Vocal learning-associated convergent evolution in mammalian proteins and regulatory elements
Morgan E Wirthlin,Tobias A Schmid,Julie E Elie,Xiaomeng Zhang,Amanda Kowalczyk,Ruby Redlich,Varvara A Shvareva,Ashley Rakuljic,Maria B Ji,Ninad S Bhat,Irene M Kaplow,Daniel E Schäffer,Alyssa J Lawler,Andrew Z Wang,BaDoi N Phan,Siddharth Annaldasula,Ashley R Brown,Tianyu Lu,Byung Kook Lim,Eiman Azim,Nathan L Clark,Wynn K Meyer,Sergei L Kosakovsky Pond,Maria Chikina,Michael M Yartsev,Andreas R Pfenning,Gregory Andrews,Joel C Armstrong,Matteo Bianchi,Bruce W Birren,Kevin R Bredemeyer,Ana M Breit,Matthew J Christmas,Hiram Clawson,Joana Damas,Federica Di Palma,Mark Diekhans,Michael X Dong,Eduardo Eizirik,Kaili Fan,Cornelia Fanter,Nicole M Foley,Karin Forsberg-Nilsson,Carlos J Garcia,John Gatesy,Steven Gazal,Diane P Genereux,Linda Goodman,Jenna Grimshaw,Michaela K Halsey,Andrew J Harris,Glenn Hickey,Michael Hiller,Allyson G Hindle,Robert M Hubley,Graham M Hughes,Jeremy Johnson,David Juan,Irene M Kaplow,Elinor K Karlsson,Kathleen C Keough,Bogdan Kirilenko,Klaus-Peter Koepfli,Jennifer M Korstian,Amanda Kowalczyk,Sergey V Kozyrev,Alyssa J Lawler,Colleen Lawless,Thomas Lehmann,Danielle L Levesque,Harris A Lewin,Xue Li,Abigail Lind,Kerstin Lindblad-Toh,Ava Mackay-Smith,Voichita D Marinescu,Tomas Marques-Bonet,Victor C Mason,Jennifer R S Meadows,Wynn K Meyer,Jill E Moore,Lucas R Moreira,Diana D Moreno-Santillan,Kathleen M Morrill,Gerard Muntané,William J Murphy,Arcadi Navarro,Martin Nweeia,Sylvia Ortmann,Austin Osmanski,Benedict Paten,Nicole S Paulat,Andreas R Pfenning,BaDoi N Phan,Katherine S Pollard,Henry E Pratt,David A Ray,Steven K Reilly,Jeb R Rosen,Irina Ruf,Louise Ryan,Oliver A Ryder,Pardis C Sabeti,Daniel E Schäffer,Aitor Serres,Beth Shapiro,Arian F A Smit,Mark Springer,Chaitanya Srinivasan,Cynthia Steiner,Jessica M Storer,Kevin A M Sullivan,Patrick F Sullivan,Elisabeth Sundström,Megan A Supple,Ross Swofford,Joy-El Talbot,Emma Teeling,Jason Turner-Maier,Alejandro Valenzuela,Franziska Wagner,Ola Wallerman,Chao Wang,Juehan Wang,Zhiping Weng,Aryn P Wilder,Morgan E Wirthlin,James R Xue,Xiaomeng Zhang,Morgan E. Wirthlin,Tobias A. Schmid,Julie E. Elie,Varvara A. Shvareva,Maria B. Ji,Ninad S. Bhat,Irene M. Kaplow,Daniel E. Schäffer,Alyssa J. Lawler,Andrew Z. Wang,BaDoi N. Phan,Ashley R. Brown,Nathan L. Clark,Wynn K. Meyer,Michael M. Yartsev,Andreas R. Pfenning,Joel C. Armstrong,Bruce W. Birren,Kevin R. Bredemeyer,Ana M. Breit,Matthew J. Christmas,Michael X. Dong,Nicole M. Foley,Carlos J. Garcia,Diane P. Genereux,Michaela K. Halsey,Andrew J. Harris,Allyson G. Hindle,Robert M. Hubley,Graham M. Hughes,Irene M. Kaplow,Elinor K. Karlsson,Kathleen C. Keough,Jennifer M. Korstian,Sergey V. Kozyrev,Alyssa J. Lawler,Danielle L. Levesque,Harris A. Lewin,Voichita D. Marinescu,Victor C. Mason,Jennifer R. S. Meadows,Wynn K. Meyer,Jill E. Moore,Lucas R. Moreira,Diana D. Moreno-Santillan,Kathleen M. Morrill,William J. Murphy,Nicole S. Paulat,Andreas R. Pfenning,BaDoi N. Phan,Katherine S. Pollard,Henry E. Pratt,David A. Ray,Steven K. Reilly,Jeb R. Rosen,Oliver A. Ryder,Pardis C. Sabeti,Daniel E. Schäffer,Arian F. A. Smit,Jessica M. Storer,Kevin A. M. Sullivan,Patrick F. Sullivan,Megan A. Supple,Aryn P. Wilder,Morgan E. Wirthlin,James R. Xue,Zoonomia Consortium**
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1126/science.abn3263
IF: 56.9
2024-03-01
Science
Abstract:Vocal production learning is a convergently evolved trait in vertebrates. To identify brain genomic elements associated with mammalian vocal learning, we integrated genomic, anatomical and neurophysiological data from the Egyptian fruit-bat with analyses of the genomes of 215 placental mammals. First, we identified a set of proteins evolving more slowly in vocal learners. Then, we discovered a vocal-motor cortical region in the Egyptian fruit-bat, an emergent vocal learner, and leveraged that knowledge to identify active cis -regulatory elements in the motor cortex of vocal learners. Machine learning methods applied to motor cortex open chromatin revealed 50 enhancers robustly associated with vocal learning whose activity tended to be lower in vocal learners. Our research implicates convergent losses of motor cortex regulatory elements in mammalian vocal learning evolution.
multidisciplinary sciences