Abstract:Background: Depression is one of the top mental health concerns among biology graduate students and has contributed to the "graduate student mental health crisis" declared in 2018. Several prominent science outlets have called for interventions to improve graduate student mental health, yet it is unclear to what extent graduate students with depression discuss their mental health with others in their Ph.D. programs. While sharing one's depression may be an integral step to seeking mental health support during graduate school, depression is considered to be a concealable stigmatized identity (CSI) and revealing one's depression could result in loss of status or discrimination. As such, face negotiation theory, which describes a set of communicative behaviors that individuals use to regulate their social dignity, may help identify what factors influence graduate students' decisions about whether to reveal their depression in graduate school. In this study, we interviewed 50 Ph.D. students with depression enrolled across 28 life sciences graduate programs across the United States. We examined (1) to what extent graduate students revealed their depression to faculty advisors, graduate students, and undergraduates in their research lab, (2) the reasons why they revealed or concealed their depression, and (3) the consequences and benefits they perceive are associated with revealing depression. We used a hybrid approach of deductive and inductive coding to analyze our data. Results: More than half (58%) of Ph.D. students revealed their depression to at least one faculty advisor, while 74% revealed to at least one graduate student. However, only 37% of graduate students revealed their depression to at least one undergraduate researcher. Graduate students' decisions to reveal their depression to their peers were driven by positive mutual relationships, while their decisions to reveal to faculty were often based on maintaining dignity by performing preventative or corrective facework. Conversely, graduates performed supportive facework when interacting with undergraduate researchers by revealing their depression as a way to destigmatize struggling with mental health. Conclusions: Life sciences graduate students most commonly revealed their depression to other graduate students, and over half reported discussing depression with their faculty advisor. However, graduate students were reluctant to share their depression with undergraduate researchers. Power dynamics between graduate students and their advisors, their peers, and their undergraduate mentees influenced the reasons they chose to reveal or conceal their depression in each situation. This study provides insights into how to create more inclusive life science graduate programs where students can feel more comfortable discussing their mental health. Supplementary information: The online version contains supplementary material available at 10.1186/s40594-023-00426-7.

College Student Concealment and Disclosure of Mental Health Issues in the Classroom: Students’ Perceptions of Risk and Use of Contextual Criteria

Self-disclosure of mental illness in the college classroom: the role of stigma and avoidance

Undergraduate students with and without mental health concerns have different perceptions of disclosing mental health challenges to instructors

College students’ disclosure of mental health problems on campus

Graduate students' perspectives on the role of faculty advisors in helping students with mental health problems

Self-Disclosures During Lecture Affect Students' Perceptions of Professor But Not Student Learning Outcomes

Talking Is Hard: A Mixed-Methods Exploration of Factors Associated with Communication about Mental Health Issues among Black College Students

A Study on the Disclosure of People with Mental Illness

A Mixed Methods Study of Perceptions of Mental Illness and Self-Disclosure of Mental Illness Among Medical Learners

College students’ mental illness disclosure and self-esteem: a moderating role of self-image goals

Online Community College Student-Researchers Explore Mental Health Stigmas: Deeper Learning Implied

The impact of concealable chronic health conditions on college students’ academic outcomes: A two-wave study

Normalising disclosure or reinforcing heroism? An exploratory critical discourse analysis of mental health stigma in medical education

Mental health literacy, self-efficacy, and stigma among college students

Face negotiation in graduate school: the decision to conceal or reveal depression among life sciences Ph.D. students in the United States

I’m Not Crazy or Anything: Exploring Culture, Mental Health Stigma, and Mental Health Service Use among Urban Community College Students

Mental health literacy, stigma, and help-seeking behaviors among male college students

Understanding the Role of Social Media–Based Mental Health Support Among College Students: Survey and Semistructured Interviews

Examining Personal, Perceived, Treatment, and Self-Stigma in College Students: The Role of Parent Beliefs and Mental Health Literacy

A qualitative investigation of instructors’ perceived communicative roles in students’ mental health management

Understanding Mental Health App Use among Community College Students: Web-Based Survey Study