Abstract:Urban plans that will shape the city's future should include sustainable transportation systems so that it becomes a livable city. Today, delimiting individual transportation and increasing the share of mass transit play an essential role in planning a sustainable urban transportation system. Several practices can be utilized for attracting private car users into public transportation. Among these practices, park-and-ride application precedes because it provides significant benefits in sustainable transport. Therefore, city planning should be considered together with parking lot areas. In this evaluation, it would be more appropriate to use multiple-criteria decision methods (MCDMs) such as analytical hierarchy process (AHP) and analytical network process (ANP) instead of cost–benefit analysis (CBA) that focuses only on costs and revenues. Therefore, it is not accurate to evaluate the park-and-ride application in cities only according to the monetized criteria by CBA, because there are severe problems in monetizing negativities such as traffic congestion, loss of time, and harmful environmental effects arising from the city's structure. For this reason, it was thought that it would be more accurate to make a multiple-criteria evaluation with methods such as AHP and ANP for the park-and-ride application. In addition, using multiple criteria decision-making methods will positively increase the effects of urban planning on the city. In this direction, a new approach to the subject is presented in our study. In this study, the park-and-ride system and other applicable scenarios have been evaluated in the city of Eskisehir with both AHP and ANP methods by taking expert views. In this respect, the study shows differences from the previous studies on this subject. The alternatives evaluated in the study comprise the Protection of the Current Situation, the Introduction of Only Restrictive Factors, and the Park-and-Ride Implementation. As a result, in applying both methods, the overall relative priority values of alternatives were calculated and found to be the highest in the case of Park-and-Ride Implementation. Therefore, the park-and-ride application came forward in both methods. In this regard, the results obtained are consistent. From this study, it was determined that the park-and-ride application ensured a clear superiority compared with other alternatives. This study provides a general framework for the park-and-ride application in medium-sized cities whose centers are congested and attract many passengers in developing countries. Although it seems that an application has been made for the city of Eskisehir, the study also contains general characteristics.

Sustainable Public Transportation System Evaluation: A Novel Two-Stage Hybrid Method Based on IVIF-AHP and CODAS

Evaluation and Optimization of Public Transport Subsidies for Alternative Energy

A Simulation-Based Approach for Sustainable Transportation Systems Evaluation and Optimization: Theory, Systematic Framework and Applications

Evaluating public transport service quality using picture fuzzy analytic hierarchy process and linear assignment model

Evaluation of Park-and-Ride Application with AHP and ANP Methods for the City of Eskisehir, Turkey

Interval valued intuitionistic fuzzy AHP-WASPAS based public transportation service quality evaluation by a new extension of SERVQUAL Model: P-SERVQUAL 4.0

Sustainable Development Solutions of Public Transportation:An Integrated IMF SWARA and Fuzzy Bonferroni Operator

Evaluation of Traffic Congestion Degree: an Integrated Approach.

Public transportation business model evaluation with Spherical and Intuitionistic Fuzzy AHP and sensitivity analysis

Comprehensive Evaluation Method of Regular Transit System in Small and Medium-sized Cities

Evaluating Performance of Public Transport Networks by Using Public Transport Criteria Matrix Analytic Hierarchy Process Models—Case Study of Stonnington, Bayswater, and Cockburn Public Transport Network

Electric Bus Selection with Multicriteria Decision Analysis for Green Transportation

A new type-2 fuzzy multi-criteria hybrid method for rail transit operation safety assessment

A Unified Approach to Evaluation and Routing in Public Transport Systems

Identification of key performance indicators using hybrid COPRAS-TOPSIS for urban public transit systems by evaluating with AHP and FAHP

A hybrid approach of fuzzy risk assessment-based incenter of centroid and MCDM methods for multimodal transportation route selection

A Proposed Service Level Improvement Methodology for Public Transportation Using Interval Type-2 Fuzzy EDAS Based on Customer Satisfaction Data

An integrated decision support system to achieve sustainable development in transportation routes with traffic flow

Intermodal travel planning and decision support integrated with transportation and energy systems

A Comparative Study Between Advanced and Traditional Public Transportation System Using Visualized Simulation

Fuzzy PROMETHEE model for public transport mode choice analysis