Lesbian and Gay Relationship Satisfaction Among Italians: Adult Attachment, Social Support, and Internalized Stigma

Massimiliano Sommantico,Santa Parrello,Barbara De Rosa
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10508-020-01736-5
2020-05-15
Archives of Sexual Behavior
Abstract:We examined adult attachment styles, perceived social support, internalized stigma, and relationship satisfaction in a sample of 305 lesbians (48.2%) and gay men (51.8%), ages 19–72 years (<i>M</i> = 36.4; SD = 11.8), and in a same-sex relationship for at least 6 months. Participants were recruited via the Internet and completed a web-based survey. We tested the hypotheses that attachment styles, perceived social support, and internalized stigma predicted relationship satisfaction, as well as that perceived social support would be correlated with internalized stigma. Results strongly supported the hypotheses, thus indicating that attachment styles, perceived support, and internalized stigma were negatively correlated with and predicted relationship satisfaction and that perceived social support was negatively correlated with internalized stigma. Furthermore, results indicated that lesbian participants had lower levels of anxious attachment style and reported higher levels of relationship satisfaction and lower levels of internalized stigma. Finally, results indicated that in the lesbian subsample, conservative political orientation and religious beliefs were correlated with higher levels of internalized stigma; participants coming from central Italy reported higher levels of perceived social support; and participants in civil unions reported higher levels of perceived social support and relationship satisfaction, and lower levels of internalized stigma. Implications for counselors and therapists working with lesbian and gay populations are discussed.
social sciences, interdisciplinary,psychology, clinical
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is to explore the relationships among adult attachment styles, perceived social support, internalized stigma and relationship satisfaction among gay and lesbian couples in Italy. Specifically, the study aims to evaluate how these factors influence the relationship quality of gay and lesbian couples and explore the differences among different groups (such as gender, political orientation, religious belief, residential area and relationship status). ### Research Background In Italy, although the attitude towards the gay and lesbian population has gradually become more open, there is still a certain degree of discrimination and social pressure. For example, a 2012 survey showed that although most respondents condemned discriminatory behavior against homosexuals, homosexuals still faced greater social prejudice in some professional fields (such as primary school teachers, politicians, doctors). In addition, homosexuals often encounter discrimination when looking for housing, obtaining medical services, interacting with neighbors, in the workplace, at school or university, and during the job - seeking process. Therefore, it is of great significance to understand the impact of these social pressures on the relationships of gay and lesbian couples. ### Research Questions The main purpose of this study is to test the following hypotheses: 1. **H1**: High levels of avoidance and anxiety are associated with lower relationship satisfaction. 2. **H2**: Relationship satisfaction is associated with higher perceived social support and lower internalized sexual orientation stigma. 3. **H3**: Perceived social support is associated with lower internalized sexual orientation stigma. 4. **H4**: Conservative political orientation and religious belief are associated with higher internalized sexual orientation stigma. 5. **H5**: Civil union is associated with lower internalized sexual orientation stigma and higher perceived social support and relationship satisfaction. 6. **H6**: Relationship status, attachment style, perceived social support and internalized stigma can predict relationship satisfaction. 7. **H7**: Higher levels of avoidance and anxiety will negatively affect relationship satisfaction; higher perceived social support will negatively affect internalized stigma and positively affect relationship satisfaction; higher internalized stigma will negatively affect perceived social support and relationship satisfaction. ### Methods The study recruited 305 homosexuals (48.2% of whom were lesbians and 51.8% were gay men) via the Internet, aged between 19 and 72 years, with an average age of 36.4 years and a standard deviation of 11.8 years. Participants completed questionnaires regarding attachment styles, perceived social support, internalized sexual orientation stigma and relationship satisfaction. ### Results 1. **Attachment Styles and Relationship Satisfaction**: The higher the levels of avoidance and anxiety, the lower the relationship satisfaction (r = - 0.54, - 0.32; p < 0.01), which supports H1. 2. **Perceived Social Support and Relationship Satisfaction**: The higher the perceived social support, the higher the relationship satisfaction (r = 0.37; p < 0.01), and the lower the internalized sexual orientation stigma, the higher the relationship satisfaction (r = - 0.47; p < 0.01), which supports H2. 3. **Perceived Social Support and Internalized Stigma**: Perceived social support is negatively correlated with internalized sexual orientation stigma (r = - 0.16; p < 0.01), especially family support has a higher correlation with internalized sexual orientation stigma, which partially supports H3. 4. **Gender Differences**: Lesbians had lower anxiety levels (F(1, 304) = 7.92, p < 0.01), higher relationship satisfaction (F(1, 304) = 20.66, p < 0.001), and lower internalized sexual orientation stigma (F(1, 304) = 4.81, p < 0.05). 5. **Residential Area Differences**: Participants from central Italy perceived higher social support and relationship satisfaction, while participants from southern Italy had higher internalized sexual orientation stigma. 6. **Relationship Status Differences**: Participants in civil unions perceived higher social support and relationship satisfaction, and had lower anxiety levels and internalized sexual orientation stigma, which supports H5. 7. **Political Orientation and Religious Belief**: Participants with liberal views had lower internalized sexual orientation stigma, and participants with religious beliefs had higher internalized sexual orientation stigma, which supports part of H4. ### Regression Analysis Through hierarchical regression analysis, it was found that age, gender, relationship status, adult attachment styles, perceived social support and internalized sexual orientation stigma together explained 55.4% of the variance in relationship satisfaction, and the adjusted R² was 54.4%. ### Conclusions This study reveals adult attachment styles, perceived social support...