Abstract:Research exploring the connection between pet ownership and mental health has expanded substantially in recent years, yet scientific evidence remains inconclusive. Existing studies have oversimplified this relationship by focusing primarily on pet ownership itself, without accounting for crucial factors such as species of the pet, or important relationship dynamics such as owner-pet attachment orientations. This study sought to investigate whether the relationship between owner-pet attachment and owner mental health could be better understood through the lens of owner-perceived pet compatibility, perceived pet welfare, and pet behavioral issues. These aspects, often overlooked in previous research, are believed to play crucial roles in shaping owner-pet relationships and owner mental wellbeing. This study surveyed emerging adults (ages 18-26) from the UK (N=600) with anxiety and/or low mood who owned dogs and/or cats. A large portion of the sample met clinical criteria for Generalized Anxiety Disorder or Major Depressive Disorder. Our findings revealed that dog owners exhibited more secure pet attachments than cat owners. Attachment notably influenced mental health whereby anxious attachment was linked to poorer mental health among dog owners, while avoidant attachment was associated with better mental health in both dog and cat owners. Insecure attachment related to poorer pet quality of life, increased reports of pet behavioral problems, and poorer owner-pet compatibility, regardless of pet species. Additionally, poorer welfare and more behavioural problems were associated with poorer mental health for dog owners; these findings were not replicated for cat owners. Notably, a dog’s mental state (such as appearing depressed), as well as fear and anxiety in dogs, mediated the relationship between owner-pet attachment and owner mental health. Owner-dog compatibility, particularly in the affection domain, influenced owner anxiety, positively mediating the relationship between anxious attachment and poorer mental health, while negatively mediating the relationship between avoidant attachment and better mental health. These findings suggest that a simplistic view of pet ownership fails to capture the complexity of the factors that shape the mental health of pet owners and underscores the need to consider important owner-pet factors to fully understand how the human-pet relationship can impact the wellbeing of both people and their pets.

A framework for understanding how activities associated with dog ownership relate to human well-being

Theoretical Foundations to the Impact of Dog-Related Activities on Human Hedonic Well-Being, Life Satisfaction and Eudaimonic Well-Being

Dogs and the Good Life: A Cross-Sectional Study of the Association Between the Dog–Owner Relationship and Owner Mental Wellbeing

Dogs as a gateway to the good life: using thematic analysis to explore the mechanisms underpinning dog ownership and human well-being

Companion dog acquisition and mental well-being: a community-based three-arm controlled study

Dog Tales: Mindful Dog Interactions Evoke Similar Experiences to Dog Assisted Mindfulness Meditations

Potential Psychosocial Explanations for the Impact of Pet Ownership on Human Well-Being: Evaluating and Expanding Current Hypotheses

The influence of interactions with pet dogs on psychological distress.

Brain and heart activity during interactions with pet dogs: A portable electroencephalogram and heart rate variability study

Exploring the Connection Between Pet Attachment and Owner Mental Health: The Roles of Owner-Pet Compatibility, Perceived Pet Welfare, and Behavioral Issues.

What Do We Know about Dog Owners? Exploring Associations between Pre-Purchase Behaviours, Knowledge and Understanding, Ownership Practices, and Dog Welfare

Walk or be walked by the dog? The attachment role

Pet’s influence on humans’ daily physical activity and mental health: a meta-analysis

Investigation of dog ownership and physical activity on weekdays and weekends using longitudinal data from the SOEP Cohort

The Pet-Effect in Daily Life: An Experience Sampling Study on Emotional Wellbeing in Pet Owners

A cross-sectional exploratory analysis between pet ownership, sleep, exercise, health and neighbourhood perceptions: the Whitehall II cohort study

Impact of Pet Ownership and Relationships on Human Psychological Health and Function

The role of dogs is associated with owner management practices and characteristics, but not with perceived canine behaviour problems

Behavioral and emotional co-modulation during dog–owner interaction measured by heart rate variability and activity

A pilot study of a joint outdoor exercise program for dog owners and dogs

Human-animal relationships and interactions during the Covid-19 lockdown phase in the UK: Investigating links with mental health and loneliness