Abstract:Overcapacity of specific industries, such as steel and coal, has been viewed as one of the most important and extensively discussed economic issues of China. The main feature of overcapacity is a massive amount of idling capacity, often considered to be a sub-optimal situation. The overcapacity of the steel industry is also closely related to low export price. Therefore, it turns out to be the most common fuse of trade disputes between China and developed economies, such as the U. S. and European Union. Since the late 1990s, the Chinese government has initiated five rounds of policies aiming to tackle with overcapacity. However, overcapacity keeps emerging periodically for some specific industries despite government's efforts. Since 2012, reducing overcapacity of particular industries has been listed as one of the primary economic goals of the Chinese government. By definition, overcapacity is a low level of capacity utilization. Therefore, the key to understanding overcapacity is to precisely measure capacity utilization rate. However, current methods of measurement, such as data envelopment analysis and stochastic production frontiers, are far from satisfaction because of either the concepts they use to define overcapacity or their underlying assumptions. Based on the definition of Greenwood et al. (1988 ) and the conceptual framework of Ackerberg et al. (2015) , we develop a new method to measure capacity utilization rate. We define the capacity utilization rate as capital utilization intensity and incorporate flexible capacity utilization rate into the production function estimation framework. Our underlying assumption is that higher capacity utilization leads to higher depreciation rate of capital. Thus, we can use capital depreciation rate as a proxy variable to estimate capacity utilization rate and total productivity factor simultaneously. Our method requires weaker assumptions, offers a more precise and intuitive characterization of overcapacity, and is more amenable to various extensions. Empirically, we apply our method to Chinese Industrial Enterprise Database. Collected and maintained by the National Bureau of Statistics, the database provides the most comprehensive micro-level information of Chinese industrial firms. It contains information on depreciation as well as inputs and outputs information for production function estimation. We estimate the capacity utilization rate and total factor productivity of Chinese industrial firms from 1998 to 2007 and from 2011 to 2013. Our results show that ignoring flexible capacity utilization would overestimate the elasticity of labor input on output and underestimate the elasticity of capital input. For most industries, this will lead to underestimation of firm-level productivity. Our results suggest that productivity of Chinese industrial firms has increased in the sample period. Compared with estimates of previous methods of capacity utilization, our estimates are much closer to the estimates obtained via direct investigation and more consistent with the macroeconomic background. Chinese industrial firms experienced an overall rise in capacity utilization rate from 1998 to 2007 and a drop around 2012. We also explored the variations in capacity utilization across firms. Firms with higher productivity, lower capital intensity, higher export intensity and profit ratio are associated with higher capacity utilization rate. Foreign-owned firms have the highest capacity utilization while state-owned enterprises have the lowest. We also observe substantial regional variations in capacity utilization across provinces. The policy implication of the results is that to tackle with overcapacity efficiently, policymakers should take into account the heterogeneity of overcapacity along different dimensions. The most important contribution of this paper lies in developing a new method of capacity utilization and utilization-adjusted total productivity factor. There are still a lot of controversies on the causes of and solutions to China's overcapacity problem. This paper tries to offer a benchmark framework to understand all these issues. We also provide some tentative and descriptive evidence to explore the variations in capacity utilization. Future research agenda concerning the mechanisms that give rise to overcapacity and the evaluation of related policies could be carried out based on the estimation strategy and results of this paper.

Decomposing capacity utilization under carbon dioxide emissions reduction constraints in data envelopment analysis: An application to Chinese regions

A study of the impact of de-capacity policies on industry capacity utilization paths: Evidence from the Chinese steel industry

Decomposing the Change of CO2 Emissions: A Joint Production Theoretical Approach

Exploring the Changes of Carbon Emissions Performance Using Data Envelopment Analysis

Exploring the drivers to energy-related carbon emissions changes at China’s provincial levels

Analysis and Evaluation of the Regional Characteristics of Carbon Emission Efficiency for China

The Driving Forces of Carbon Emissions in Consideration of Technical Efficiency

Economic Development and Carbon Dioxide Emissions in China: Provincial Panel Data Analysis

Carbon Efficiency and Abatement Cost of China's Coal-Fired Power Plants

Decomposition of China's Carbon Emissions Responsibility from the Perspective of Technological Heterogeneity

Temporospatial pattern of carbon emission efficiency of China’s energy-intensive industries and its policy implications

Decomposing CO2 emission changes in thermal power sector: A modified production-theoretical approach

A Study of Carbon Dioxide Emissions Performance of China's Transport Sector

A Decomposition Model and Reduction Approaches for Carbon Dioxide Emissions in China

Centralized carbon emission abatement (CEA) allocation based on non-separation using data envelopment analysis: an observation of regional highway transportation systems in China

Multiregional Input-Output Analysis of Spatial-Temporal Evolution Driving Force for Carbon Emissions Embodied in Interprovincial Trade and Optimization Policies: Case Study of Northeast Industrial District in China.

Regional Differences Between the Rate of Change of CO2 Emission Intensity of Chinese Provinces and Implications for Sustainable Development

Capacity Utilization Rate Measurement and Productivity Estimation for Industrial Firms

China's Transportation Sector Carbon Dioxide Emissions Efficiency and Its Influencing Factors Based on the EBM DEA Model with Undesirable Outputs and Spatial Durbin Model

Clarifying the “gains” and “losses” of transport climate mitigation in China from technology and efficiency perspectives

Decomposition and prediction of China's carbon emission intensity towards carbon neutrality: From perspectives of national, regional and sectoral level