The Response of Hip Joint Cartilage to Exercise in Children: An MRI Study Using T2-Mapping

Scott Fernquest,Antony Palmer,Claudio Pereira,Calum Arnold,Emma Hirons,John Broomfield,Simon Newman,Sion Glyn-Jones

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1177/1947603520931182

IF: 3.117

2020-06-12

Cartilage

Abstract:Objective The aim of this study was to determine the effects of activity and cam morphology on cartilage composition during adolescence and investigate the development of cartilage composition with age. Design Cross-sectional observational cohort study of individuals from football club academies and an age-matched control population, aged 9 to 18 years. Assessments included questionnaires and T2-mapping of hips. Primary imaging outcome measures were T2 relaxation time of acetabular and femoral cartilage, average alpha angle, and lateral epiphyseal extension. Results The cohort consisted of 109 elite male footballers, 49 male controls, and 51 female controls. Elite male footballers had an acetabular cartilage T2 value 4.85 ms greater than male controls ( P < 0.001). A significant positive correlation existed between Physical Activity Questionnaire Score and acetabular cartilage T2 value (coefficient 1.07, P < 0.001) and femoral cartilage T2 value (coefficient 0.66, P = 0.032). Individuals with a closed physis had an acetabular cartilage T2 value 7.86 ms less than individuals with an open physis. Acetabular cartilage T2 values decreased with age in elite footballers. No correlation existed between alpha angle and anterosuperior acetabular cartilage T2 value and no difference in T2 value existed between individuals with and without cam morphology. Conclusions This study demonstrates that high activity levels may significantly affect acetabular cartilage composition during adolescence, but cam morphology may not detrimentally affect cartilage composition until after adolescence.

orthopedics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The main problem that this paper attempts to solve is to understand the impact of exercise on the composition of hip joint cartilage in adolescents and to study the developmental changes in the composition of hip joint cartilage as age increases. Specifically, the research objectives include:

1. **Explore the influence of activity level and femoral head deformity (cam morphology) on the composition of cartilage during adolescence**:
- By comparing the differences in cartilage T2 values between elite football players and the control group, explore whether high activity levels will affect the composition of hip joint cartilage.
- Research whether femoral head deformity (cam morphology) exists and its impact on the composition of cartilage.

2. **Study the age - related changes in the composition of hip joint cartilage during the growth of adolescents**:
- Analyze the changes in cartilage T2 values at different ages to understand the developmental trend of cartilage composition.
- Explore the impact of skeletal maturity (such as the closure state of the epiphyseal line) on the composition of cartilage.

### Main research findings:

1. **The impact of high activity levels on the composition of cartilage**:
- The acetabular cartilage T2 values of elite football players are significantly higher than those of male subjects in the control group, indicating that high activity levels may affect the composition of acetabular cartilage.
- Individuals with high scores on the Physical Activity Questionnaire (PAQ) also have higher T2 values in their acetabular and femoral head cartilages, which may mean that high activity levels lead to changes in cartilage structure and composition, such as a decrease in glycosaminoglycan (GAG) content and disordered collagen fiber arrangement.

2. **The impact of age on the composition of cartilage**:
- As age increases, the acetabular cartilage T2 values of elite football players decrease significantly, while no consistent age - related changes are observed in the control group.
- Skeletal maturity (the closure state of the epiphyseal line) has a significant impact on the acetabular cartilage T2 value, and individuals with closed epiphyses have lower acetabular cartilage T2 values.

3. **The impact of femoral head deformity (cam morphology) on the composition of cartilage**:
- No significant association was found between femoral head deformity and the T2 value of the anterior - superior acetabular cartilage.
- Univariate regression analysis shows that individuals with femoral head deformity (alpha angle greater than 60°) have lower T2 values in the anterior - superior acetabular cartilage, but this association is not significant in multivariate regression analysis.

### Conclusion:

The results of this study indicate that high activity levels may have an adverse impact on the composition of acetabular cartilage during adolescence, while femoral head deformity may not cause a significant negative impact on cartilage composition during adolescence. These findings are helpful for understanding the impact of exercise and skeletal development on hip joint health and provide a basis for further research.