Abstract:Phenomenon: Professionalism is integral to the role of the physician. Most professionalism assessments in medical training are delayed until clinical rotations where multisource feedback is available. This leaves a gap in student assessment portfolios and potentially delays professional development. Approach: A total of 246 second-year medical students (2013-2015) completed self- and peer assessments of professional behaviors in 2 courses following a series of Team-Based Learning exercises. Correlation and regression analyses were used to examine the alignment or misalignment in the relationship between the 2 types of assessments. Four subgroups were formed based on observed patterns of initial self- and peer assessment alignment or misalignment, and subgroup membership stability over time was assessed. A missing data analysis examined differences between average peer assessment scores as a function of selective nonparticipation. Findings: Spearman correlation demonstrated moderate to strong correlation between self-assessments completed alone (no simultaneous peer assessment) and self-assessments completed at the time of peer assessments ( = .59, p < .0001) but weak correlation between the two self-assessments and peer assessments (alone: = .13, p < .013; at time of peer: = .21, p < .0001). Generalized estimating equation models revealed that self-assessments done alone (p < .0001) were a significant predictor of self-assessments done at the time of peer. Course was also a significant predictor (p = .01) of self-assessment scores done at the time of peer. Peer assessment score was not a significant predictor. Bhapkar's test revealed subgroup membership based on the relationship between self- and peer ratings was relatively stable across Time 1 and Time 2 assessments ((2) = 0.83, p = .84) for all but one subgroup; members of the subgroup with initially high self-assessment and low peer assessment were significantly more likely to move to a new classification at the second measurement. A missing data analysis revealed that students who completed all self-assessments had significantly higher average peer assessment ratings compared to students who completed one or no self-assessments with a difference of -0.32, 95% confidence interval [-0.48, -0.15]. Insights: Multiple measurements of simultaneous self- and peer assessment identified a subgroup of students who consistently rated themselves higher on professionalism attributes relative to the low ratings given by their peers. This subgroup of preclinical students, along with those who elected to not complete self-assessments, may be at risk for professionalism concerns. Use of this multisource feedback tool to measure perceptual stability of professionalism behaviors is a new approach that may assist with early identification of at-risk students during preclinical years.

Collaborative group testing increases intrinsic motivation but does not impact competition in medical students

High-Stakes Collaborative Testing: Why Not?

Caution with competitive gamification in medical education: unexpected results of a randomised cross-over study

Does participation in sports competitions enhance interprofessional teamwork among medical students? Evidence from a medical school curriculum experiment

Evaluation of the role of incentive structure on student participation and performance in active learning strategies: A comparison of case-based and team-based learning

Medical students' general and radiology-specific motivation: Correlations, stability and associations with learning strategies and ability beliefs

Test-reduced teaching for stimulation of intrinsic motivation (TRUST): a randomized controlled intervention study

Low intrinsic motivation but not GRIT is predictive of low performing medical students

Impact of Collaborative Testing on Academic Performance in Pharmacy Education

Surveying Undergraduate Medical Students' Motivational Orientations and Learning Strategies in the First and Last Year of Medical School

'Let's work together to pass medical school': a qualitative study of medical student attitudes to teamwork, competition and collaboration

Pre-Clinical Medical Students' Use of Motivational and Cognitive Study Strategies During Anatomy Learning: A Three-Year Cross-Sectional Survey.

Exploring the Situational Motivation of Medical Students Through Clinical Medicine Level Test: a Cross-Sectional Study.

Influence of learning strategies and motivation on anatomy test performance of undergraduate medical students

The Impact of Peer-Led Learning Groups on First-Year Medical Students

Intrinsic motivation in competition: The intervening role of four individual differences following objective competence information

A Novel Approach to Assessing Professionalism in Preclinical Medical Students Using Multisource Feedback Through Paired Self- and Peer Evaluations

A simulation-based curriculum to introduce key teamwork principles to entering medical students

Medical students’ motivation and academic performance: the mediating roles of self-efficacy and learning engagement

Stress and value: the student perspective on utilizing real vs. actor patients in objective structured clinical examinations

Motivation, learning strategies, participation and medical school performance