Abstract:With environmental problems becoming severe, many firms, including HP, Huawei, and Apple are simultaneously implementing trade-in programs and advertising to stimulate market demand. Offering trade-in service by the manufacturer is a method of price discrimination by providing replacement consumers with a rebate when they purchase new products. With the recycled, used products, the manufacturer can benefit through a strict series—via a remanufacturing process. Although numerous literatures have investigated the pricing strategy and advertising decisions in the closed-loop supply chain (CLSC), to the best of our knowledge, there is little research that analyzes and compares the economic and social performance of these two marketing strategies. To fill this gap, we establish two supply chain models with two periods, namely, an advertisement model and a joint model, while the equilibrium purchasing behavior of the replacement consumers can be characterized under three conditions: (1) all of the replacement consumers purchasing new products (ATA); (2) partial replacement consumers purchasing (PTA); (3) no replacement consumers purchasing (NTA). These three conditions are decided by the numerous relationships of the parameters. Solving the optimal decisions of the manufacturer in both models, the critical value in the joint model is higher in the advertisement model, which indicates that developing the trade-in program can enhance the robustness of the business model. Furthermore, through numerical example, we find that the market demand in the joint model is higher than in the advertisement model, and the cost of marketing strategy in the joint model is lower in the advertisement model, which means that the efficiency of the marketing strategy is higher than the single marketing strategy. As a result, comparing the economic and social performance between the two models, we conclude that the advertisement elasticity of the market demand is the key factor of the manufacturer’s profits and total social welfare.

Joint Advertisement and Trade-In Marketing Strategy in Closed-Loop Supply Chain

Models for Closed-Loop Supply Chain with Trade-Ins

Promoting consumer returns in closed-loop supply chains under cap-and-trade regulation: A cooperative recycling advertising perspective

Dynamic Pricing in a Trade‐in Program with Replacement and New Customers

Impacts of selling models: Who should offer trade-in programs in e-commerce supply chains?

Autonomous trade-in strategy for retailer with market segmentation

Decision Making by Trade-In Programs in the E-Commerce Supply Chain, Considering Cash Rebate Strategies and Platform Services

Trade-in and resale in a platform supply chain: Manufacturer's choice of selling strategies

Trade-in Strategy and Competition Between Two Independent Remanufacturers

Pricing and strategy selection in a closed-loop supply chain under demand and return rate uncertainty

A Sustainable Closed-Loop Supply Chain Decision Mechanism in the Electronic Sector

Effects of double subsidies and consumers' acceptability of remanufactured products on a closed-loop supply chain with trade-in programs

Optimal Pricing Strategy and Government Consumption Subsidy Policy in Closed-Loop Supply Chain with Third-Party Remanufacturer

Optimal pricing decisions for closed-loop supply chain with different disposal responsibilities

Replacement program decision-making and remanufacturing model selection considering consumer segmentation

An Advance Selling Strategy with a Trade-in Program

Cooperative Promotion and Wholesale Price Discount Incentives in a Closed-Loop Supply Chain with Dynamic Returns

Pricing and Collection Rate Decisions in a Closed-Loop Supply Chain Considering Consumers’ Environmental Responsibility

Pricing and Collection Decisions of a Closed-Loop Supply Chain with Fuzzy Demand

Quality Choice for Product Recovery Considering a Trade-in Program and Third-Party Remanufacturing Competition

A Dynamic Analysis of a Green Closed-Loop Supply Chain with Different On-Line Platform Smart Recycling and Selling Models