COVID-19 Pandemic Lessons for Agri-Food Systems Innovation
Christopher B. Barrett,Jessica Fanzo,Mario Herrero,Daniel Mason-D'Croz,Alexander Mathys,Philip Thornton,Stephen Wood,Tim G. Benton,Shenggen Fan,Late Lawson-Lartego,Rebecca Nelson,Jianbo Shen,Lindiwe Majele Sibanda
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1088/1748-9326/ac25b9
IF: 6.7
2021-01-01
Environmental Research Letters
Abstract:The COVID-19 pandemic provides both a warning about agri-food systems’ (AFS) functioning and an accelerator for AFS innovation. It revealed both the increasing frequency of extreme events and structural shortcomings with respect to access to healthy diets, equitable livelihoods, resilience, and climate and environmental sustainability challenges that pervade AFS worldwide (Barrett et al 2020). Return to prior state is both unlikely and undesirable. The central question is howwill AFSs transform in response to the pandemic and the conditions it revealed? The pandemic has shifted awareness and incentives in ways that have the capacity—but are not guaranteed—to prompt necessary, transformational AFS adaptation (Kates et al 2012, Bassett and Fogelman 2013). Will AFS transformation occur and, if so, who will benefit and who will bear the costs and risks? Drawing on a year-long global expert panel review (Barrett et al 2020) we summarize the evidence on AFS impacts of the pandemic and offer seven key lessons to guide adjustments to policies and practices. Massive AFS disruptions have been commonplace throughout history. Crop failures and livestock disease epidemics have caused agricultural supply shocks, natural disasters and conflict have disrupted local or regional supply chains, and price spikes driven by rapid demand growth—including in related markets, like for petroleum products— or speculative market behavior have been commonplace, even within the past two decades (Barrett 2013, Baldos and Hertel 2015, Lesk et al 2016, Davis et al 2021, Gomez et al 2021). The COVID-19-driven AFS shock is unusual because it originates primarily from a massive collapse and restructuring of food demand, one disproportionately impacting the food service sub-sector (e.g. restaurants, school cafeterias), coupled with shocks to labor availability at multiple agri-food value chain (AVC) entry points (figure 1). There was no major shock to primary production on farm, no infrastructure destruction, and no price spike. Primary agricultural production proved remarkably robust in 2020 despite modest-to-moderate supply-side disruptions in some countries, mainly due to labor supply and transport disruptions caused by government-imposed movement restrictions meant to slow disease transmission. The Food and Agriculture Organization (FAO) reports record global cereals harvests for 2020 (FAO 2021b). And despite food export bans imposed by at least 21 different national governments—mostly lasting only a few weeks—and massive shutdown of commercial passenger transportation, merchandise freight shipments proved remarkably resilient, especially in multinational firms’ global supply chains (Laborde et al 2020). The major AFS disruptions originated chiefly from the demand-side shock of workplace closures that affected 93% of the world’s workers as of early January 2021, resulting in historically unprecedented losses equivalent to 255 million full-time jobs, with disproportionately adverse impacts on the food service sector globally (ILO 2021). The combination of disease outbreaks and movement restrictions led to labor shortages at all nodes throughout the value chain (Aday and Aday 2020, Gruère and Brooks 2021). Survey data from >30 000 households in nine lowand middle-income countries (LMICs) reveal 68% reported income losses from the pandemic (Egger et al 2021). Income loss combined with a 22.5% increase in the FAO global food price index from the May 2020 low to January 2021—as supply growth was outpaced by demand growth, especially in China and for feedgrains such as maize (FAO 2021b)—together caused 45% of LMIC households to miss or reduce meals (Egger et al 2021). Even in high-income countries (HICs), demand for private and public food assistance rose as millions more people struggled to feed their families. Before the pandemic, more than three billion people worldwide could not afford a healthy diet (Bai et al 2020, FAO et al 2021); the UN estimates that in 2020 the number of people lacking access to adequate food increased by 320 million and the global prevalence of undernourishment increased by 1.5 percentage points (FAO 2021a). The populations most