Abstract:Background/Context Federal policy, as codified in Race to the Top (RTT) funding guidelines, outlines four types of intervention: turnaround, restart, closure, and transformation. RTT has embraced a technocratic paradigm for school reform that frames choice less as the opportunity for the public to deliberate about what it wants from its schools and more in terms of the freedom of individual families to choose, as customers, from a diverse array of school options. This market-based system has eroded substantive opportunities for parents and students to participate in decisions about their schools. Although scholars have developed compelling arguments about the need to involve parents and teachers in a more deliberative and democratic approach to intervening in low-performing schools, there is little scholarship focused on the role of young people in school intervention processes. Purpose There is widespread agreement among progressive critics that RTT interventions are not sufficiently democratic. More work is needed to develop participatory approaches. In some cases this may require departing from a strict “evidence-based” framework and imagining new alternatives consistent with values of social justice and educational equity. It also requires expanding existing treatments of deliberative democracy theory to include young people. Research Design & Findings: This article makes a conceptual argument rooted in theory, empirical literature, and practical experience in schools. After explaining theories of participatory democracy, youth–adult partnerships, and thirdspace, we propose five practices that should guide a deliberative, participatory approach to public decision-making about schools. These are: border-crossing facilitation, participatory research, multilingual and multicultural discourse practices, authentic decision-making, and joint work and distributed expertise. Conclusions/Recommendations The current school turnaround paradigm, embodied by closures, conversion to charters, and teacher reassignments, has left a great deal of collateral damage in its wake. Teachers work under threat of firing. We propose an alternative approach to improve struggling public neighborhood schools—not just another option in a menu of turnaround strategies, but an alternative frame and set of practices that expands the conversation about intervention. This approach encourages deliberation and communication among diverse networks of students, teachers, and families.

School-based YPAR: negotiating productive tensions of participation and possibility

Examining the Intersection of Sociopolitical Development and Transformative Social and Emotional Learning Outcomes: An Integrated Approach in Youth Participatory Action Research

Power, Privilege, and Precarity: Attempts to Conduct Ethical Youth Participatory Action Research as Early Career Researchers

An interdisciplinary framework of youth participatory action research informed by curricula, youth, adults, and researchers

A case study of participatory action research in a public new England middle school: empowerment, constraints and challenges

School Citizenship Education Through YPAR: What Works? A Mixed-Methods Study in Italy

Youth-driven Youth–Adult Partnerships: A Phenomenological Exploration of Agricultural Education Teachers' Experiences

Youth Participatory Action Research as Culturally Sustaining Pedagogy

Participatory Democracy and Struggling Schools: Making Space for Youth in School Turnarounds

Realising agency: insights from participatory research with learners in a South African sexual and reproductive health programme

From Democratic Participation to Cariño: Exploring the Core Commitments of Foundational Scholars in the Field of Youth Participatory Action Research

Preventing Bullying and Improving School Climate Through Integrating Youth Participatory Action Research Into School-wide Positive Behavioral Interventions and Supports: An Illustration Using a Multiple Case Study Approach

Bounded agency and social participation: how socioeconomic situation and experiences influence young people’s way of engaging in society

Finding the balance: the choreography of participatory research with children and young people

Children’s participation: moving from the performative to the social

Evaluation of an Active Citizenship Intervention Based on Youth-Led Participatory Action Research

Youth activism in the urban community: learning critical civic praxis within community organizations

Place-based civic science-collective environmental action and solidarity for eco-resilience

Adult Reflection on Engaging Youth of Color in Research and Action: A Case Study From Five U.S. Cities

Using critical media literacy and youth-led research to promote the sociopolitical development of Black youth: Strategies from “Our Voices”

‘They Really Should Start Listening to You’: The Benefits and Challenges of Co-Producing a Participatory Framework of Youth Justice Practice