Abstract:This study develops a quantitative analysis of the impact of the Canada-United States-Mexico Agreement (USMCA), as signed on 30 November 2018. The USMCA provides a major overhaul of the North American Free Trade Agreement (NAFTA) based largely on the Trans-Pacific Partnership (TPP) text, introducing only minor changes to market access, while intensifying trade and investment diversion, increasing uncertainty by weakening the institutional framework of the NAFTA, and seeking to change the net benefits of the NAFTA by shifting them towards the United States. The evaluation of the USMCA is developed using simulations on a computable general equilibrium (CGE) model, based on a dynamic specification of the Global Trade Analysis Project (GTAP) model, modified to directly represent goods and services trade conducted through foreign affiliates, as well as on a cross-border basis, and to reflect the impact of liberalization of FDI. The impact of the USMCA is assessed against a baseline that reflects an in-force NAFTA. These results can, however, be compared to the impacts of NAFTA lapsing to infer the difference between the USMCA and a “hard” NAFTA exit scenario.The policy shock generated by the USMCA is unusual in that it has little traditional tariff liberalization and has many features that promise to be restrictive of trade. We evaluate non-tariff measures based on the extent to which the USMCA reduces/increases the parties’ scores on indexes measuring restrictiveness of regimes for goods, services, and investment. For goods, we examine possible improvements upon the WTO Trade Facilitation Agreement (TFA) commitments as measured by the OECD’s Trade Facilitation Indicators (TFI). For services, we consider the liberalization implied by the services commitments evaluated on the basis of changes to the parties’ scores under the OECD’s Services Trade Restrictiveness Index (STRI). For investment, we consider the changes implied against the parties’ scores on the OECD’s Foreign Direct Investment Restrictiveness (FDIR) index. For services and investment, we consider the value of binding market access commitments. Major modelling challenges include quantifying the impact of the changes in the rules of origin for the automotive and textiles and apparel sectors, incorporating the implications of the USMCA regimes for intellectual property and the digital economy, and taking into account the heightened uncertainty about market access to the United States. An over-arching issue is how to treat the policy signals from the various linkages of the USMCA with other features of US trade policy, including the trade war with China, the restrictions on entry of asylum seekers through Mexico, and the implications for North American integration of the Trump Administration’s identification of national security with domestic re-industrialization.

Comprehensive Broiler Supply Chain Model with Vertical and Horizontal Linkages: Impact of US–China Trade War and USMCA

The Value of “made in USA”: Impact of Chinese Acquisition of a US Company on Consumer Willingness to Pay

The Value of "Made in USA": Impact of Chinese acquisition of a US Company on Consumer Willingness to Pay

Multi-product Exporters in US–China Trade War

Impacts of Agricultural Price Support Policy on Price Variability and Welfare: Evidence from China's Soybean Market

Price Transmission Analysis of the International Soybean Market in a Trade War Context

Product Adjustments of Multi-Product Exporters: Evidence from Us-China Trade War

Quantifying the USMCA

Linkage relationship between China and US futures market during trade friction: the case of soybean, soybean oil and soybean meal

Empirical analysis of US bilateral corn trade: Evidence from Japan, Mexico, China, South Korea, and the European Union

Trade Wars along the Global Value Chains

The impact of trade policy on soybean futures in China

Global and National Environmental Impacts of the US-China Trade War

The Impact of Tariffs on a Transnational Supply Chain under Different Power Structures in China

China's Food Supply Sources under Trade Conflict with the United States and Limited Domestic Land and Water Resources

COVID-19, supply chain disruption and China’s hog market: a dynamic analysis

The Influence of Sino-US Trade Friction on U.S. Soybean Export

Non-tariff and tariff impediments affecting spatial competition between the United States and Brazil for soybean shipments to China

Exploring the Impacts of Sino–US Trade Disruptions with a Multi-Regional CGE Model

The Global Value Chain and Welfare Effects of Tariffs—Counterfactual Analysis of Sino–US Economic and Trade Frictions

China's corn and biofuel policies and agricultural trade: Projections from an international agricultural commodity market model