A long-lived magma ocean on a young Moon

M. Maurice,N. Tosi,S. Schwinger,D. Breuer,T. Kleine

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1126/sciadv.aba8949

IF: 13.6

2020-07-10

Science Advances

Abstract:Fitting the isotopic composition of lunar rocks to a new thermal and crystallization model shows the Moon formed 4.40 to 4.45 Ga.

multidisciplinary sciences

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

Employing magma ocean crystallization models to constrain structure and composition of the lunar interior

Sabrina Schwinger,Doris Breuer

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.pepi.2021.106831

2021-04-14

Abstract:The process of lunar magma ocean solidification provides constraints on the properties of distinct chemical reservoirs in the lunar mantle that formed during the early evolution of the Moon. We use a combination of phase equilibria models consistent with experimental results on lunar magma ocean crystallization to study the effect of bulk silicate Moon composition on the properties of lunar mantle reservoirs. We find that the densities and relative proportions of these mantle reservoirs, in particular of the late forming ilmenite bearing cumulates (IBC), strongly depend on the FeO content of the bulk silicate Moon. This relation has implications for post-magma ocean mantle dynamics and the mass distribution in the lunar interior, because the dense IBC form at shallow depths but tend to sink towards the core mantle boundary. We quantify the relations between bulk silicate Moon FeO content, IBC thickness and bulk Moon density as well as mantle stratigraphy and bulk silicate Moon moment of inertia to constrain the bulk silicate Moon FeO content and the efficiency of IBC sinking. In combination with seismic and selenodetic constraints on mantle stratigraphy, core radius, extent of the low velocity zone at the core mantle boundary, considerations about the present day selenotherm and the effects of reservoir mixing by convection our model indicates that the bulk silicate Moon is only moderately enriched in FeO compared to the Earths mantle and contains about 9.4 - 10.9 weight percent FeO (with a lowermost limit of 8.3 weight percent and an uppermost limit of 11.9 weight percent). We also conclude that the observed bulk silicate Moon moment of inertia requires incomplete sinking of the IBC layer by mantle convection: only 20 - 60 percent of the IBC material might have reached the core mantle boundary, while the rest either remained at the depth of origin or was mixed into the middle mantle.

Geophysics
Isotopic Geochronological Constraints on the Formation and Evolution of the Moon

Ai-Cheng Zhang,Huai -Yu He,Sen Hu,Xian-Hua Li,Yang -Ting Lin,Li -Ping Qin,Gui-Qin Wang,Zhi-Yong Xiao

DOI: https://doi.org/10.34133/space.0170

2024-01-01

Space Science & Technology

Abstract:One major task of studying the formation and evolution of the Moon is to construct a timeline of the important events with precise isotopic ages. Here, we review recent major isotopic geochronological progress in the past decade and the unsolved problems in isotopic geochronology. The Moon probably formed between 4.52 and 4.42 Ga. Recent high-precision whole-rock and mineral Sm-Nd isotopic dating results suggested that ferroan anorthosite and highlands magnesian suite rocks formed contemporarily around 4.37 to 4.33 Ga. Although the major mare basaltic volcanism took place from 3.85 to 2.93 Ga, new geochronological data from lunar meteorites and Chang’e-5 basalts suggested that lunar basaltic volcanism took place as old as up to 4.37 Ga and at least as young as 2.0 Ga, respectively. Impact events older than 3.9 Ga have also been revealed based on U-bearing minerals Pb/Pb ages and Ar-Ar ages and can provide important clues to understand the late heavy bombardment hypothesis. However, the reliable isotopic ages for the important events on the Moon are still far from conclusive, due to lack of pristine samples that directly crystallized from Lunar Magma Ocean and samples from impact melt sheets in large impact basins (e.g., the South Pole-Aitken basin). In the future, collection and return of pristine samples of ferroan anorthosite and highlands magnesian suite rocks from the farside, cryptomare basalts and late-stage basalts, quartz monzogabbros, granites/felsites, and rocks from impact melt sheets in large impact basins are required for better understanding the formation and evolution of the Moon.
The iodine-plutonium-xenon age of the Moon-Earth system revisited

Guillaume Avice,Bernard Marty

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1511.00952

2015-11-03

Earth and Planetary Astrophysics

Abstract:From iodine-plutonium-xenon isotope systematics, we re-evaluate time constraints on the early evolution of the Earth-atmosphere system and, by inference, on the Moon-forming event. Two extinct radioactivites (129I, T1/2 = 15.6 Ma, and 244Pu, T1/2 = 80 Ma) have produced radiogenic 129Xe and fissiogenic 131-136Xe, respectively, within the Earth, which related isotope fingerprints are seen in the compositions of mantle and atmospheric Xe. Recent studies of Archean rocks suggest that xenon atoms have been lost from the Earth's atmosphere and isotopically fractionated during long periods of geological time, until at least the end of the Archean eon. Here we build a model that takes into account these results. Correction for Xe loss permits to compute new closure ages for the Earth's atmosphere that are in agreement with those computed for mantle Xe. The minimum Xe formation interval for the Earth- atmosphere is 40 (-10+20) Ma after start of solar system formation, which may also date the Moon-forming impact.
Fusible Mantle Cumulates Trigger Young Mare Volcanism on the Cooling Moon

Bin Su,Jiangyan Yuan,Yi Chen,Wei Yang,Ross N. Mitchell,Hejiu Hui,Hao Wang,Hengci Tian,Xian-Hua Li,Fu-Yuan Wu

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1126/sciadv.abn2103

IF: 13.6

2022-01-01

Science Advances

Abstract:The Chang'E-5 (CE5) mission has demonstrated that lunar volcanism was still active until two billion years ago, much younger than the previous isotopically dated lunar basalts. How the small Moon retained enough heat to drive such late volcanism is unknown, particularly as the CE5 mantle source was anhydrous and depleted in heat-producing elements. We conduct fractional crystallization and mantle melting simulations that show that mantle melting point depression by the presence of fusible, easily melted components could trigger young volcanism. Enriched in calcium oxide and titanium dioxide compared to older Apollo magmas, the young CE5 magma was, thus, sourced from the overturn of the late-stage fusible cumulates of the lunar magma ocean. Mantle melting point depression is the first mechanism to account for young volcanism on the Moon that is consistent with the newly returned CE5 basalts.
A 3‐D Numerical Study of the Thermal Evolution of the Moon after Cumulate Mantle Overturn: the Importance of Rheology and Core Solidification

Nan Zhang,E. M. Parmentier,Yan Liang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1002/jgre.20121

2013-01-01

Journal of Geophysical Research Planets

Abstract:Models in which the mantle of the Moon evolves from an initially stratified state following magma ocean solidification and overturn have been applied to address important features of long-term thermal evolution of the Moon, including convective instability of overturned ilmenite-bearing cumulates (IBC) at the lunar core-mantle boundary, generation of mare basalts, core sulfur content and inner core radius, paleomagnetism, and the present-day mantle structure. Whether a dense overturned IBC-rich layer at the bottom of the mantle can become thermally unstable to generate a single upwelling is controlled largely by the temperature-dependence of viscosity (the activation energy). Convective instability of the IBC-rich layer controls the heat flux out the core and the presence of an internally generated magnetic field. A long period of (similar to 700Ma) high positive core-mantle-boundary (CMB) heat flux after the instability of the IBC-rich layer is expected from our models. Present-day deep mantle temperatures inferred from seismic and gravitational inversion constrain the magnitude of mantle viscosity from 5x10(19) to 1x10(21)Pas. The CMB temperature and solidified inner core radius inferred from seismic reflection constrain the core sulfur content. Our evolution models with 5-10wt% sulfur content can produce the observed 240km radius inner core at the present day. The asymmetrical distribution of the deep moonquakes only in the nearside mantle could be explained as the remnant structure of the single chemical upwelling generated from IBC-rich layer. Our evolution model after the overturn results in an early similar to 0.55km expansion in radius for similar to 1000Ma due to the radiogenic heating associated with IBC in the deep mantle and may provide a simple explanation for the early expansion inferred from the Gravity Recovery and Interior Laboratory mission.
Long-lived lunar volcanism sustained by precession-driven core-mantle friction

Shuoran Yu,Xiao Xiao,Shengxia Gong,Nicola Tosi,Jun Huang,Doris Breuer,Long Xiao,Dongdong Ni

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1093/nsr/nwad276

IF: 20.6

2023-10-31

National Science Review

Abstract:Abstract Core-mantle friction induced by the precession of the Moon’s spin axis is a strong heat source in the deep lunar mantle during the early phase of satellite’s evolution, but its influence on the long-term thermal evolution still remains poorly explored. Using a 1-D thermal evolution model, we show that core-mantle friction can sustain global-scale partial melting in the upper lunar mantle until ∼3.1 Ga, thus accounting for the intense volcanic activity on the Moon before ∼3.0 Ga. Besides, core-mantle friction tends to suppress the secular cooling of the lunar core and is unlikely to be an energy source for the long-lived lunar core dynamo. Our model also favours the transition of Cassini state before the end of the lunar magma ocean phase (∼4.2 Ga), which implies a decreasing lunar obliquity over time after the solidification of the lunar magma ocean. Such a trend of lunar obliquity evolution may allow volcanically-released water to be buried in the lunar regolith of the polar regions. As a consequence, the local water-ice could be more abundant than previously thought by considering only its accumulation caused by solar wind and comet spreading.

multidisciplinary sciences
Forming the Moon from terrestrial silicate-rich material

R.J. de Meijer,V.F. Anisichkin,W. van Westrenen

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.chemgeo.2012.12.015

2013-01-12

Abstract:Recent high-precision measurements of the isotopic composition of lunar rocks demonstrate that the bulk silicate Earth and the Moon show an unexpectedly high degree of similarity. This is inconsistent with one of the primary results of classic dynamical simulations of the widely accepted giant impact model for the formation of the Moon, namely that most of the mass of the Moon originates from the impactor, not Earth. Resolution of this discrepancy without changing the main premises of the giant impact model requires total isotopic homogenisation of Earth and impactor material after the impact for a wide range of elements including O, Si, K, Ti, Nd and W. Even if this process could explain the O isotope similarity, it is unlikely to work for the much heavier, refractory elements. Given the increasing uncertainty surrounding the giant impact model in light of these geochemical data, alternative hypotheses for lunar formation should be explored. In this paper, we revisit the hypothesis that the Moon was formed directly from terrestrial mantle material. We show that the dynamics of this scenario requires a large amount of energy, almost instantaneously generated additional energy. The only known source for this additional energy is nuclear fission. We show that it is feasible to form the Moon through the ejection of terrestrial silicate material triggered by a nuclear explosion at Earths core-mantle boundary (CMB), causing a shock wave propagating through the Earth. Hydrodynamic modelling of this scenario shows that a shock wave created by rapidly expanding plasma resulting from the explosion disrupts and expels overlying mantle and crust material.

Earth and Planetary Astrophysics
Crustal Remelting Origin of Highly Silicic Magmatism on the Moon

Bin Su,Yi Chen,Zongyu Yue,Lin Chen,Ross N. Mitchell,Ming Tang,Wei Yang,Guangyu Huang,Jinghui Guo,Xian-Hua Li,Fu-Yuan Wu

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1038/s43247-023-00900-8

2023-01-01

Communications Earth & Environment

Abstract:Orbital observations of non-mare, highly silicic volcanic constructs on the Moon challenge the conventional view of the formation of silicic crusts in the presence of water and plate tectonics—the former the Moon has in very short supply and the latter it likely never ever had. Revealing the silica-rich magma origin may reshape our understanding of early planetary crust formation. However, the cause of lunar silicic magmatism remains enigmatic. Here we conduct phase equilibrium simulations for potential lunar igneous lithologies that demonstrate that the compositions of silicic volcanic constructs can be produced by partial melting of KREEP (potassium, rare earth elements, and phosphorus) basalts. Either internal radiogenic heating or external impact bombardment can provide the heat needed for KREEP basalt melting. Combined with silica-rich materials identified on other rocky planets, we suggest that highly evolved crusts might be more prevalent in the early solar system than anticipated as they can originate from crustal remelting in the absence of water and plate tectonics.
A Possible High-Temperature Origin of the Moon and Its Geochemical Consequences

E. S. Steenstra,J. Berndt,S. Klemme,Y. Fei,W. van Westrenen

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.epsl.2020.116222

IF: 5.3

2020-01-01

Earth and Planetary Science Letters

Abstract:The formation of the Moon is thought to be the result of a giant impact between a Mercury-to-proto-Earth-sized body and the proto-Earth. However, the initial thermal state of the Moon following its accretion is not well constrained by geochemical data. Here, we provide geochemical evidence that supports a high-temperature origin of the Moon by performing high-temperature (1973-2873 K) metal-silicate partitioning experiments, simulating core formation in the newly-formed Moon. Results indicate that the observed lunar mantle depletions of Ni and Co record extreme temperatures (>2600-3700 K depending on assumptions about the composition of the lunar core) during lunar core formation. This temperature range is within range of the modeled silicate evaporation buffer in a synestia-type environment. Our results provide independent geochemical support for a giant-impact origin of the Moon and show that lunar thermal models should start with a fully molten Moon. Our results also provide quantitative constraints on the effects of high-temperature lunar differentiation on the lunar mantle geochemistry of volatile, and potentially siderophile elements Cu, Zn, Ga, Ge, Se, Sn, Cd, In, Te and Pb. At the extreme temperatures recorded by Ni and Co, many of these elements behave insufficiently siderophile to explain their depletions by core formation only, consistent with the inferred volatility related loss of Cr, Cu, Zn, Ga and Sn during the Moon-forming event and/or subsequent magma-ocean degassing. (C) 2020 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
Abundances of Lunar Heat-Producing Elements Constrained by a 3-D Numerical Model of Titanium-Rich Basaltic Eruption

Zhang WenBo,Zhang Nan,Li HaoYuan

DOI: https://doi.org/10.6038/cjg2022p0753

2022-01-01

Abstract:Remote-sensing data and returned samples of mare basalts and mafic lunar glasses revealed that their petrogenesis are from lunar mantle and their temporal-spatial distributions can originate from multi-stage volcanism. Hence, these basalts and glasses are believed to be closely related to a long-term thermochemical evolution of the global lunar mantle. The thermochemical evolution is largely controlled by bulk abundances of radioactive heat-producing elements and mechanic properties of lunar solid layers. This study considers the early cumulate mantle overturn and subsequent basaltic volcanism due to re-heated ilmenite bearing lunar mantle. These processes are well-established thermochemical evolution model and provide a viable mechanism for the formation of mare basalts and lunar glasses. We use the observed episodes and distributions of mare basalts to constrain the heat-producing elements abundances and lunar mantle viscosity. To produce reasonable hot mantle anomalies for distributed lunar volcanism and fit in the first mare eruption at 3.9 Ga, our model prefers an estimate of radiogenic heat similar to that of our Earth and a maximum lunar viscosity of 1 X 10(21) Pa . s. Our model also reveals that different internal heat generation does not vary in mantle evolution pattern, but the eruption time scale.
Two-billion-year-old volcanism on the Moon from Chang’e-5 basalts

Qiu-Li Li,Qin Zhou,Yu Liu,Zhiyong Xiao,Yangting Lin,Jin-Hua Li,Hong-Xia Ma,Guo-Qiang Tang,Shun Guo,Xu Tang,Jiang-Yan Yuan,Jiao Li,Fu-Yuan Wu,Ziyuan Ouyang,Chunlai Li,Xian-Hua Li

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1038/s41586-021-04100-2

IF: 64.8

2021-10-19

Nature

Abstract:Abstract The Moon has a magmatic and thermal history that is distinct from that of the terrestrial planets 1 . Radioisotope dating of lunar samples suggests that most lunar basaltic magmatism ceased by around 2.9–2.8 billion years ago (Ga) 2,3 , although younger basalts between 3 Ga and 1 Ga have been suggested by crater-counting chronology, which has large uncertainties owing to the lack of returned samples for calibration 4,5 . Here we report a precise lead–lead age of 2,030 ± 4 million years ago for basalt clasts returned by the Chang’e-5 mission, and a 238 U/ 204 Pb ratio ( μ value) 6 of about 680 for a source that evolved through two stages of differentiation. This is the youngest crystallization age reported so far for lunar basalts by radiometric dating, extending the duration of lunar volcanism by approximately 800–900 million years. The μ value of the Chang’e-5 basalt mantle source is within the range of low-titanium and high-titanium basalts from Apollo sites ( μ value of about 300–1,000), but notably lower than those of potassium, rare-earth elements and phosphorus (KREEP) and high-aluminium basalts 7 ( μ value of about 2,600–3,700), indicating that the Chang’e-5 basalts were produced by melting of a KREEP-poor source. This age provides a pivotal calibration point for crater-counting chronology in the inner Solar System and provides insight on the volcanic and thermal history of the Moon.

multidisciplinary sciences
Hydrodynamical simulations of proto-Moon degassing

Gustavo Madeira,Leandro Esteves,Sebastien Charnoz,Elena Lega,Frederic Moynier

2024-12-02

Abstract:Similarities in the non-mass dependent isotopic composition of refractory elements with the bulk silicate Earth suggest that both the Earth and the Moon formed from the same material reservoir. On the other hand, the Moon's volatile depletion and isotopic composition of moderately volatile elements points to a global devolatilization processes, most likely during a magma ocean phase of the Moon. Here, we investigate the devolatilisation of the molten Moon due to a tidally-assisted hydrodynamic escape with a focus on the dynamics of the evaporated gas. Unlike the 1D steady-state approach of Charnoz et al. (2021), we use 2D time-dependent hydrodynamic simulations carried out with the FARGOCA code modified to take into account the magma ocean as a gas source. Near the Earth's Roche limit, where the proto-Moon likely formed, evaporated gases from the lunar magma ocean form a circum-Earth disk of volatiles, with less than 30% of material being re-accreted by the Moon. We find that the measured depletion of K and Na on the Moon can be achieved if the lunar magma-ocean had a surface temperature of about 1800-2000 K. After about 1000 years, a thermal boundary layer or a flotation crust forms a lid that inhibits volatile escape. Mapping the volatile velocity field reveals varying trends in the longitudes of volatile reaccretion on the Moon's surface: material is predominantly re-accreted on the trailing side when the Moon-Earth distance exceeds 3.5 Earth radii, suggesting a dichotomy in volatile abundances between the leading and trailing sides of the Moon. This dichotomy may provide insights on the tidal conditions of the early molten Earth. In conclusion, tidally-driven atmospheric escape effectively devolatilizes the Moon, matching the measured abundances of Na and K on timescales compatible with the formation of a thermal boundary layer or an anorthite flotation crust.

Earth and Planetary Astrophysics
Orthopyroxene-dominated Upper Mantle Melting Built the Early Crust of the Moon

Si-Zhang Sheng,Bin Su,Shui-Jiong Wang,Yi Chen,Li,Hao Wang,Hejiu Hui,Shitou Wu,Bo Zhang,Jiang-Yan Yuan

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1038/s43247-024-01574-6

2024-01-01

Communications Earth & Environment

Abstract:The paradigm of lunar crust formation has been widely applied to other terrestrial bodies, but the nature of early crust building on the Moon remains enigmatic. Here we report non-Apollo-like highland clasts from the Chang’e-5 mission and find high-alumina melts enclosed in a noritic anorthosite. Geochemistry and phase equilibria modeling suggest that the melt is compositionally parental to lunar magnesian-suite rocks, and was sourced from a plagioclase-bearing, orthopyroxene-dominated upper mantle ( ~ 4.5 kbar and 1225°C). It was formed as a direct consequence of upper mantle melting at the onset of gravitational instability. We propose a continuous early crust formation on the Moon, started from multiple anorthositic cumulate flotations, to upper mantle melting caused by small-scale, in-situ overturn, and eventually ended up by decompression melting of lower mantle cumulates following large-scale, global overturn. The first magma on the Moon formed by decompression melting of orthopyroxene-dominated mantle rocks facilitated by density-driven mantle overturn, according to petrographic modelling and observations of lunar highland samples from the Chang’e-5 mission
First-principles Calculations of Equilibrium Ca Isotope Fractionation: Implications for Oldhamite Formation and Evolution of Lunar Magma Ocean

Fang Huang,Chen Zhou,Wenzhong Wang,Jinting Kang,Zhongqing Wu

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.epsl.2018.12.034

IF: 5.3

2019-01-01

Earth and Planetary Science Letters

Abstract:Calcium is a major element of the Earth, the Moon, terrestrial planets, and rocky meteorites. Here we present equilibrium Ca isotope fractionation factors of Ca-bearing minerals using the first-principles calculations based on density functional theory (OFT). The sequence of minerals from the isotopically heaviest to the lightest in Ca is forsterite > orthopyroxene (opx) > grossular similar to pigeonite > diopside > anorthite > oldhamite. Overall, the equilibrium fractionation of Ca isotopes is mainly controlled by the average bond lengths. Although oldhamite is enriched in light Ca isotopes relative to silicate minerals in equilibrium, natural oldhamite of enstatite chondrites are isotopically heavier than coexisting silicate materials. This implies that enstatite chondrites oldhamites should have been formed during solar nebular gas condensation instead than during parent body processing. Following previous models for crystallization of the Lunar Magma Ocean (LMO), we simulated Ca isotopic fractionation of the LMO based on our calculated equilibrium Ca isotope fractionation factors. It shows that the delta Ca-44/40 of the lunar anorthositic crust should be lower than the average of the bulk Moon by 0.09-0.11 parts per thousand. Considering that the lunar mantle might have overturned and mixed after solidification of the LMO, we further predict that the lunar mantle should be isotopically heavier than the bulk Moon by 0.17-0.26 parts per thousand if the mantle was fully overturned, or only by 0.06-0.08 parts per thousand for the case of fully mixing. Therefore, we predict that the potential offset of Ca isotopic composition between the anorthositic crust and the lunar mantle can be used to test LMO evolution models. (C) 2019 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
Effect of Re-impacting Debris on the Solidification of the Lunar Magma Ocean

Viranga Perera,Alan P. Jackson,Linda T. Elkins-Tanton,Erik Asphaug

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1029/2017JE005512

2018-04-13

Abstract:Anorthosites that comprise the bulk of the lunar crust are believed to have formed during solidification of a Lunar Magma Ocean (LMO) in which these rocks would have floated to the surface. This early flotation crust would have formed a thermal blanket over the remaining LMO, prolonging solidification. Geochronology of lunar anorthosites indicates a long timescale of LMO cooling, or re-melting and re-crystallization in one or more late events. To better interpret this geochronology, we model LMO solidification in a scenario where the Moon is being continuously bombarded by returning projectiles released from the Moon-forming giant impact. More than one lunar mass of material escaped the Earth-Moon system onto heliocentric orbits following the giant impact, much of it to come back on returning orbits for a period of 100 Myr. If large enough, these projectiles would have punctured holes in the nascent floatation crust of the Moon, exposing the LMO to space and causing more rapid cooling. We model these scenarios using a thermal evolution model of the Moon that allows for production (by cratering) and evolution (solidification and infill) of holes in the flotation crust that insulates the LMO. For effective hole production, solidification of the magma ocean can be significantly expedited, decreasing the cooling time by more than a factor of 5. If hole production is inefficient, but shock conversion of projectile kinetic energy to thermal energy is efficient, then LMO solidification can be somewhat prolonged, lengthening the cooling time by 50% or more.

Earth and Planetary Astrophysics
Composition, Structure and Origin of the Moon

Paolo A. Sossi,Miki Nakajima,Amir Khan

2024-08-30

Abstract:Here we critically examine the geophysical and geochemical properties of the Moon in order to identify the extent to which dynamical scenarios satisfy these observations. New joint inversions of existing lunar geophysical data (mean mass, moment of inertia, and tidal response) assuming a laterally- and vertically homogeneous lunar mantle show that, in all cases, a core with a radius of 300$\pm$20 km ($\sim$0.8 to 1.5 % the mass of the Moon) is required. However, an Earth-like Mg# (0.89) in the lunar mantle results in core densities (7800$\pm$100 kg/m$^3$) consistent with that of Fe-Ni alloy, whereas FeO-rich compositions (Mg# = 0.80--0.84) require lower densities (6100$\pm$800 kg/m$^3$). Geochemically, we use new data on mare basalts to reassess the bulk composition of the Moon for 70 elements, and show that the lunar core likely formed near 5 GPa, 2100 K and $\sim$1 log unit below the iron-wüstite buffer. Moreover, the Moon is depleted relative to the Earth's mantle in elements with volatilities higher than that of Li, with this volatile loss likely having occurred at low temperatures (1400$\pm$100 K), consistent with mass-dependent stable isotope fractionation of moderately volatile elements (e.g., Zn, K, Rb). The identical nucleosynthetic (O, Cr, Ti) and radiogenic (W) isotope compositions of the lunar and terrestrial mantles, strongly suggest the two bodies were made from the same material, rather than from an Earth-like impactor. Rb-Sr in FANs and Lu-Hf and Pb-Pb zircon ages point Moon formation close to $\sim$4500 Ma. Taken together, there is no unambiguous geochemical or isotopic evidence for the role of an impactor in the formation of the Moon, implying perfect equilibration between the proto-Earth and Moon-forming material or alternative scenarios for its genesis.

Earth and Planetary Astrophysics,Geophysics
Resurgence of Lunar Volcanism: Role of Localized Radioactive Enrichment in a Numerical Model of Magmatism and Mantle Convection

Ken'yo Uh,Masanori Kameyama,Gaku Nishiyama,Takehiro Miyagoshi,Masaki Ogawa

2024-07-10

Abstract:We develop a 2-D numerical model of magmatism and mantle convection to understand the volcanism on the Procellarum KREEP terrane (PKT) of the Moon, which continued for billions of years with two peaks of activities at 3.5-4 Gyr ago and around 2 Gyr ago. In our model, the effects of the PKT on lunar evolution are considered by initially imposing a region of localized radioactive enrichment. The calculated volcanism has two peaks induced by different mechanisms. The first peak occurs at 3.5-4 Gyr ago when magma generated in the deep mantle by internal heating ascends to the surface as partially molten plumes. The basaltic blocks in the uppermost mantle formed by this magmatism, then, sink to the deep mantle, triggering further plumes that cause the resurgence of volcanism at $\sim$2 Gyr ago. Our model shows that localized radioactive enrichment is important for the long-lasting volcanism with a couple of peaks.

Geophysics,Earth and Planetary Astrophysics
High-precision U-Pb zircon dating identifies a major magmatic event on the Moon at 4.338 Ga

Mélanie Barboni,Dawid Szymanowski,Blair Schoene,Nicolas Dauphas,Zhe J. Zhang,Xi Chen,Kevin D. McKeegan

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1126/sciadv.adn9871

IF: 13.6

2024-07-26

Science Advances

Abstract:The Moon has had a complex history, with evidence of its primary crust formation obscured by later impacts. Existing U-Pb dates of >500 zircons from several locations on the lunar nearside reveal a pronounced age peak at 4.33 billion years (Ga), suggesting a major, potentially global magmatic event. However, the precision of existing geochronology is insufficient to determine whether this peak represents a brief event or a more protracted period of magmatism occurring over tens of millions of years. To improve the temporal resolution, we have analyzed Apollo 14, 15, and 17 zircons that were previously dated by ion microprobe at ~4.33 Ga using isotope dilution thermal ionization mass spectrometry. Concordant dates with sub-million-year uncertainty span ~4 million years from 4.338 to 4.334 Ga. Combined with Hf isotopic ratios and trace element concentrations, the data suggest zircon formation in a large impact melt sheet, possibly linked to the South Pole–Aitken basin.

multidisciplinary sciences
A changing thermal regime revealed from shallow to deep basalt source melting in the Moon

Yash Srivastava,Amit Basu Sarbadhikari,James M. D. Day,Akira Yamaguchi,Atsushi Takenouchi

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467-022-35260-y

IF: 16.6

2022-12-09

Nature Communications

Abstract:Sample return missions have provided the basis for understanding the thermochemical evolution of the Moon. Mare basalt sources are likely to have originated from partial melting of lunar magma ocean cumulates after solidification from an initially molten state. Some of the Apollo mare basalts show evidence for the presence in their source of a late-stage radiogenic heat-producing incompatible element-rich layer, known for its enrichment in potassium, rare-earth elements, and phosphorus (KREEP). Here we show the most depleted lunar meteorite, Asuka-881757, and associated mare basalts, represent ancient (~3.9 Ga) partial melts of KREEP-free Fe-rich mantle. Petrological modeling demonstrates that these basalts were generated at lower temperatures and shallower depths than typical Apollo mare basalts. Calculated mantle potential temperatures of these rocks suggest a relatively cooler mantle source and lower surface heat flow than those associated with later-erupted mare basalts, suggesting a fundamental shift in melting regime in the Moon from ~3.9 to ~3.3 Ga.

multidisciplinary sciences
The volcanic and radial expansion/contraction history of the Moon simulated by numerical models of magmatism in the convective mantle

Ken'yo U,Masanori Kameyama,Masaki Ogawa

2023-03-29

Abstract:To understand the evolution of the Moon, we numerically modeled mantle convection and magmatism in a two-dimensional polar rectangular mantle. Magmatism occurs as an upward permeable flow of magma generated by decompression melting through the convecting matrix. The mantle is assumed to be initially enriched in heat-producing elements (HPEs) and compositionally dense ilmenite-bearing cumulates (IBC) at its base. Here, we newly show that magma generation and migration play a crucial role in the calculated volcanic and radial expansion/contraction history. Magma is generated in the deep mantle by internal heating for the first several hundred million years. A large volume of the generated magma ascends to the surface as partially molten fingers and plumes driven by melt-buoyancy to cause a volcanic activity and radial expansion of the planet with the peak at 3.5-4 Gyr ago. Eventually, however, the planet begins to radially contract when the mantle solidifies by cooling from the surface boundary. As the mantle is cooled, the activity of partially molten plumes declines but continues for billions of years after the peak because some basal materials enriched in the dense IBC components hold HPEs. The calculated volcanic and radial expansion/contraction history is consistent with the observed history of the Moon. Our simulations suggest a substantial fraction of the mantle was solid, and there was a basal layer enriched in HPEs and the IBC components at the beginning of the history of the Moon.

Earth and Planetary Astrophysics,Geophysics

A long-lived magma ocean on a young Moon

Employing magma ocean crystallization models to constrain structure and composition of the lunar interior

Isotopic Geochronological Constraints on the Formation and Evolution of the Moon

The iodine-plutonium-xenon age of the Moon-Earth system revisited

Fusible Mantle Cumulates Trigger Young Mare Volcanism on the Cooling Moon

A 3‐D Numerical Study of the Thermal Evolution of the Moon after Cumulate Mantle Overturn: the Importance of Rheology and Core Solidification

Long-lived lunar volcanism sustained by precession-driven core-mantle friction

Forming the Moon from terrestrial silicate-rich material

Crustal Remelting Origin of Highly Silicic Magmatism on the Moon

A Possible High-Temperature Origin of the Moon and Its Geochemical Consequences

Abundances of Lunar Heat-Producing Elements Constrained by a 3-D Numerical Model of Titanium-Rich Basaltic Eruption

Two-billion-year-old volcanism on the Moon from Chang’e-5 basalts

Hydrodynamical simulations of proto-Moon degassing

Orthopyroxene-dominated Upper Mantle Melting Built the Early Crust of the Moon

First-principles Calculations of Equilibrium Ca Isotope Fractionation: Implications for Oldhamite Formation and Evolution of Lunar Magma Ocean

Effect of Re-impacting Debris on the Solidification of the Lunar Magma Ocean

Composition, Structure and Origin of the Moon

Resurgence of Lunar Volcanism: Role of Localized Radioactive Enrichment in a Numerical Model of Magmatism and Mantle Convection

High-precision U-Pb zircon dating identifies a major magmatic event on the Moon at 4.338 Ga

A changing thermal regime revealed from shallow to deep basalt source melting in the Moon

The volcanic and radial expansion/contraction history of the Moon simulated by numerical models of magmatism in the convective mantle