Nitrogen stimulation of periphyton biomass in rivers: Differential effects of ammonium-N and nitrate-N

Catherine Kilroy,Logan Brown,Lisa Carlin,Paul Lambert,Amber Sinton,Janine A. Wech,Clive Howard-Williams
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1086/710081
2020-09-01
Freshwater Science
Abstract:The ecological effects of wastewater treatment plant (WWTP) discharges into rivers typically include elevated periphyton biomass resulting from enrichment by dissolved reactive phosphorus (DRP), dissolved inorganic nitrogen (DIN), or both. WWTP discharges may transfer DIN to receiving water as ammonium-N (NH<sub>4</sub>-N) and, following nitrification steps, nitrate-N (NO<sub>3</sub>-N). The potential for NH<sub>4</sub>-N to exacerbate nuisance periphyton biomass compared to NO<sub>3</sub>-N is not well understood. Theoretically, NH<sub>4</sub>-N is the more energy-efficient source of N for algae, but its effect on algal growth rates depends on concentration, interaction with NO<sub>3</sub>-N, and environmental conditions, such as temperature. We investigated the relative importance of NH<sub>4</sub>-N and NO<sub>3</sub>-N in WWTP discharges by tracking periphyton biomass and algal assemblage composition in streamside channels for 27 d under 500 µg DIN/L comprising different proportions of NH<sub>4</sub>-N: 0.5% (low-NH<sub>4</sub>, ambient levels of NH<sub>4</sub>-N, 2.2 µg/L), 30% (medium-NH<sub>4</sub>, 160 µg/L), and 77% NH<sub>4</sub>-N (high-NH<sub>4</sub>, 389 µg/L). The DIN treatments had replete DRP (25 µg/L) and were compared to controls with no enrichment (control) and DRP enrichment only (P-control). Biomass was measured as chlorophyll <i>a</i> (Chl <i>a</i>) and ash-free dry mass (AFDM), which showed contrasting responses to different proportions of NH<sub>4</sub>-N enrichment. Chl <i>a</i> was higher under high-NH<sub>4</sub> than under low-NH<sub>4</sub> (<i>p</i> &lt; 0.01, 50% higher at maximum Chl <i>a</i> on d 20). Under medium-NH<sub>4</sub> and low-NH<sub>4</sub>, Chl <i>a</i> was not different from the controls and P-controls (<i>p</i> &gt; 0.15). AFDM did not differ among the 3 DIN treatments (<i>p</i> &gt; 0.11) but was higher in all DIN treatments than in the controls (<i>p</i> &lt; 0.05). Algal assemblage composition discriminated the controls from all other treatments and the low-NH<sub>4</sub> from high-NH<sub>4</sub> treatments. The assemblage analyses indicated that high-NH<sub>4</sub> favored enhanced cell division rates in small diatoms, especially <i>Encyonema minutum</i>. Higher Chl <i>a</i>/unit volume of small taxa than larger taxa likely explained elevated Chl <i>a</i> under high-NH<sub>4</sub>. The results illustrated that, with replete DRP, elevating DIN through enrichment with NH<sub>4</sub>-N may cause additional increases in periphyton biomass as Chl <i>a</i> compared to elevating DIN through NO<sub>3</sub>-N enrichment. Consequently, enhanced management to specifically reduce NH<sub>4</sub>-N outputs in WWTP discharges may assist in the control of nuisance periphyton downstream.
ecology,marine & freshwater biology
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
### What problems does this paper attempt to solve? This paper aims to explore the impact of nitrogen (N) discharged from wastewater treatment plants (WWTP) on the biomass of periphyton in rivers, especially the different impacts of ammonia - nitrogen (NH₄ - N) and nitrate - nitrogen (NO₃ - N). Specifically, the research mainly focuses on the following points: 1. **Differences in the impact of ammonia - nitrogen and nitrate - nitrogen on periphyton biomass**: - The research hypothesizes that under the condition of the same concentration of dissolved inorganic nitrogen (DIN), ammonia - nitrogen (NH₄ - N) can promote the growth of periphyton more than nitrate - nitrogen (NO₃ - N), especially when phosphorus (P) is sufficient. - The research also hypothesizes that changing the ratio of ammonia - nitrogen and nitrate - nitrogen will lead to significant changes in the composition of the periphyton community. 2. **The impact of ammonia - nitrogen and nitrate - nitrogen on the composition of the algal community**: - Different types of nitrogen sources may have different impacts on different types of algae. The research hopes to verify these differences through experiments and understand the underlying mechanisms. 3. **Management recommendations in practical applications**: - If ammonia - nitrogen does indeed lead to an increase in periphyton biomass more easily than nitrate - nitrogen, then special attention should be paid to reducing the output of ammonia - nitrogen in WWTP discharge management in order to control the excessive growth of periphyton in downstream rivers. ### Research background Wastewater treatment plant discharges usually contain high concentrations of dissolved reactive phosphorus (DRP) and dissolved inorganic nitrogen (DIN), which will stimulate the growth of periphyton in rivers and lead to an increase in biomass. Although phosphorus is traditionally considered the main factor causing excessive algal growth, research shows that the role of nitrogen cannot be ignored, especially during the low - flow period in summer, when the input of nitrogen may exacerbate the excessive growth of algae. In addition, ammonia - nitrogen (NH₄ - N) and nitrate - nitrogen (NO₃ - N), as two different forms of nitrogen, their specific impacts on algal growth are not fully understood. Theoretically, ammonia - nitrogen is a more efficient nitrogen source because it does not require additional energy to be reduced to NH₄⁺, but the actual effects under different environmental conditions need further research. Through this research, the author hopes to fill this knowledge gap and provide a scientific basis for the discharge management of wastewater treatment plants, so as to better control the health of river ecosystems.