Abstract:The relationship between investment and cash flow has been a subject of considerable empirical debate. In this paper, our aim is to shed a new light on this relationship. It is argued that a firm’s observed investment and financing decisions are endogenous, in an ex-post behavioral sense, and that, therefore, investment-cash flow sensitivity (when estimated in a reduced-form, linear investment equation) is likely to be an ambiguous, and possibly misleading, measure of (current and expected future) financial constraints. Empirical evidence is provided in support of our case, based on a two-stage estimation strategy. In the first stage, allowance is made for unobserved firm heterogeneity as related to cash flow; we generalize the Q-investment equation and estimate individual, firm-specific investment-cash flow sensitivities by applying an entropy-based fixed-effect estimator. In the second stage, we look inside the black box and investigate how and to what extent these sensitivities are “driven” by important underlying factors. A number of striking ceteris-paribus results emerge: a) investment-cash flow sensitivity is monotonically decreasing in the level of cash flow; b) cutting back on investment, hoarding more cash, taking less on debt, building up debt capacity, and paying low or zero dividends (actions that are typically associated with the presence of tighter financial constraints) tend to produce a smaller value of investment-cash flow sensitivity; c) investment-cash flow sensitivity is negatively related to cash-flow volatility and positively related to investment volatility; and d) firm size and asset tangibility do not contribute to explaining the variation in investment-cash flow sensitivities across firms. From these results, it follows that the relation between the investment-cash flow sensitivity’s magnitude and the degree of financial constraints is indeterminate a priori. While such results call into question conventional wisdom, they help to explain the many contradictory findings encountered in the literature.

Investment-Cash Flow Sensitivity and Financing Constraints: Study of Pakistani Business Group Firms

Innovation and Investment in High-Tech Firms in Financially Constrained Environment

Investment-Cash Flow Sensitivities, Credit Rationing and Financing Constraints

The Impact of Operating Cash Flows on Financial Stability of Commercial Banks: Evidence from Pakistan

Effect of family control on corporate financing decisions of firms: evidence from Pakistan

Debt Maturity Structure, Firm Value and Underinvestment Incentive - The Case of Pakistan

Investment-Cash Flow Sensitivities: Evidence from China Listed Real Estate Operating Companies

Measuring Financing Constraints Using Firm-Level Estimation of Investment-Cash Flow Sensitivities: A Bayesian Approach

Determinants of corporate cash holdings in tranquil and turbulent period: evidence from an emerging economy

Testing Financial Constraint Hypothesis of Investment in NEPSE Listed Companies

Do Investment-Cash Flow Sensitivities Measure Financial Constraints? New Evidence from Unpacking the Black Box

Analysis of Determinants of Debt Financing: A Case study of the Cement Industry of Pakistan

Investment Cash Flow Sensitivities Really Reflect Related Investment Decisions

ZMIJEWSKI Financial Distress Prediction Model and Its Predictability, A Case of Karachi Stock Exchange

An Empirical Analysis of Working Capital Management Attributes and Firm’s Profitability Evidence from the Textile Sector of Pakistan.

Corporate cash holdings and financial performance: moderating effect of corporate governance and family ownership

The Effect of Working Capital Management on The Profitability of the Textile Industry: Evidence from Pakistan Textile Industry

Financial Indicators and Corporate Financial Distress Prediction in Context of Pakistan: A Systemic Review.

Current Asset Management as the driver of financial efficiency in Textile Industry of Pakistan

Asymmetrically Timely Loss Recognition and the Accrual Anomaly: Evidence From Pakistan’s Non-financial Sectors

Corporate risk-taking, financial constraints and cash holdings: evidence from Saudi Arabia