Study design factors influencing patients’ willingness to participate in clinical research: a randomised vignette-based study

Angèle Gayet-Ageron,Sandrine Rudaz,Thomas Perneger
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1186/s12874-020-00979-z
2020-04-26
BMC Medical Research Methodology
Abstract:Abstract Background High patient participation in clinical research reduces selection bias and ensures the generalizability of study findings. We explored study-related factors that may influence patients’ willingness to participate in research. Methods We submitted by mail two vignettes that described clinical research studies – a drug trial and a diagnostic study – to patients recently discharged from hospital and assessed their willingness to participate. We used a factorial design to randomly allocate three study attributes per vignette: in the drug trial, presumed superiority of new drug versus equipoise, public versus industry funding, and random versus non-random treatment allocation; in the diagnostic study, common versus rare disease, genetic versus protein analysis, and automatic reporting of results versus reporting on request. Results Of 2600 patients contacted, 1140 (44%) participated. Globally, willingness to participate in a drug trial was lower than in a diagnostic study (44.8% vs. 76.2%; P < 0.001). In the drug trial, participation was significantly higher when the new drug was presented as presumably better than the old (vs. equipoise) and when the study was funded by public sources (vs. industry), but was not affected by the allocation method. None of the factors tested in the diagnostic study was associated with participation. Conclusions Patients were more likely to participate in a hypothetical observational diagnostic study than in a hypothetical drug trial. Participation in the trial was lower when clinical equipoise was expressed and when the trial was funded by industry. These results suggest that some features of study design can influence participation.
health care sciences & services
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is to explore which research design factors may influence patients' willingness to participate in clinical research. Specifically, through a randomized case - study design, the research investigated patients' willingness to participate in two different types of clinical research (drug trials and diagnostic studies), and analyzed how specific research attributes (such as beliefs in the effectiveness of new drugs, sources of research funding, ways of allocating interventions, etc.) influence patients' participation decisions. The research aims to provide guidance for increasing the patient participation rate in clinical research, thereby reducing selection bias and ensuring the general applicability of research results.