The Relative Importance of Succession, Stand Age and Stand Factors on Carbon Allocation of Korean Pine Forests in the Northern Mt. Xiaoxing’anling, China

Xuemei Wang,Zhiwen Guo,Xin Guo,Xiangping Wang
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3390/f11050512
IF: 3.282
2020-05-02
Forests
Abstract:Exploring carbon allocation pattern and its influencing factors is of great significance for estimating the carbon sequestration rate and potential of forest ecosystems. Here, we investigate all carbon pool components (including above and belowground biomass of tree, shrub and herb layers, and dead biomass and soil carbon pools) in four successional stages of broad-leaved and Korean pine (Pinus koraiensis Siebold & Zucc.) mixed forests in Northeast China. We explore the change of allocation among carbon pools with succession and examine the relative importance of succession, stand age, and stand factors on carbon allocation pattern. Our results illustrate that above- and belowground vegetation carbon increase as maximum tree height increases. Below- to aboveground vegetation carbon ratio (R/S ratio) decreases significantly with succession and increases significantly as mean diameter at breast height (DBH) increases, but does not significantly correlate with stand age. With succession and increasing stand age, understory (shrub, herb) to tree carbon ratio (understory/tree ratio) and soil to vegetation carbon ratio (soil/vegetation ratio) decrease significantly. The joint effect of succession, stand age, and stand factors have the largest contribution on above- and belowground vegetation carbon and understory/tree ratio (26.83%, 27.93%, and 49.48% of variations explained, respectively). As for the pure effects, stand factors explain the largest proportion of variations in vegetation aboveground carbon (11.25%) and soil carbon (20.18%). Meanwhile, succession is the variable with the largest contribution to vegetation belowground carbon (12.64%), R/S ratio (21.83%), understory/tree ratio (25.84%), and soil/vegetation ratio (6.68%). Overall, these results suggest that species composition change during forest succession, instead of stand factors and stand age, is the main driver of forest vegetation carbon allocation. In contrast, stand factors play a major role in soil carbon allocation. Our findings suggest more studies to better understand the role of species composition (in addition to stand factors and age) on biomass allocation, and the influence of stand factors and litterfalls on soil carbon sequestration, which are critical to improve forest management strategies (e.g., adjustment of species composition and forest structure) to increase the future ability of forest carbon sequestration.
forestry
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The main problem that this paper attempts to solve is to explore the effects of forest succession, stand age and stand factors on the carbon allocation pattern in the Korean pine - broad - leaved mixed forest in the Xiaoxing'anling Mountains in Northeast China. Specifically, the study aims to answer two scientific questions: 1. **How does carbon storage allocation change with forest succession?** - By analyzing the components of carbon pools (vegetation, soil, dead biomass) at different succession stages, the study explored how the allocation pattern of carbon in each carbon pool changes with the succession stage. 2. **What are the relative importance of succession stage, stand age and stand structure on carbon storage and allocation?** - Through variance decomposition analysis, the study explored the individual and combined effects of succession stage, stand age and stand factors (such as average breast - height diameter, maximum breast - height diameter, average height, maximum height and stand density) on carbon storage and allocation. ### Main findings - **Changes in carbon storage and allocation patterns**: - With forest succession, vegetation carbon increased significantly, while soil carbon did not change significantly. In the early succession stage, soil carbon was approximately four times that of vegetation carbon, while in the late succession stage, they were almost equal. - The proportion of vegetation carbon in the total ecosystem carbon increased significantly, from 24% in the early stage to 51% in the late stage, while the proportion of soil carbon decreased significantly, from 76% to 48%. - Above - and below - ground vegetation carbon increased significantly with succession, while herbaceous plant carbon decreased significantly and shrub carbon did not change significantly. - **Effects of stand age and stand factors**: - Above - and below - ground vegetation carbon stocks were significantly positively correlated with stand age, while soil carbon stocks were negatively correlated with stand age. - The understory / canopy ratio and soil / vegetation ratio were significantly negatively correlated with stand age. - Above - ground vegetation carbon stocks were significantly positively correlated with maximum height and stand density, and below - ground vegetation carbon was significantly positively correlated with maximum height. - The root / crown ratio was significantly positively correlated with the average breast - height diameter, while the understory / canopy ratio was significantly negatively correlated with the maximum breast - height diameter and maximum height. - **Comprehensive effects of succession, stand age and stand factors**: - The combined effects of succession, stand age and stand factors contributed the most in explaining above - and below - ground vegetation carbon stocks, accounting for 26.83% and 27.93% respectively. - In terms of pure effects, stand factors had the strongest explanatory power for above - ground vegetation carbon stocks (11.25%), while succession had the strongest explanatory power for below - ground vegetation carbon stocks (12.64%). - Succession contributed the most to the root / crown ratio, understory / canopy ratio and soil / vegetation ratio, accounting for 21.83%, 25.84% and 6.68% respectively. ### Conclusion The research results show that the change of species composition plays a major driving role in vegetation carbon allocation during forest succession, and stand factors play an important role in soil carbon allocation. These findings are helpful to better understand the effects of species composition, stand factors and stand age on biomass allocation, so as to improve forest management strategies and enhance the forest carbon sink capacity.