Abstract:Metaphors are powerful windows to gain insight into EFL teachers' professional identity constructions. This study examined 33 Chinese EFL student teachers' (STs) self-generated metaphors about teaching before and after their student teaching. Before their teaching practicum experience, they were: (a) optimistic, but had naïve perceptions about their roles, (b) worried about their inadequacy to teach professionally, and (c) anxious about their relationship with cooperating teachers. Post-practicum, we noted (a) increased transformative perceptions about their role, (b) professional knowledge growth, (c) the participants explicated a broad array of challenges of building good student relationships, and (d) the placement-school contexts exert a significant influence on their identity formation. Implications for facilitating EFL student teachers' professional identity (trans)formations during the field experiences are discussed.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
This paper attempts to explore the changes in the professional identities of English as a foreign language (EFL) student - teachers expressed through self - generated metaphors before and after their internships. Specifically, the study focuses on the following two sub - questions:
1. **What views on their professional identities are revealed by the written metaphors of EFL student - teachers at the beginning of the internship?**
2. **What views on their professional identities are revealed by the written metaphors of EFL student - teachers at the end of the internship?**
### Research Background and Problems
#### Background
International scholars generally believe that internships and other practical experiences are crucial for constructing the professional identities of student - teachers. These experiences not only provide future teachers with opportunities to understand their responsibilities, but also help them develop teaching strategies and construct professional identities. However, during the internship, student - teachers may encounter many challenges, such as the immediacy of classroom practice, the needs of the internship school, and the expectations of in - school mentors and university supervisors. Nevertheless, these experiences are also full of multi - level learning and uncertainty, especially during the identity transformation process from student to teacher.
#### Problems
However, it is not always easy to describe a person's identity. Metaphors provide a way to explore the emerging professional identities of teachers. Researchers have long recognized the close relationship between metaphors and teacher identity construction. Although existing studies have used metaphors to explore teacher identity, these studies usually only focus on one metaphor at a specific point in time. This approach is useful in some respects, but also has limitations, because professional identities, especially those of student - teachers in the process of learning how to teach, may be more dynamic.
### Research Purposes
Therefore, this study aims to explore the changes in the professional identities of EFL student - teachers during their internships by analyzing their self - generated metaphors before and after the internships. The researchers hope to answer the following core questions:
- **How do EFL student - teachers express their professional identities through metaphors at the beginning and end of the internship?**
### Methods
The study was conducted in an EFL teacher education program at a four - year university in Zhejiang province. A total of 33 EFL pre - service teachers participated in the study, and they had their internships from the fall of 2017 to the spring of 2018. Participants were required to write metaphors about their professional identities and their explanations at the beginning and end of the internship respectively. The researchers used grounded theory and the constant comparative method to analyze the collected data.
### Main Findings
The study found that the metaphors of EFL student - teachers before and after the internship reflect significant changes in their professional identities. Specifically, these are manifested in the following aspects:
1. **Characteristics of professional identities at the beginning of the internship**:
- **Naive understanding of roles**: Many student - teachers had idealized views of the roles and responsibilities of English teachers at the beginning of the internship. For example, they compared themselves to "sunflowers in the sun" or "beautiful Christmas trees", believing that teachers should base their teaching around the needs of students.
- **Worries about insufficient professional abilities**: Some student - teachers felt that they lacked sufficient professional knowledge and skills to cope with complex teaching tasks. For example, they compared themselves to "lonely shepherds" or "half - cooked steaks".
- **Anxiety about relationships with cooperating teachers**: Due to hierarchical power relationships, student - teachers had difficulty in establishing equal colleague relationships. For example, they compared themselves to "clumsy parrots" or "transfer students".
2. **Characteristics of professional identities at the end of the internship**:
- **Transformed understanding of roles and responsibilities**: After the internship, student - teachers had a deeper understanding of the complexity of English teaching and the multiple roles of teachers. For example, they compared themselves to "parrots that can say a few words" or "eagles flying in the sky".
- **Professional growth**: Student - teachers had accumulated more practical teaching experience. For example, they compared themselves to "a gust of wind" or "bamboo shoots after a spring rain".
- **Shift in educational beliefs from teacher - centered to student - centered**: Student - teachers revised their language teaching beliefs, from traditional teaching methods to more progressive orientations. For example, they compared themselves to "road guides" or "butterflies".
- **Challenges in establishing relationships with students and their parents**: Student - teachers found that winning the trust of students and parents was a challenge. For example, they compared themselves to "hidden love" or "student union presidents".
- **Influence of the internship school environment**: School policies and teaching routines had an important impact on the formation of student - teachers' professional identities. For example, they compared themselves to "three half - cooked steaks" or "wild geese".