Abstract:Purpose Currently, most research studies focus on ownership reforms and governance reforms, while only a few research studies focus on management system innovations. Based on an evolution of state-owned enterprises’ (SOEs) performance appraisal systems, this paper investigates the influence of performance appraisal system on earnings management. Design/methodology/approach Using a natural experiment that central government-owned enterprises (CGOEs) carried out economic value-added performance appraisal (EVA-PA) in 2010, the authors adapt difference-in-difference method to analyze the relationship between EVA-PA and earnings management choice. Furthermore, the authors consider the situation which contained financial status, separation between decision-making rights and decision-control rights, separation between ownership and control and industrial characteristics. Findings The research finds that after carrying out EVA-PA, CGOEs prefer accrual-based earnings management to real earnings management, and there is substitution effect between the two types of earnings management. Moreover, further research studies reveal that enterprises suffering losses in the previous year and featuring higher separation between decision-making rights and decision-control rights and higher separation between ownership and control have stronger earnings management motive under EVA-PA. In contrast, enterprises achieving satisfactory financial performance in the previous year and engaging in businesses within protective industry have weaker earnings management motive under EVA-PA. After the implementation of EVA-PA, accrual-based earnings management and real earnings management both impair operating performances of CGOEs. Originality/value Theoretically, this paper enriches research studies on earnings management from the perspective of incentive mechanism and expands research studies on economic consequences of EVA-PA. In addition, it validates the relationship between the two types of earnings management. As an important mechanism of corporate management and control, performance appraisal system is an important part for establishing ownership management system and improving internal management system of SOEs.

EVA Application in the Performance Evaluation of State-owned Enterprises in China—Take Gree Group as an Example

On EVA Performance Evaluation for State-owned Enterprises

Establishment and Improvement of an Assessment and Accountability System for Eco-environmental Performance Evaluation

The Application of EVA in the State-owned Enterprise Performance Measure

VEAs Pattern in China: Is It a Good Choice for Environmental Management?

Research on the Evaluation of Financial Performance of Supor Based on EVA Perspective

Study of the Relationship between the Sustainable Growing Social Responsibility and EVA Performance Evaluation System of Chinese Central Enterprises

Does EVA Performance Evaluation Improve the Value of Cash Holdings? Evidence from China

Discussion on EVA Performance Evaluation Standard of Central Enterprise Based on WACC Valuation

Research on ESG performance and financial performance of new energy enterprises

Analysis on Value Creation of A-share Group for Agriculture, Forestry, Animal Husbandry and Fishery in China

Practice of EVA-Based Balanced Scorecard in the Construction of Performance Evaluation System

Comparison of Performance among Chinese Commercial Banks and Their Driving Factors

Study on Evaluation Model of State－owned Asset Performance and Its Application

Does new performance appraisal system (EVA) affect earnings management?

EVA Performance Evaluation Analysis and Improvement Path of ICBC

Explore Performance Evaluation System of Coal Enterprises from the Perspective of Social Responsibility

Influence Activities and Favoritism in Subjective Performance Evaluation: Evidence from Chinese State-Owned Enterprises

Corporate Governance of China’s State-Owned Enterprises: A Review of Past Experiences

Research on EVA Based Performance Measurement in Service Oriented Enterprise

Economic Value Added (EVA) for Performance Evaluation of Public Organizations