Revisiting Heuristics for Evaluating Player Experience in Different Gaming Platforms: A Multi-Modal Approach

Çakır Aker,Kerem Rızvanoğlu,Yavuz İnal

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-030-37643-7_6

2020-01-01

Abstract:The aim of the study was to adopt a multi-modal approach to analyze differences of player experience between PC and mobile platforms and identify methods which are effective for evaluating it. To achieve this goal, playability heuristics were employed along with usability evaluations, semi-structured interviews, and observations. 20 players were recruited for the empirical tests. The players were chosen from hardcore and mid-core gamers that have never played Plants vs Zombies game before. The results from the study indicated that the heuristic set was ineffective for analyzing different experiences between platforms when applied by itself, yet the player feedbacks proved to be invaluable for analyzing the experience differences. Interviews and player observations after gameplay sessions were contributive in offering an in-depth comprehension of different motivations of the players for both PC and mobile platforms. The dependencies of the playability problems addressed by the players were grouped into three categories. Fundamentally, different gaming platforms offer different experiences. Therefore, it is as crucial to understand the importance of platform differences as much as different games in terms of understanding player experience. By the grouping of these problems, it was possible to put forward a general classification of differences in experience between platforms. Additionally, we found that the implementation of usability evaluations proved to be effective and point towards a general difference in experience between platforms.