High-performance work systems and job performance: the mediating role of social identity, social climate and empowerment in Chinese banks

Timothy Bartram,Brian Cooper,Fang Lee Cooke,Jue Wang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1108/pr-08-2019-0425

IF: 3.228

2020-07-14

Personnel Review

Abstract:Purpose Despite the utility of social identity and social climate theories in explaining individual and group behaviour within organizations, little research has been conducted on how these approaches interconnect to explain the way high-performance work systems (HPWSs) may increase job performance. This study extends one’s understanding of the human resource management (HRM)–performance relationship by examining the interconnections between these disparate social approaches within the Chinese banking context. Design/methodology/approach Drawing on a sample of 561 employees working across 62 bank branches in China, the authors test four hypotheses: (1) HPWS is positively related to social climate; (2) social climate mediates the relationship between HPWS and social identification; (3) psychological empowerment mediates the relationship between social identification and job performance; and (4) social climate, social identification and psychological empowerment sequentially mediate the relationship between HPWS and job performance. Data were collected over two waves and job (in-role) performance was rated by managers. Findings The authors confirm the four hypotheses. Social climate, social identification and psychological empowerment sequentially mediate the relationship between HPWS and job performance. Research limitations/implications This study contains some limitations. First, the authors’ research sites were focussed on one main region in state-owned banks in China. Second, this study examined only one industry with a relatively homogeneous workforce (i.e. relatively young and highly educated employees). Practical implications HPWS may translate into individual performance through a supportive social climate in which staff identify themselves with their work team. This suggests that organizations should pay close attention to understanding how their HPWS system can foster a strong social climate to enhance employee identification at the work group level. Second, as the nature of work is becoming increasingly more complex and interdependent, enabling not just individuals but also work groups to function effectively, it is critical for departments and work groups to promote a collective understanding of HRM messages with shared values and goals. Originality/value This research contributes towards a more comprehensive understanding of the HRM–performance chain as a complex social process underpinned by social identity theory. The authors demonstrate that social identification and social climate both play an important role in explaining how HPWS positively affects psychological empowerment and subsequent job performance.

management,industrial relations & labor,psychology, applied

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is: How does the High - Performance Work System (HPWS) influence employees' job performance through social mechanisms (such as social climate, social identity and social empowerment)? Specifically, the authors hope to explore how, in the context of China's banking industry, HPWS can enhance employees' social identity by promoting a positive social climate, and ultimately improve employees' job performance through psychological empowerment. The paper explores these relationships by proposing four hypotheses:

1. **The relationship between HPWS and social climate**: Hypothesis 1 holds that there is a positive correlation between HPWS and social climate.
2. **The mediating role of social climate between HPWS and social identity**: Hypothesis 2 holds that social climate plays a mediating role between HPWS and social identity.
3. **The mediating role of psychological empowerment between social identity and job performance**: Hypothesis 3 holds that psychological empowerment plays a mediating role between social identity and job performance.
4. **The sequential mediating role of social climate, social identity and psychological empowerment between HPWS and job performance**: Hypothesis 4 holds that social climate, social identity and psychological empowerment play mediating roles in sequence between HPWS and job performance.

Through these hypotheses, the paper aims to reveal how HPWS promotes employees' job performance through multi - level social processes (such as social climate, social identity and psychological empowerment), thus providing a new perspective for human resource management and organizational behavior research.