Abstract:Previous research has suggested that making classrooms more active and student centered improves learning, and this usually involves encouraging student talk in the classroom. However, the majority of students remain silent during whole-class discussions, and men's voices are more likely to be heard in science classrooms. Previous interview studies and quantitative studies have discussed the role instructors play in encouraging or discouraging participation, the weight students put into the fear of negative evaluation, and other factors. However, interview studies on the experiences of college students in the sciences, specifically, are lacking. Thus, we conducted a qualitative interview study to investigate students' experiences deciding whether to participate verbally in class, focusing on students recruited from science classrooms. We analyzed the data using an inductive approach and found three main themes: (1) A wide variety of external factors impact students' decision to participate, including instructor characteristics and choices, peer influences, and course material characteristics; (2) Students weigh these factors in complex ways, and this internal calculus varies by student; and (3) Women put greater emphasis on fearing peer judgment, and men may be more motivated by course material considerations. Most of the external factors we identified as important for student participation have been described previously, and we validate that previous literature. We add to the literature by a more complex discussion of how students weigh these different factors and how complex the classroom ecosystem can be. We end by framing our results within the Expectancy Value Theory of motivation, discussing limitations, and providing implications for science college instructors to promote broad and equitable participation.

Class Discussion and Class Participation: Determination of Their Relationship

Online Tests Participation/Performance is a Determinant of Final Grades in Physiology

CLASSROOM PARTICIPATION AND PERSONALITY DEVELOPMENT OF STUDENTS AT HIGHER LEVEL: A CORRELATIONAL STUDY

The Influence of Superordinate Identity on Group Decision Making Through Discussion

Students’ Participation Intention in an Online Discussion Forum: Why is Computer-Mediated Interaction Attractive?

The effects of instructor participation and class size on student participation in an online class discussion forum

What Motivates a Student to Participate in the Electronic Discussion Forum: A Survey Study of Students' Participation Intention.

To participate or not to participate? A qualitative investigation of students' complex motivations for verbal classroom participation

Can Online Discussion Participation Predict Group Project Performance? Investigating the Roles of Linguistic Features and Participation Patterns

Analysis of Relationship between Students' Perceptions of Classroom Learning Environment, Approaches to Learning and Levels of Satisfaction with Teaching

Effect of Student and Faculty Interaction on College Student ’s Attainments and Satisfaction

The relationships between social participatory roles and cognitive engagement levels in online discussions

An Empirical Study of College English PAD Class Based on Self-Determination Theory

Analysis of English Classroom Interaction in Colleges and Universities Based on Student Behavioral Data

A STUDY OF THE CORRELATION BETWEEN TEACHERS’ TEACHING STYLES AND STUDENTS’ PARTICIPATION MOTIVATION IN THE PHYSICAL EDUCATION

Analysis of Out-of-class Student Involvement Impact Mechanism on Student Development

Study on the Asynchronous Online Discussion Participation Patterns of University Student Readers Using Social Network Analysis

Student participation in everyday school life—Linking different perspectives

Classroom Learning Motivators:Breaking ESL Chinese university students' passivity in class discussion

Identifying Chinese students' perceptions of smart classrooms and their relationships with design features

Student satisfaction and interaction in higher education