Abstract:The banking industry necessitates implementing an early warning system to effectively identify the factors that impact bank managers and enable them to make informed decisions, thereby mitigating systemic risk. Identifying factors that influence banks in times of stability and crisis is crucial, as it ultimately contributes to developing an improved early warning system. This study undertakes a comparative analysis of the stability of Indonesian Islamic and conventional banking across distinct economic regimes—crisis and stability. We analyze monthly banking data from December 2007 to November 2022 using the Markov Switching Dynamic Regression technique. The study focuses on conducting a comparative analysis between Islamic banks, represented by Islamic Commercial Bank (ICB) and Islamic Rural Bank (IRB), and conventional banks, represented by the Conventional Commercial Bank (CCB) and Conventional Rural Bank (CRB). The findings reveal that both Islamic and conventional banks exhibit a higher probability of being in a stable regime than a crisis regime. Notably, Islamic banks demonstrate a greater propensity to remain in a stable regime than their conventional counterparts. However, in a crisis regime, the likelihood of recovery for Sharia-compliant institutions is lower than for conventional banks. Furthermore, our analysis indicates that larger banks exhibit higher stability than their smaller counterparts regarding assets and size. This study pioneers a comprehensive comparison of the Z-score, employed as a proxy for stability, between two distinct classifications of Indonesian banks: Sharia (ICB and IRB) and conventional (CCB and CRB). The result is expected to improve our awareness of the elements that affect the stability of Islamic and conventional banking in Indonesia, leading to a deeper comprehension of their dynamics.

THE DETERMINANTS OF SYSTEMIC RISK: EVIDENCE FROM INDONESIAN COMMERCIAL BANKS

How Financial Risk Affects Indonesia Sovereign Sukuk Market Development

Bank Geographic Diversification and Systemic Risk

Determinants of credit risk: Empirical evidence from Indian commercial banks

The Influence Of Risk Management On Financial Performance With Firm Size As A Moderating Variable In Islamic Commercial Banks For The Period 2017-2021

The Impact of Credit Diversification on Credit Risk and Performance of Indonesian Banks

Systemic Bank in the National Banking's Legal System

Systemic Risk Contribution and Bank’s Competitiveness

The impact of monetary policy and credit risk on bank credit behavior: An analysis of banks listed on the Indonesian stock exchange

Systemic risk, financial markets, and performance of financial institutions

Systemic Risk of The Vietnamese Commercial Banks: A New Approach Using CoVaR and SRISK Measurements

Monetary Policy, Capital Regulation and Systemic Risk in Commercial Banks: Evidence from in China

Stand-alone vs systemic risk-taking of financial institutions

The Systemic Risk of European Banks During the Financial and Sovereign Debt Crises

The Determinants of Credit Risk: An Evidence from ASEAN and GCC Islamic Banks

Determinant Banking Credit Risk Management

On Bank Credit Risk: Systemic or Bank Specific? Evidence for the United States and United Kingdom

Systemic risk and the financial network system: an experimental investigation

Comparative stability analysis of Indonesian banks: Markov Switching—Dynamic Regression for Islamic and conventional sectors

Do Firm-Level Factors Play Forward-Looking Role for Financial Systemic Risk: Evidence from China

Network sensitivity of systemic risk