Climate warming moderates the impacts of introduced sportfish on multiple dimensions of prey biodiversity

Charlie J. G. Loewen,Angela L. Strecker,Benjamin Gilbert,Donald A. Jackson

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1111/gcb.15225

IF: 11.6

2020-07-07

Global Change Biology

Abstract:<p>Human‐assisted introductions of exotic species are a leading cause of anthropogenic change in biodiversity; however, context dependencies and interactions with co‐occurring stressors impede our ability to predict their ecological impacts. The legacy of historical sportfish stocking in mountainous regions of western North America creates a unique, natural quasi‐experiment to investigate factors moderating invasion impacts on native communities across broad geographic and environmental gradients. Here, we synthesize fish stocking records and zooplankton relative abundance for 685 mountain lakes and ponds in the Cascade and Canadian Rocky Mountain Ranges, to reveal the effects of predatory sportfish introduction on multiple taxonomic, functional, and phylogenetic dimensions of prey biodiversity. We demonstrate an innovative analytical approach, combining exploratory random forest machine learning with confirmatory multigroup analysis using multivariate partial least‐squares structural equation models, to generate and test hypotheses concerning environmental moderation of stocking impacts. We discovered distinct effects of stocking across different dimensions of diversity, including negligible (nonsignificant) impacts on local taxonomic richness (i.e. alpha diversity) and trophic structure, in contrast to significant declines in compositional uniqueness (i.e. beta diversity) and body size. Further, we found that stocking impacts were moderated by cross‐scale interactions with climate and climate‐related land‐cover variables (e.g. factors linked to treeline position and glaciers). Interactions with physical morphometric and lithological factors were generally of lesser importance, though catchment slope and habitat size constraints were relevant in certain dimensions. Finally, applying space‐for‐time substitution, a strong antagonistic (i.e. dampening) interaction between sportfish predation and warmer temperatures suggests redundancy of their size‐selective effects, meaning that warming will lessen the consequences of introductions in the future and stocked lakes may be less impacted by subsequent warming. While both stressors drive biotic homogenization, our results have important implications for fisheries managers weighing the costs/benefits of stocking—or removing established non‐native populations—under a rapidly changing climate.</p>

environmental sciences,biodiversity conservation,ecology

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is how the impact of introduced sportfish on zooplankton diversity in mountain lakes changes in the context of global warming. Specifically, by analyzing the historical records of 685 lakes and ponds in the mountainous areas of western North America, the researchers explored the following issues:

1. **Impact of introduced sportfish on zooplankton diversity**: The researchers used a set of biodiversity indicators to quantify diversity in different dimensions, including taxonomic diversity, functional diversity, and phylogenetic diversity, in order to assess the specific impacts on these diversity indicators after the introduction of sportfish.

2. **How environmental factors modulate the impact of introduced sportfish**: The researchers applied the exploratory Random Forest (RF) machine - learning algorithm, combined with the confirmatory multivariate partial least - squares structural equation models (PLS - SEM), to discover and test environmental factors that may modulate the impact of fish introduction. These environmental factors include climate variables, topographic features, geological factors, and land cover, etc.

3. **Interaction between climate change and fish introduction**: The researchers specifically focused on the interaction between climate change and fish introduction, especially whether rising temperature would have an inhibitory or enhancing effect on the impact of fish introduction. Through the space - for - time substitution method, the researchers speculated that future climate warming might mitigate the negative impact of fish introduction on lake ecosystems.

### Research Background

- **Impact of invasive species**: Human - assisted introduction of alien species is one of the main causes of biodiversity decline, but its ecological impact is often modulated by multiple environmental factors, making prediction complex.
- **Superimposed effect of climate change**: The superimposed effect of climate change and other ecological stressors (such as invasive species) is difficult to predict, especially in freshwater ecosystems, where this superimposed effect is particularly significant.
- **Uniqueness of mountain ecosystems**: Mountain ecosystems have obvious environmental heterogeneity, which provides unique natural experimental conditions for studying how environmental factors modulate the impact of invasive species.

### Research Methods

- **Data collection**: The researchers integrated the historical records of 685 lakes and ponds, including fish introduction records and zooplankton relative abundance data.
- **Biodiversity indicators**: Multiple biodiversity indicators were calculated, including taxonomic richness, evenness, and compositional uniqueness, functional diversity, and phylogenetic diversity.
- **Statistical analysis**: Two - sample permutation tests were used to compare the biodiversity differences between lakes with and without introduced sportfish; the Random Forest algorithm was applied to discover possible environmental modulating factors; finally, the partial least - squares structural equation model (PLS - SEM) was used for hypothesis testing to verify the importance of the interactions discovered by the Random Forest.

### Main Findings

- **Taxonomic diversity**: The introduction of sportfish had no significant impact on local taxonomic richness (alpha diversity) and trophic structure.
- **Functional diversity and phylogenetic diversity**: The introduction of sportfish significantly reduced the compositional uniqueness (beta diversity) and body size of zooplankton.
- **Environmental modulating factors**: Climate change and its related land cover variables (such as treeline position and glacial factors) played an important modulating role in the impact of fish introduction. In particular, there was an antagonistic relationship between temperature rise and fish predation, meaning that warming would weaken the negative impact of fish introduction.

### Conclusion

The research results show that the interaction between climate change and fish introduction has a complex impact on zooplankton diversity. This finding is of great significance for future fishery management and biodiversity conservation, especially under rapidly changing climatic conditions.