Application of Beta-Distribution and Combined Uniform and Binomial Methods in Longitudinal Modeling of Bounded Outcome Score Data

Chuanpu Hu,Honghui Zhou,Amarnath Sharma
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1208/s12248-020-00478-5
2020-07-21
The AAPS Journal
Abstract:Disease status is often measured with bounded outcome scores (BOS) which takes a discrete set of values on a finite range. The distribution of such data is often skewed, rendering the standard analysis methods assuming normal distribution inappropriate. Among the methods used for BOS analyses, two of them have the ability to predict the data within its natural range and accommodate data skewness: (1) a recently proposed beta-distribution based approach and (2) a mixture model known as CUB (combined uniform and binomial). This manuscript compares the two approaches, using an established mechanism-based longitudinal exposure-response model to analyze data from a phase 2 clinical trial in psoriatic patients. The beta-distribution–based approach was confirmed to perform well, and CUB also showed potential. A separate issue of modeling clinical trial data is that the collected baseline disease score range may be more limited than that of post-treatment disease score due to clinical trial inclusion criteria, a fact that is typically ignored in longitudinal modeling. The effect of baseline disease status restriction should in principle be adjusted for in longitudinal modeling.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?