflammation, and airway hyperresponsiveness. 6 The unpredictability nature of this disease may lead to a variety of psychological reactions, including fear and anxiety. 7 For that reason, a certain understanding of the illness can provide a certain sense of control, which in turn promotes an empowering effect. 8 Despite the importance of illness perception in asthma, it has been only preliminarily explored, 9 mostly focusing on the effect that emotional representations have on treatment adherence and self-management. 10 The placebo/nocebo effects have been known for a long time to be relevant for people with asthma. For example, in 1956 -Abstract Truncated-
immunology,allergy,respiratory system