Abstract:A dairy farm's ability to generate positive profit is dependent on the cow's response to management decisions made in conjunction with input cost management. Therefore, farm managers consider a multifaceted set of choices, managing their herd not as a homogeneous group of animals, but justifying the influence of individual cows on the farm's financial performance. We combined cow-level performance records from Minnesota DHIA and farm-level financials from the University of Minnesota Center for Farm Financial Management database FINBIN (https://finbin.umn.edu/) from 2012 to 2018 to evaluate farm- and cow-level profitability. The objective of this study was to evaluate individual cow performance matched with farm-level input expenses allocated to the cow level to measure a dairy farm's ability to be profitable over time, considering input and milk price fluctuations. Conventional Minnesota dairy farms were divided into 2 groups-financially resilient and non-resilient-based on their adjusted net farm income ratio over time. Yearly farm-level expenses and revenues were allocated to cows based on performance measures provided in monthly DHIA test data, and a cumulative lifetime break-even was calculated for all cows with consecutive farm data from 2012 to 2018. Herd-level and cow-level characteristics were analyzed to test for statistical difference between resilient and non-resilient farms as well as cows who achieved their break-even versus those that did not for resilient and non-resilient farms. Results showed that resilient farms had statistically different and lower expenses than non-resilient farms, with lower heifer raising expenses ($1,839.32 vs. $1,886.20), lifetime feed expenses ($4,197.07 vs. $4,975.39), and lifetime non-feed expenses ($2,761.63 vs. $4,502.67). Resilient farms had 38.3% of cows reach break-even, whereas non-resilient farms had 25.2% of cows break even. On average, cows who achieved their break-even remained in the herd for approximately 1 yr longer for both resilient farms (1,011 d for cows who break even and 627 d for those that do not) and non-resilient farms (1,033 d for cows who break even and 683 d for those that do not). Cows on resilient farms who achieved their lifetime break-even had an average lifetime profit of $1,613.48, which was $3,095.10 higher than the lifetime profit of -$1,481.62 of cows who never reach their break-even. Cows who reached their break-even on non-resilient farms had a lifetime profit of $1,270.51, which was $3,854.11 higher than the lifetime profit of -$2,583.60 for those who did not break even. Therefore, financially resilient dairy farms were utilizing a low-input, low-output model that proved to be successful and resulted in maintained profitability across volatile and fluctuating commodity prices.

What Makes an Organic Dairy Farm Profitable in the United States? Evidence from 10 Years of Farm Level Data in Vermont

The economic implications of organic farming

Revenue efficiency, profitability, and profitability potential on organic versus conventional dairy farms—results from comparable groups of farms

Benchmarking upper midwest dairy farm profitability

Links between profitability, nitrogen surplus, greenhouse gas emissions, and energy intensity on organic and conventional dairy farms

An analysis of operating profit margin: a valuable tool for New Zealand dairy farmers

The contribution of organic farming to rural development: An exploration of the socio-economic linkages of organic and non-organic farms in England

Dairy Farm Management and Long-Term Farm Financial Performance

Conversion to Organic Farming in the Continental United States: A Geographically Weighted Regression Analysis

Farm business financial performance in local foods value chains

Production Costs of Organic Vegetable Farms: Two Case Studies from Pennsylvania

Financial competitiveness of organic agriculture on a global scale

Risk factors for clinical mastitis, ketosis, and pneumonia in dairy cattle on organic and small conventional farms in the United States

Estimation and analysis of cow-level cumulative lifetime break-even on financial resiliency

A Study on Scale Benefit of US Dairies Milk Production

Meeting Breeding Potential in Organic and Low-Input Dairy Farming

Factors Related to Profitability of Agritourism in the United States: Results from a National Survey of Operators

Assessment of the Relations for Determining the Profitability of Dairy Farms, A Premise of Their Economic Sustainability

Feed autonomy in organic cattle farming systems: a necessary but not sufficient lever to be activated for economic efficiency

Organic farming in the United States: Principles and perspectives

Effect of yield and price risk on conversion from conventional to organic farming