Abstract:Academic abstract: Advantaged group allies have multiple motives for supporting equality, raising questions about their sincerity. We draw upon the covariation model of attributions to explain how disadvantaged group members make attributions about whether advantaged group "allies" are sincerely motivated to empower the disadvantaged group. We propose an Attribution-Identity Model of Sincerity (AIMS) which posits that disadvantaged group members view advantaged group members as sincere allies when they support equality in the presence of inhibitory causes and in the absence of facilitative causes, exceed expectations for the advantaged group, and provide support across time and contexts. Furthermore, those who identify strongly with their disadvantaged group and perceive intergroup inequality as illegitimate are most motivated to ascertain the sincerity of advantaged group members' allyship. AIMS suggests how members of disadvantaged groups seek to maximize benefits and minimize risks of advantaged group members' allyship. Public abstract: Advantaged group members (e.g., men, White Americans) can act as allies for disadvantaged groups (e.g., women, Americans belonging to minoritized racial groups), but members of disadvantaged groups sometimes have reason to question whether their motives are sincere. We argue that members of disadvantaged groups view advantaged group allies as more sincere when they support equality when they do not stand to benefit from it and even when they stand to lose. We also argue that members of disadvantaged groups view advantaged group allies as more sincere when their support for equality goes beyond expectations for their advantaged group, consistently over time, and is not limited to particular situations, forms, or contexts. Members of disadvantaged groups like sincere allies, want to work with them, and feel safe around them. Sincere allies also serve as moral exemplars to other members of advantaged groups.

Consequences of enactment and concealment for felt authenticity: Understanding the effects of stigma through self‐distancing and motive fulfillment

The consequences of being myself: Understanding authenticity and psychological safety for LGB employees

Relationships between stigma-identity constructs and psychological health outcomes among adults who stutter

The identity group as a source of social influence for individuals with concealable stigmatized identities

Visible and concealable stigmatized identities and mental health: Experiences of racial discrimination and anticipated stigma.

Tainted by Stigma: The Interplay of Stigma and Moral Identity in Health Persuasion

Living as Socially Marked Individuals: Two Stories on Stigma and Its Consequences

"My Aim Is True": An Attribution-Identity Model of Ally Sincerity

Authentic isn't always best: When inauthentic social media influencers induce positive consumer purchase intention through inspiration

To thine own self be true? Clarifying the effects of identity discrepancies on psychological distress and emotions

Social Stigma and Self-Esteem: Situational Construction of Self-Worth

Observers' motivated sensitivity to stigmatized actors' intent

Emotion regulation strategies and coping self-efficacy as moderators of daily associations between transgender and gender diverse (TGD) enacted stigma and affect among TGD young adults assigned female at birth

Sticky Stigma: The Impact of Incarceration on Perceptions of Personality Traits and Deservingness

Perceived authenticity as a vicarious justification for prejudice

Service employees and self-verification: The roles of occupational stigma consciousness and core self-evaluations

Identity Processing Style and Depression: The Mediational Role of Experiential Avoidance and Self-Regulation

The Catch-22 of Countering a Moral Occupational Stigma in Employee-Customer Interactions

Insights into stigma management communication theory: considering stigmatization as interpersonal influence

The cumulative effects of stigma-related stress: Chronic stigma-related stress exposure exacerbates daily associations between enacted stigma and anxious/depressed affect

Disability and autonomy: Priming alternative identities.