Abstract:The main contention of this paper is that our ability to embed a consideration of values into business school curricula is hampered by certain normative parameters that our students have when entering the classroom. If we don’t understand the processes of valuation that underpin our students’ reasoning, our ethics teaching will inevitably miss its mark. In this paper, we analyze one of the most prevalent metaphors that underpin moral arguments about business, and reveal the beliefs and assumptions that underpin it. By revisiting the content of Adam Smith’s “invisible hand” metaphor, we show that the moral content of the metaphor has been significantly misconstrued through its subsequent reception in economic theory. The “Giving Voice to Values” (GVV) pedagogy aims to enable students to act on their tacit values and address the rationalizations that they may encounter for not acting on these values (Gentile in Giving voice to values. How to speak your mind when you know what’s right, Yale University Press, Yale, 2010a; Discussions about ethics in the accounting classroom: student assumptions and faculty paradigms, Darden Business Publishing,2010b. http://store.darden.virginia.edu/Syllabus%20Copy/Discussions-about-Ethics-in-Accounting_S.pdf; Educating for values-driven leadership across the curriculum: giving voice to values, Business Expert Press, New York, 2013). We believe our analysis can strengthen the employment of GVV in three ways: (1) understanding tacit blockages to moral action, i.e., how students’ belief in the moral efficacy of the invisible hand could undermine their own sense of moral duty; (2) addressing common rationalizations that may emerge from different assumptions about morally appropriate courses of action in the workplace; and (3) resolving values conflicts on how to act.

The Situationist Critique of Virtue Ethics and Its Implications for the Media Ethics Classroom

Virtue Theory against Situationism

Media Ethics, Moral Controversies, and the Sociology of Critique

Normative media theory in the digital media landscape: from media ethics to ethical communication

Media and Moral Education: A Philosophy of Critical Engagement

Teaching Virtue: Pedagogical Implications of Moral Psychology

Technology and the Situationist Challenge to Virtue Ethics

The Solution of Situantionism-Virtue Ethics Debate from a Psychological Perspective

Dialogic Problematization of Academic Integrity Education

An Ethical Foundation for Social Good: Virtue Theory and Solidarity

4. Cultural Pluralism and Media Ethics: Theorizing in a Globalized World of Difference

Designing a Future Worth Wanting: Applying Virtue Ethics to HCI

A critical evaluation of Clifford Christians’s media ethics theory: a précis

Challenges and Opportunities for the Future of Media and Mass Communication Theory and Research: Positionality, Integrative Research, and Public Scholarship

The Philosopher as Moral Activist

Analyzing the Social Construction of Media Claims: Enhancing Media Literacy in Social Problems Classes

Introduction to ethics in the age of digital communication

Lost in Translation: The Construct Representation of Character Virtues

The Fundamental Concept and the Main Task of Ethics of Virtue from Aristotelianism's Perspective

Person and social media: new value or devaluation of personality?

Strengthening “Giving Voice to Values” in Business Schools by Reconsidering the “Invisible Hand” Metaphor