Culture Industries

Derek Johnson
DOI: https://doi.org/10.4324/9781351015233-14
2020-08-04
Abstract:Despite the limitations of Frankfurt School critiques, this chapter argues that critical media industry studies research would benefit from closer integration with “culture industry” (or culture industries) perspectives. Attuned to the “totality” of media industry institutions, such a critical lens can reveal connections between the print, recording, screen, and now digital industries and other material cultures of production and consumption in which media industries are intertwined. At the same time, developing critiques of the culture industries – rather than media industries so narrowly defined – permits deeper understanding of the linkages between media and a host of other, separate industries such as fashion, merchandising, tourism, and more. In doing so, the critical investment of the culture industries tradition bears the potential to shore up the critical edge of media industry studies: against media industry scholars’ tendency to be descriptive and engage in projects that map how institutional cultures of production, distribution, and delivery operate, insistence on a culture industries perspective reasserts the importance of ideological critiques that speak to the stakes in those institutional cultures and explain why they matter. Finally, an emphasis on culture more broadly can help draw connections between media industries and the realms of everyday life in which its products are circulated and its ideologies consumed. To explore the possibilities of such a perspective, the chapter suggests that closer consideration of media-licensed toy merchandising from this culture industries perspective offers just one such productive opportunity to better understand and critique the power of media. This chapter explains arguments in turn but first it will be useful to reflect on the origins of the culture industries as a critical lens and its adaptation over time. The different strategies and logics are explained at play in different culture industries while investigating the ways in which they might simultaneously operate in relation to one another. In that sense, a focus on the culture industries can also afford critical media industry studies with a framework for understanding the participation of non-professional subjects in the cultural relations of industry. However, critical media industry studies could take a step back from the investigation of play produced and experienced for the digital screen to give greater consideration to the culture industries that have commoditized play in other material forms throughout the industrial age and continuing into the present. The cultural industries could prove equally productive if integrated into the concerns of the critical media studies project.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?