Abstract:Context Educational reform efforts have taken the form of different school models intended to reduce educational inequality. Personalized, interest-based schools and academically focused, “No Excuses” schools are two leading small-school designs with sharply contrasting approaches to innovation. Given mixed research findings about the successes and challenges of school reform models in the United States, it is imperative to understand how educational outcomes of students relate to the philosophy and distinguishing characteristics of particular school models such as these. At the same time, evaluating social mobility effects of high school education across educational reform models requires examination of common metrics such as high school graduation rate and college entrance and degree attainment. Purpose This study sought to establish whether and how a personalized, interest-based secondary school reform model is associated with graduates’ characteristics and postsecondary outcomes—and to place these findings in relation to student outcomes reported by a leading No Excuses school network. Setting Big Picture Learning is a network of innovative small schools that serves primarily low-income and minoritized students through an individualized, relational, real-world-based high school experience. The Big Picture educational model features individualized learning plans connected to extensive internships, independent learning organized around student interests, authentic assessments, and close, informal relationships between students and adults. Research Design The Big Picture Longitudinal Study tracked 1900 graduates from six graduating high school classes. Data sources included student and school advisor surveys, National Student Clearinghouse college enrollment data, and interviews with graduates’ former advisors. Published outcomes data for KIPP No Excuses schools provided comparative information. Analyses comprised descriptive statistics of survey data and multivariate regression analyses connecting high school exit data to college outcomes. Findings The Big Picture Learning model is extremely successful in meeting its stated goals of fostering positive relationships, helping students discover and pursue their interests, and promoting high school graduation and college entrance. Results for academic subject achievement and college persistence are mixed, however. Big Picture graduates have similar college matriculation rates but somewhat lower six-year graduation rates than alumni from the KIPP No Excuses school network. Alumni from both networks show high rates of college attrition. Conclusion When taken alone and in context of other innovative school models, the Big Picture results point to the difficulty of sustaining secondary school gains in the post-high school lives of low-income students and highlight shortcomings of traditional colleges in serving this population.

Measuring life skills, hope, and academic growth at project-based learning schools

Enhancing College Students’ Life Skills through Project Based Learning

Postsecondary Outcomes of Innovative High Schools: The Big Picture Longitudinal Study

Improving Science Achievement—Is It Possible? Evaluating the Efficacy of a High School Chemistry and Physics Project-Based Learning Intervention

Assessing the Effect of Project-Based Learning on Science Learning in Elementary Schools

Supporting the students most in need: Academic self-efficacy and perceived teacher support in relation to within-year academic growth

Putting PjBL to the Test: The Impact of Project-Based Learning on Second Graders’ Social Studies and Literacy Learning and Motivation in Low-SES School Settings

The Effects of Project-Based Learning on Students' Scientific Reasoning Abilities and Credibility : A Teachers' Perspective

Measuring LEND Core Competencies Using Trainee Follow-Up Surveys

Do Books Make a Difference? The Effects of an Indigo Love of Reading Foundation Grant and Teacher Professional Learning on Motivation for Reading in a Middle School

Effect of project‐based learning on high school students' state‐mandated, standardized math and science exam performance

A case study of student development across project-based learning units in middle school chemistry

Fostering the skills of critical thinking and question-posing in a project-based learning environment

Teacher-student support, effortful engagement, and achievement: A 3-year longitudinal study.

Redesigning the Core Literacy Block: A Two-Year Evaluation Study

"Thanks for helping me find my enthusiasm for physics!" The lasting impacts "research in schools" projects can have on students, teachers, and schools

A Social Gradient in the Effects of the Skills for Life Program on Self-Efficacy and Mental Wellbeing of Adolescent Students

Effectiveness of project-based mathematics in first-year high school in terms of learning environment and student outcomes

Schoolwork With Purpose: A Mixed Methods Study on Youths' Perspective on What Makes Learning Meaningful

Examining Use of the Schoolwide Expectations Survey for Specific Settings to Build Expectation Matrices: A Pilot Study

Parental Self-Efficacy in Helping Children Succeed in School Favors Math Achievement