Instability Resistance Training improves Working Memory, Processing Speed and Response Inhibition in Healthy Older Adults: A Double-Blinded Randomised Controlled Trial

Nils Eckardt,Claudia Braun,Armin Kibele

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-020-59105-0

IF: 4.6

2020-02-13

Scientific Reports

Abstract:Abstract Aging is associated with declines in physical and cognitive performance. While there is no doubt about beneficial effects of physical exercise on proxies of strength and balance, the overall evidence for positive effects of resistance and balance training on executive functions is rather inconsistent. Whether the simultaneous exercising of strength and balance, i.e., instability resistance training, promotes executive functions in older adults is unknown. In the present trial, we tested the effects of unstable vs. stable resistance training on executive functions. Sixty-eight healthy older adults aged 65–79 years were randomly assigned to either an instability free-weight resistance training or one of two stable machine-based resistance training programs. Each group exercised twice a week on non-consecutive days for 10 weeks. Four tests to evaluate specific domains of executive functions were administered prior and following training: working memory, processing speed, response inhibition and set-shifting. The instability resistance training group improved working memory, processing speed and response inhibition from pre to post-test. In contrast, we found no improvements in executive functions for both stable resistance training groups. Our results demonstrate that 10 weeks of instability resistance training suffice to improve executive functions in older adults.

multidisciplinary sciences

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is to explore the difference in the effect on improving the executive function of the elderly between instability free - weight resistance training (I - FRT) and traditional stable machine - based resistance training (S - MRT). Specifically, the researchers want to verify the following two hypotheses:

1. **Whether a multi - component challenging exercise pattern (i.e., instability resistance training) can exceed the influence of less challenging stable machine - based resistance training on the executive function of healthy elderly people**. The researchers hope to determine whether the former can more effectively improve the working memory, processing speed and response inhibition ability of the elderly by comparing the effects of instability free - weight resistance training and stable machine - based resistance training.

2. **Whether there are differences between two different stable training patterns**. The researchers hope to verify whether the "instability" feature plays a key role in improving the executive function of the elderly by comparing two different stable training patterns (S - MRT and S - MRTHIP).

To verify these hypotheses, the researchers designed a double - blind randomized controlled trial and randomly assigned 68 healthy elderly people aged between 65 and 79 years to three groups: the instability free - weight resistance training group, the stable machine - based resistance training group and the stable machine - hip training group. Each group trained twice a week for 10 weeks. The executive function in specific areas was evaluated through four tests (working memory, processing speed, response inhibition and switching tasks), and the tests were carried out before and after training respectively.

The research results show that the instability free - weight resistance training group has significant improvements in working memory, processing speed and response inhibition, while the two stable training groups do not show similar improvements. This supports the first hypothesis, that is, instability resistance training can more effectively improve the executive function of the elderly. For the second hypothesis, the research results also confirm that there is no significant difference between the two stable training groups, further supporting the importance of the "instability" feature in improving the executive function.

In conclusion, this study provides evidence that 10 weeks of instability free - weight resistance training can effectively improve the executive function of the elderly, and high - load training is not a necessary condition for improving these functions. This finding is of great significance for promoting the cognitive health of the elderly.