Abstract:We explore conclusions a person draws from observing society when he allows for the possibility that individuals' outcomes are affected by group-level discrimination. Injecting a single non-classical assumption, that the agent is overconfident about himself, we explain key observed patterns in social beliefs, and make a number of additional predictions. First, the agent believes in discrimination against any group he is in more than an outsider does, capturing widely observed self-centered views of discrimination. Second, the more group memberships the agent shares with an individual, the more positively he evaluates the individual. This explains one of the most basic facts about social judgments, in-group bias, as well as "legitimizing myths" that justify an arbitrary social hierarchy through the perceived superiority of the privileged group. Third, biases are sensitive to how the agent divides society into groups when evaluating outcomes. This provides a reason why some ethnically charged questions should not be asked, as well as a potential channel for why nation-building policies might be effective. Fourth, giving the agent more accurate information about himself increases all his biases. Fifth, the agent is prone to substitute biases, implying that the introduction of a new outsider group to focus on creates biases against the new group but lowers biases vis a vis other groups. Sixth, there is a tendency for the agent to agree more with those in the same groups. As a microfoundation for our model, we provide an explanation for why an overconfident agent might allow for potential discrimination in evaluating outcomes, even when he initially did not conceive of this possibility.

The Psychology of Bias: From Data to Theory

The (Dis)unity of psychological (social) bias

Implicit Bias in Judicial Decision Making How It Affects Judgment and What Judges Can Do About It

Causal foundations of bias, disparity and fairness

On (Cognitive) Bias in School Psychology

The Bias of Individuals (in Crowds): Why Implicit Bias Is Probably a Noisily Measured Individual-Level Construct

Implicit bias in healthcare: clinical practice, research and decision making

Overconfidence and Prejudice

Illusory Essences: A Bias Holding Back Theorizing in Psychological Science

Algorithmic bias: on the implicit biases of social technology

Personal Values and Cognitive Biases

Impact of Biases in Big Data

Fantastic Biases (What are They) and Where to Find Them

A systemic approach to the psychology of racial bias within individuals and society

Understanding Bias in Machine Learning

An Unintentional, Robust, and Replicable Pro-Black Bias in Social Judgment

A Comprehensive Study on Bias in Artificial Intelligence Systems: Biased or Unbiased AI, That's the Question!

Implicit-Bias Remedies: Treating Discriminatory Bias as a Public-Health Problem

Bias and error in human judgment

Introduction to Causal Inference for Psychologists: Testable and Non-Testable Causal and Statistical Assumptions

Artificial mental phenomena: Psychophysics as a framework to detect perception biases in AI models