Dynamic game strategies of a two-stage remanufacturing closed-loop supply chain considering Big Data marketing, technological innovation and overconfidence

Zehua Xiang,Minli Xu
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cie.2020.106538
2020-07-01
Abstract:In the "Internet+" era, involving third-party Internet recycling platforms (IRPs) has revolutionized the operation models of closed-loop supply chains (CLSCs) in China. This study explores the impact of technological innovation, Big Data marketing and overconfidence on supply chain member decision-making. We propose a two-stage remanufacturing CLSC dynamic model consisting of a manufacturer, an IRP, and a supplier based on differential game theory. By comparing the optimal decisions of each member in three scenarios, we find that the IRP's overconfident behavior is beneficial to both the manufacturer and the IRP but will damage the supplier's profit. Although a suitable cost-sharing ratio can enable the manufacturer and IRP to achieve a "win-win" situation, an excessive level of confidence will inhibit the incentives of the cost-sharing strategy, negatively affecting the manufacturer's interests. Interestingly, a cost-sharing contract will become inefficient under certain conditions, i.e., highly efficient level of technological innovation, highly efficient Big Data marketing, and a high level of overconfidence, negatively affecting the manufacturer's interests. Additionally, technological innovation efficiency and marketing efficiency will have different effects on the IRP's recycling price. A cost-sharing contract and the IRP's overconfidence will prompt the IRP to exert more efforts on technological innovation and Big Data marketing and to significantly reduce the manufacturing costs and recycling costs for all members. Notably, although the IRP's overconfidence and cost-sharing strategies may damage the supplier's profit, the total profit of the CLSC increases.
computer science, interdisciplinary applications,engineering, industrial
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problems that this paper attempts to solve mainly focus on the following aspects: 1. **Explore the impact of third - party Internet recycling platforms (IRP) on upstream manufacturing enterprises in the closed - loop supply chain (CLSC)**: With the advent of the "Internet +" era, third - party Internet recycling platforms have played a revolutionary role in the closed - loop supply chain operation mode in China. By constructing a two - stage remanufacturing closed - loop supply chain dynamic model including manufacturers, IRPs and suppliers, the paper studies how the introduction of IRP affects the decision - making and profits of upstream manufacturing enterprises. 2. **Analyze the impact of IRP's overconfident behavior on the decision - making of supply chain members**: The paper pays special attention to IRP's overconfident behavior in big - data marketing decision - making and explores how this behavior affects the decision - making of each member of the supply chain. Research shows that although IRP's overconfidence may damage the profits of suppliers, it can generally increase the total profit of the entire CLSC. 3. **Evaluate the benefits of technological innovation and big - data marketing for different members of the supply chain**: The paper analyzes the positive and negative impacts of technological innovation and big - data marketing on each member of the supply chain in different scenarios. Specifically, technological innovation can significantly reduce manufacturing costs and recycling costs, while big - data marketing can optimize supply chain management by improving recycling efficiency. 4. **Study whether the manufacturer's cost - sharing strategy can improve the profitability of CLSC**: The paper explores the effectiveness of the manufacturer's cost - sharing strategy under different conditions. The results show that in the case of high technological innovation efficiency, good big - data marketing effect and high IRP overconfidence level, the cost - sharing contract may become invalid, thus having a negative impact on the manufacturer's interests. ### Main contributions 1. **CLSC model in a dynamic environment**: Based on the existing static CLSC research, the paper takes into account the influence of the big - data environment and designs a CLSC differential game model including IRP, which better captures the real - life recycling - manufacturing process. 2. **Two - stage CLSC model considering the quality of recycled products**: The paper extends the traditional single - stage remanufacturing CLSC model, takes into account the quality level of recycled products, and highlights the quality characteristics in used products through classified remanufacturing. 3. **Impact of technological innovation investment**: In addition to marketing strategies, the paper also considers IRP's technological innovation investment. The results show that IRP's technological innovation can significantly reduce the production costs of upstream enterprises in the supply chain and has a positive impact on both enterprises and the environment. 4. **Impact of overconfident behavior**: The paper explores the impact of overconfident behavior on enterprise decision - making and profits from the perspective of IRP, and finds that moderate overconfidence will not damage the overall performance of CLSC, but will affect the effectiveness of the manufacturer's cost - sharing strategy. ### Conclusion By constructing and analyzing a two - stage remanufacturing CLSC dynamic model including IRP, the paper systematically explores the impacts of big - data marketing, technological innovation and overconfident behavior on the decision - making and profits of each member of the supply chain. The research results not only enrich the theoretical research in the CLSC field, but also provide valuable references for practical operations.