Abstract:Transcranial direct current stimulation (tDCS) is used as a tool to causally influence neural activity in humans non-invasively. Although most studies recruit a large number of participants in order to uncover population-level effects, growing evidence suggests that tDCS may be expected to induce different effects in different individuals, leading to large inter-individual variability and confounds in population-level testing. Alternatively, this variability may arise from intra-individual sources that are difficult to assess in standard designs. Here, we performed between 8 and 10 sessions of tDCS within individuals to understand how intra-individual variability impacts the inference of tDCS effects. We recruited 5 participants who underwent functional MRI to localize the human frontal eye field (FEF) homologue. An HD-tDCS montage was used to stimulate the target location based on individual MRI localizations, alternating the polarity between anodal or cathodal current over 8-10 repeated sessions during a 5 week period. Participants performed a free choice task before and after stimulation while recording EEG activity. We then developed a difference-in-difference method based on permutation testing to assess the likelihood of a causal effect of tDCS at different levels of abstraction: group-level, inter-individual, and intra-individual. At the group-level, we found evidence for an influence of tDCS on choice reaction times, which followed a reaction-time dependent change in alpha-band activity, and on how choices depended on recent history. However, individuals showed heterogeneous, and often contradictory, effects. We then analyzed the distribution of session permutations at the intra-individual level, and found a discrepancy between the inter-individual effects that survived significance testing and the intra-individual effects that correlated on a session-session basis. We argue that, while the observed variability may have arisen from a combination of inter and intra-individual differences relevant to tDCS-dependent mechanisms of action, it may be equally well explained by spurious effects arising from history-dependence between repeated measures that are typically assumed to be independent. In light of this, we assess the counterfactuals that must be evaluated in order to make data-driven inferences about the causal effects of tDCS on free choice behaviour and its neural correlates.

Individual differences in local functional brain connectivity affect TMS effects on behavior

Modeling the effects of transcranial magnetic stimulation on spatial attention

Spread of activity following TMS is related to intrinsic resting connectivity to the salience network: A concurrent TMS-fMRI study

The role of white matter variability in TMS neuromodulatory effects

Precision Network Modeling of TMS Across Individuals Suggests Therapeutic Targets and Potential for Improvement

Resting fMRI-guided TMS results in subcortical and brain network modulation indexed by interleaved TMS/fMRI

Precision Network Modeling of Transcranial Magnetic Stimulation Across Individuals Suggests Therapeutic Targets and Potential for Improvement

Effect of neuroanatomy on corticomotor excitability during and after transcranial magnetic stimulation and intermittent theta burst stimulation

Chronometric TMS-fMRI of personalized left dorsolateral prefrontal target reveals state-dependency of subgenual anterior cingulate cortex effects

Individual differences in neuroanatomy and neurophysiology predict effects of transcranial alternating current stimulation

Effects of inhibitory theta burst TMS to different brain sites involved in visuospatial attention - a combined neuronavigated cTBS and behavioural study

Dynamic Functional Connectivity Within the Fronto-Limbic Network Induced by Intermittent Theta-Burst Stimulation: A Pilot Study.

Regional specificity of cathodal transcranial direct current stimulation effects on spatial–numerical associations: Comparison of four stimulation sites

Neural effects of transcranial magnetic stimulation at the single-cell level

Neuromodulatory transcranial magnetic stimulation (TMS) changes functional connectivity proportional to the electric-field induced by the TMS pulse

TMS provokes target-dependent intracranial rhythms across human cortical and subcortical sites

Effects of continuous versus intermittent theta-burst TMS on fMRI connectivity

Graph Analysis of TMS-EEG Connectivity Reveals Hemispheric Differences following Occipital Stimulation

Intra-individual variability in the effects of transcranial direct current stimulation on free choice saccade behaviour

Inter-individual Differences in Resting-State Functional Connectivity Predict Task-Induced BOLD Activity

Prefrontal Multielectrode Transcranial Direct Current Stimulation Modulates Performance and Neural Activity Serving Visuospatial Processing