Abstract:Finite-temperature lattice free energy differences between polymorphs of molecular crystals are fundamental to understanding and predicting the relative stability relationships underpinning polymorphism, yet are computationally expensive to obtain. Here, we implement and critically assess machine-learning-enabled targeted free energy calculations derived from flow-based generative models to compute the free energy difference between two ice crystal polymorphs (Ice XI and Ic), modelled with a fully flexible empirical classical force field. We demonstrate that even when remapping through an analytical reference distribution, such methods enable a cost-effective and accurate calculation of free energy differences between disconnected metastable ensembles when trained on locally ergodic data sampled exclusively from the ensembles of interest. Unlike classical free energy perturbation methods, such as the Einstein crystal method, the targeted approach analysed in this work requires no additional sampling of intermediate perturbed Hamiltonians, offering significant computational savings in the system sizes compared in this work. To systematically assess the accuracy of the method, we monitored the convergence of free energy estimates during training by implementing an overfitting-aware weighted averaging strategy. By comparing our results with ground-truth free energy differences computed with the Einstein crystal method, we assess the accuracy and efficiency of two different model architectures, employing two different representations of the supercells degrees of freedom (Cartesian vs. quaternion-based). We conduct our assessment by comparing free energy differences between crystal supercells of different sizes and temperatures and assessing the accuracy in extrapolating lattice free energies to the thermodynamic limit. While at low temperatures and in small system sizes, the models perform with similar accuracy, we note that for larger systems and high temperatures, the choice of representation is key to obtaining generalisable results of quality comparable to that obtained from the Einstein crystal method. We hope the current work to be a useful stepping stone towards efficient free energy calculations in larger, more conformationally flexible systems.

Inaccurate Conformational Energies Still Hinder Crystal Structure Prediction in Flexible Organic Molecules

Reliable and Practical Computational Prediction of Molecular Crystal Polymorphs

Predicting Organic Crystal Lattice Energies with Chemical Accuracy

How Accurate Can Crystal Structure Predictions Be for High-Energy Molecular Crystals?

Machine-Learned Fragment-Based Energies for Crystal Structure Prediction

A Robust Crystal Structure Prediction Method to Support Small Molecule Drug Development with Large Scale Validation and Prospective Studies

The computational prediction of pharmaceutical crystal structures and polymorphism

Crystal Polymorphism in Oxalyl Dihydrazide: Is Empirical DFT-D Accurate Enough?

Dispersion corrected hartree-fock and density functional theory for organic crystal structure prediction

Discriminating and understanding molecular crystal polymorphism.

Crystal Structure Prediction of Molecular Crystals from First Principles: Are we there yet?

Formal Estimation of Errors in Computed Absolute Interaction Energies of Protein-Ligand Complexes

Rationalizing polymorphism with local correlation-based methods: A case study of pnictogen molecular crystals

The interplay of density functional selection and crystal structure for accurate NMR chemical shift predictions

Accurate Lattice Free Energies of Packing Polymorphs from Probabilistic Generative Models

Collective Variables for Conformational Polymorphism in Molecular Crystals

Modeling Polymorphic Molecular Crystals with Electronic Structure Theory

Energy partitioning of pharmaceutical cocrystal structures

Equivariant Neural Networks Utilizing Molecular Clusters for Accurate Molecular Crystal Binding Energy Predictions

Current approaches to predicting molecular organic crystal structures

An influence of electronic structure theory method, thermodynamic and implicit solvation corrections on the organic carbonates conformational and binding energies