Abstract:Human-autonomy collaboration plays a pivotal role in the development of Maritime autonomous surface ships (MASS), as Shore control center (SCC) operators may engage in the control loop by directly operating the MASS, or, in the supervisory loop, monitoring the MASS and taking over control when needed. Thus, efficient human performance during takeover control and operation is crucial for the safety of MASS operations. However, since the MASS is still in the early phase of development, the mechanism of human errors is unknown, and the data on human-autonomy collaborative operation is scarce. Human reliability analysis (HRA) aims to assess human errors qualitatively and quantitatively, and is widely used in various complex systems to help safety analysis. This study is dedicated to incorporating advanced HRA methods elements to identify and quantify human errors during taking over control and operation of a MASS in collision avoidance scenarios. It presents virtual experimental results, combined with theoretical human error identification and assessment methods. At first, we apply the Human-System Interaction in Autonomy (H-SIA) method to identify potential human errors; secondly, we identify relevant Performance Shaping Factors (PSFs) including Experience, Boredom, Task complexity, Available time and Pre-warning, and performance measures of the human errors, and implement them in the virtual experiment based on a full-scale autonomous ferry research vessel called milliAmpere2. Finally, we build a Bayesian Network (BN) to present causal and probabilistic relationships between PSFs and human errors through experimental data. The results show that available time has the highest impact on takeover performance of operators, followed by task complexity and pre-warning. Boredom does not present a significant sole impact unless combined with available time. Experience does not show a significant impact on human performance. In addition to the relevance of the human errors analysis to the safe development and operational design of MASS, the developed method benefits other human-autonomy collaborative systems. The developed BN model shows adaptability to assess human error probabilities, and the practical significance of integrating experimental data into the existing HRA methodologies for complex systems.

Bibliometric analysis of human factors in aviation accident using MKD

Analysis on coupling dynamic effect of human errors in aviation safety

Human Factors Analysis for Maritime Accidents Based on a Dynamic Fuzzy Bayesian Network

Analysis of Human Factors in Typical Accident Tests of Certain Type Flight Simulator

An audit-based prediction model for aviation maintenance safety

Human Factors Analysis of Air Traffic Safety Based on HFACS-BN Model

A Design Knowledge Management Model for Civil Aircraft Cabin Based on Markov Logic Networks

An information flow field model for human–machine interaction

Human error analysis of commercial aviation accidents: application of the Human Factors Analysis and Classification system (HFACS)

Probabilistic Framework for Quantifying Human Flight Failure Rate to Landslides

Routes to failure: Analysis of 41 civil aviation accidents from the Republic of China using the human factors analysis and classification system

Risk Analysis of Airplane Upsets in Flight: An Integrated System Framework and Analysis Methodology

Human Error Management in Aviation Maintenance using Hybrid FMEA with a Novel Fuzzy Approach

Intelligent Analysis Model for Civil Aviation Employees Safety Supervision Based on Knowledge Graph

A data-driven Bayesian network of management and organizational factors for human reliability analysis in the process industry

Shield Human Factors Taxonomy and Database for Learning from Aviation and Maritime Safety Occurrences

Flight safety assessment based on a modified human error risk quantification approach

Toward Safer Flight Training: The Data-Driven Modeling of Accident Risk Network Using Text Mining Based on Deep Learning

A Comparison of Rule-Based and Machine Learning Models for Classification of Human Factors Aviation Safety Event Reports

Analysis of human errors in Human-autonomy collaboration in autonomous ships operations through shore control experimental data

Assessment of piloting behavior impact on landing risk of transport aircraft