A Computerized Frailty Assessment Tool at Points-of-Care: Development of a Standalone Electronic Comprehensive Geriatric Assessment/Frailty Index (eFI-CGA)

Katayoun Sepehri,McKenzie Sarah Braley,Betty Chinda,Macy Zou,Brandon Tang,Grace Park,Antonina Garm,Robert McDermid,Kenneth Rockwood,Xiaowei Song
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3389/fpubh.2020.00089
IF: 5.2
2020-03-31
Frontiers in Public Health
Abstract:<span><strong>Background:</strong> Frailty is characterized by loss of biological reserves and is associated with an increased risk of adverse health outcomes. Frailty can be operationalized using a Frailty Index (FI) based on the accumulation of health deficits; items under health evaluation in the well-established Comprehensive Geriatric Assessment (CGA) have been used to generate an FI-CGA. Traditionally, constructing the FI-CGA has relied on paper-based recording and manual data processing. As this can be time-consuming and error-prone, it limits widespread uptake of this proven type of frailty assessment. Here, we report the development of an electronic tool, the eFI-CGA, for use on personal computers by frontline healthcare providers, to collect CGA data and automate FI-CFA calculation. The ultimate goal is to support early identification and management of frailty at points-of-care, and make uptake in Electronic Medical Records (EMR) feasible and transparent.<strong>Methods:</strong> An electronic CGA (eCGA) form was implemented to operate on Microsoft's WinForms platform and coded using C# programming language. Users complete the eCGA form, from which items under the CGA evaluation are automatically retrieved and processed to output an eFI-CGA score. A user-friendly interface and secured data saving methods were implemented. The software was debugged and tested using systematically designed simulation data, addressing different logic, syntax, and application errors, and then tested with clinical assessment. The user manual and manual scoring were used as ground truth to compare eFI-CGA input and automated eFI score calculations. Frontline health-provider user feedback was incorporated to improve the end-user experience.<strong>Results:</strong> The Standalone eFI-CGA software tool was developed and optimized for use on personal computers. The user interface adapted the design of paper-based CGA form to facilitate familiarity for clinical users. Compared to known scores, the software tool generated eFI-CGA scores with 100% accuracy to four decimal places. The eFI-CGA allowed secure data storage and retrieval of multiple types, including user input, completed eCGA form, coded items, and calculated eFI-CGA scores. It also permitted recording of actions requiring clinical follow-up, facilitating care planning. Application bugs were identified and resolved at various stages of the implementation, resulting in efficient system performance.<strong>Discussion:</strong> Accurate, robust, and reliable computerized frailty assessments are needed to promote effective frailty assessment and management, as a key tool in health care systems facing up to frailty. Our research has enabled the delivery of the standalone eFI-CGA software technology to empower effective frailty assessment and management by various healthcare providers at points-of-care, facilitating integrated care of older adults.</span>
public, environmental & occupational health
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is: by developing an independent electronic comprehensive geriatric assessment / frailty index tool (eFI - CGA), to improve the efficiency and accuracy of frailty assessment at the point of care. Specifically, this study aims to: 1. **Design and implement an electronic CGA form**: Based on the widely - used traditional paper - based CGA form, design an electronic version to enable clinicians to complete the assessment conveniently. 2. **Ensure the accuracy, robustness and efficiency of eFI - CGA calculation**: Through automated processing and calculation, reduce the time and errors in manual recording and data processing. 3. **Optimize the user experience of the eFI - CGA software tool**: Make it easy to use in the clinical environment and easy to integrate into the electronic medical record system. ### Background Frailty is a state of decreased physiological reserve capacity, associated with multiple adverse health outcomes, such as increased hospitalization and mortality. Traditional frailty assessment methods rely on pen - and - paper recording and manual data processing, which are time - consuming and error - prone, limiting their wide application. Therefore, developing an electronic assessment tool can significantly improve the efficiency and accuracy of assessment. ### Methods Researchers developed an independent software tool named eFI - CGA, which can run on a personal computer and help front - line healthcare providers collect CGA data and automatically calculate eFI - CGA scores. The main technical details include: - **Operating system and platform**: The software runs on Microsoft Windows 2000 or later versions, and is developed using the C# programming language and the WinForms platform. - **User requirement analysis**: Ensure that the appearance of the electronic form is similar to that of the traditional paper - based CGA form so that clinicians are familiar with it. At the same time, provide multiple input controls (such as check boxes, radio buttons, text boxes and drop - down lists) to improve the accuracy and efficiency of data input. - **Clinical follow - up actions**: Allow marking items that require clinical follow - up and provide space for detailed recording. - **User interface design**: The software interface is divided into three pages, which are used for user agreement, basic information input, and CGA form filling and eFI - CGA calculation respectively. - **Dynamic user guidance**: Through color reminders, error messages and warning signs, help users complete the form correctly. - **eFI - CGA calculation**: Calculate the frailty index based on the deficit accumulation method, and ensure that the calculation is carried out only when at least 80% of the form fields are filled. - **Data storage**: Data is stored locally in CSV files to ensure data security and confidentiality. ### Results - **System input and output**: The software has successfully implemented all major functions, including preview, user manual, reset, save records and calculate eFI - CGA scores. - **Performance**: Through simulation tests and clinical tests, the software shows efficient and accurate performance, and can calculate eFI - CGA scores with 100% accuracy when rounded to four decimal places. - **Performance in terms of efficiency**: Time complexity analysis shows that the software has efficient performance in processing and calculating eFI - CGA. ### Discussion Accurate, reliable and efficient electronic frailty assessment tools are crucial for promoting effective frailty management and care. The eFI - CGA software tool developed in this study can help various healthcare providers conduct rapid and accurate frailty assessments at the point of care, thereby improving the comprehensive care of the elderly.