Population aging, migration, and productivity in Europe

Guillaume Marois,Alain Bélanger,Wolfgang Lutz

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.1918988117

IF: 11.1

2020-03-23

Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences

Abstract:Significance Migration is one of the most controversial political topics in industrialized countries. One important aspect is population aging and the prospects of a shrinking labor force in case of low or no immigration. We address this aspect systematically through multidimensional microsimulations for all European Union (EU) member states. The outcome variables considered go beyond the conventional old-age dependency ratios by also studying labor-force dependency ratios and the introduced productivity-weighted labor-force dependency ratio. We consider a wide range of future migration scenarios differing by volume, educational selectivity of migrants, and labor market integration efforts. Combined with alternative scenarios of labor-force participation for the EU-born population, the findings provide scientific insights for future migration and labor policies in Europe.

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is: **How to alleviate the negative economic impacts brought by the aging population in Europe by changing immigration and labor participation rates**.

Specifically, the authors used a micro - simulation population projection model (CEPAM - Mic), considered 13 individual characteristics (including education, immigration - related variables, etc.), and constructed changes in future labor participation rates, the number of immigrants, their educational composition and integration speed under different scenarios. They studied the impacts of these changes on the following three dependency ratios:
1. **Traditional Age - Dependency Ratio (ADR)**: \[ \text{ADR}_t^c=\frac{\text{Pop}_{0 - 14,t}^c+\text{Pop}_{65+,t}^c}{\text{Pop}_{15 - 64,t}^c} \]
2. **Labor - Force Dependency Ratio (LFDR)**: \[ \text{LFDR}_t^c=\frac{I_t^c}{A_t^c} \]
3. **Productivity - Weighted Labor - Force Dependency Ratio (PWLFDR)**: \[ \text{PWLFDR}_t^c=\frac{I_t^c}{0.62\times L_A_t^c + 1\times M_A_t^c+1.66\times H_A_t^c} \]

Among them, \( I_t^c \) represents the economically inactive population, and \( L_A_t^c \), \( M_A_t^c \) and \( H_A_t^c \) represent the economically active populations with low, medium and high education levels respectively.

Through these analyses, the authors hope to answer the following key questions:
- **How do changes in immigration and labor participation rates affect dependency ratios?**
- **Which policies can effectively alleviate the economic burden brought by population aging?**
- **What are the impacts of different immigration policies and integration effects on future economic dependency ratios?**

The research results show that increasing the labor participation rate of the general population (such as the Swedish model) and combining selective immigration policies (such as the Canadian model) with efficient integration can significantly improve the economic dependency ratios. On the contrary, policies with a high volume of immigration but low education levels and unsuccessful integration will lead to an increase in dependency ratios. This highlights the importance of integration policies in high - immigration - volume scenarios.