Abstract:This paper presents a comparative analysis investigating how cultural values are represented in two sets of widely used Chinese as a second language (CSL) textbooks published in mainland China (New Practical Chinese Reader, NPCR) and the US (Integrated Chinese, IC) respectively. Using an integrated critical social semiotic approach, we examined the image-text semiotic relations as well as their cultural meaning potentials in textbook content focused on cultural values around education. We found that (1) there are three types of image-text relations, namely, denotational/pedagogic/linguistic relations, denotational/pedagogic relations, and denotational relations; (2) IC is notable because the images are occasionally involved in pedagogic activities, which amounts to a kind of guided semiosis (Weninger, C., & Kiss, T. (2013). Culture in English as a Foreign language (EFL) textbooks: A semiotic approach. <i>Tesol Quarterly</i>, <i>47</i>(4), 694–716.); (3) IC presents more opportunities to engage the readers in critical and comparative reflections on Chinese cultural values, while in NPCR the cultural meanings invoked by the pictures are mostly denotational in nature, missing opportunities to explore deeper cultural interpretations. Discussions and implications on the development of cultural content in language textbooks have been offered in reference to intercultural authenticity and reflection-in-action.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is: how to present Chinese cultural values, especially educational values, in Chinese as a second language (CSL) textbooks. Specifically, through a comparative analysis of two widely - used CSL textbooks - "New Practical Chinese Reader" (NPCR) and "Integrated Chinese" (IC), the author explores the following issues:
1. **Presentation of cultural content**: What Chinese cultural content, especially values related to education, is included in these two textbooks?
2. **Presentation methods**: How are these cultural contents expressed through the relationship between image - text - teaching activities? Are there different types of image - text relationships, such as ideational / didactic / linguistic relationships, ideational / didactic relationships, or simply ideational relationships?
### Research background
With the development of globalization and cross - cultural communication, cultural teaching in language education has become increasingly important. Textbooks, as an important source of target - language input and cultural knowledge, play a crucial role in second - language education. However, there are some disputes and discussions regarding the presentation and representation of cultural content in textbooks. For example, is the presentation of Chinese culture too China - centric, ignoring the cultural and identity recognition of international learners? In addition, how to balance traditional Chinese culture and modern social and cultural themes is also an important research topic.
### Research methods
The author adopts the method of critical social semiotics, focusing on analyzing the image - text relationships in textbooks and their potential for cultural significance. Specific steps include:
1. **Preliminary screening**: Identify 12 images related to educational values and their adjacent texts.
2. **Classification analysis**: Determine the types of image - text relationships, including ideational / didactic / linguistic relationships, ideational / didactic relationships, and ideational relationships.
3. **Social semiotics analysis**: Based on the systemic - functional model, analyze three categories of visual meaning: representational meaning, interactive meaning, and compositional meaning.
### Main findings
Through a comparative analysis of "Integrated Chinese" (IC) and "New Practical Chinese Reader" (NPCR), the author draws the following conclusions:
1. **IC textbook**:
- It more often guides readers to engage in critical and comparative reflection, providing more opportunities for readers to explore in - depth cultural interpretations.
- Images are not only used to illustrate text content but also often participate in didactic activities, promoting readers' cultural thinking and learning.
2. **NPCR textbook**:
- Cultural meanings are mainly directly conveyed by pictures, lacking opportunities to guide readers to explore in - depth.
- Images are mainly used to illustrate certain words or topics and are less involved in deeper - level cultural interpretations.
### Conclusion
This study emphasizes the factors that should be considered when presenting cultural content in CSL textbooks, including how to balance traditional and modern cultures and how to guide readers to think critically. From the perspective of critical social semiotics, the author calls on textbook writers to pay more attention to the diversity and depth of cultural content to promote cross - cultural communication and understanding.
### Example of formula display
Although this article does not involve specific mathematical, physical, chemical, or biological formulas, in other related fields, the Markdown format of formulas is as follows:
```markdown
$$ E = mc^2 $$
```
This will be presented as: \[ E = mc^2 \]
Hope this information is helpful to you! If you have any further questions, please feel free to ask.