Abstract:Background: The conversational speech of most children can be understood by people outside the family by the time they reach 4 years. However, for some children, speech sound disorders (SSDs) persist into their early school years, and beyond, despite adequate hearing, oromotor function, and language learning opportunities. One explanation for children's SSDs are domain-general cognitive-linguistic deficits that impair the child's ability to correctly derive rules governing how speech sounds legally combine to form words in a specific language. Aims: To explore whether there are differences in performance on executive function tasks between children who make speech errors characteristic of phonological delay and those who make speech errors characteristic of phonological disorder. Methods & procedures: Twenty-six children aged from 3;6 to 5;2 (13 with phonological delay and 13 with phonological disorder), matched pairwise for age and sex (nine males), were assessed on tasks measuring cognitive flexibility (rule abstraction and cognitive shift) and phonological working memory. Outcome & results: For the cognitive flexibility tasks, the performance of children with phonological delay was significantly better than that for children with phonological disorder, but there were no group differences for the phonological working memory task. Conclusions & implications: Children with phonological disorders might benefit from intervention programmes that incorporate training in cognitive flexibility. What is already known on the subject: Children with phonological delay and phonological disorder comprise the two largest SSD subgroups that present to speech-language therapy clinics. Evidence suggests domain-general cognitive processes (e.g., phonological working memory, ability to revise faulty underlying representations, rule abstraction, and cognitive shift) influence phonological development. Differences between the two subgroups in the types of speech errors, linguistic abilities, developmental trajectories, and responses to intervention have been reported, yet little is known about the underlying cognitive-linguistic deficits. What this paper adds to existing knowledge: The results of this study suggest that children with phonological delay and phonological disorder have distinct patterns of performance on executive function tasks: Children with phonological disorder showed deficits in domain general rule-abstraction and cognitive shift when compared to children with phonological delay. WHAT ARE THE POTENTIAL OR ACTUAL CLINICAL IMPLICATIONS OF THIS WORK?: The findings draw attention to: (1) the importance of differential diagnosis of phonological delay and phonological disorder; (2) the role of domain-general cognitive processes in explaining why children make particular types of errors; and (3) the need to develop innovative and tailored intervention techniques that target specific underlying deficits.

A longitudinal investigation of the double dissociation between reading and spelling deficits: the role of linguistic and executive function skills

Development of Phonological and Orthographic Skill: A 2-Year Longitudinal Study of Dyslexic Children

Spelling development of children with and without reading difficulties throughout elementary grades: evidence from the Greek orthography

Tracking reading skills and reading-related skills in dyslexia before (age 5) and after (ages 10–17) diagnosis

Reading profiles in secondary school: concurrent language and cognitive abilities, and retrospective and prospective reading skills

Longitudinal relations between verbal working memory and reading in students from diverse linguistic backgrounds

Exploring the Underpinnings and Longitudinal Associations of Word Reading and Word Spelling: A 2-Year Longitudinal Study of Hong Kong Chinese Children Transitioning to Primary School

A Three-Year Longitudinal Study Of Reading And Spelling Difficulty In Chinese Developmental Dyslexia: The Matter Of Morphological Awareness

Differentiating phonological delay from phonological disorder: Executive function performance in preschoolers

Division of Labor Between Phonology and Semantics During Reading and Spelling in Chinese Children with Developmental Dyslexia

The Relationship of Character Reading and Spelling: A Longitudinal Study in Chinese

Executive functioning and spoken language skills in young children with hearing aids and cochlear implants: Longitudinal findings

Predicting reading ability in teenagers who are deaf or hard of hearing: A longitudinal analysis of language and reading

Testing mechanisms underlying children's reading development: The power of learning lexical representations

Developmental Outcomes for Children at High Risk of Dyslexia and Children With Developmental Language Disorder

Exploring spelling ability in school-aged children with literacy learning difficulties using data collected in a clinical setting

A Longitudinal Study of Early Reading Development: Letter-Sound Knowledge, Phoneme Awareness and RAN, but Not Letter-Sound Integration, Predict Variations in Reading Development

Reading strategies in Spanish developmental dyslexics

Examining the Word-Level Skill and Reading Comprehension Profiles of Adolescents With and Without Specific Learning Disabilities

Longitudinal Trajectories of Reading and Mathematics Achievement for Students With Learning Disabilities

Specific reading difficulties in Chinese, English, or both: longitudinal markers of phonological awareness, morphological awareness, and RAN in Hong Kong Chinese children.