Reducing homework stress by increasing adoption of need-supportive practices: Effects of an intervention with parents

Angelica Moè,Idit Katz,Rinat Cohen,Marianna Alesi
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.lindif.2020.101921
IF: 3.897
2020-08-01
Learning and Individual Differences
Abstract:Homework is widely recognized as a source of stress for both parents and children, but the underlying mechanisms remain unclear. This study tested the hypothesis that the frustration of the basic psychological needs for competence, autonomy and relatedness is the main source of stress and that satisfying these needs should reduce stress and lead to more positive outcomes. Study 1 assessed the associations between parental and child need frustration, homework stress and parental adoption of need-thwarting practices (n = 171 parent/child dyads). Study 2 tested the effectiveness of a four-session parental training (n = 55) program focused on helping parents increase their need-supportive practices. Study 1 confirmed that the more parents experience homework as need-frustrating, the more their children report stress. This finding was mediated by the stress the parents themselves experience, parents' tendency to adopt need-thwarting practices, and the child's experience of homework as need-frustrating. Study 2 showed that a brief intervention aimed at supporting parental need satisfaction reduced parental and child stress and improved parental adoption of need-supportive practices. The theoretical and educational implications are discussed.
psychology, educational
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The main problems that this paper attempts to solve are the stress brought by homework and its impact on parents and children. Specifically, the researchers hope to explore the following points: 1. **Sources of homework stress**: The research attempts to understand why homework becomes a stressor for parents and children, especially the relationship between this stress and the frustration of basic psychological needs (such as the sense of competence, autonomy, and relatedness). 2. **Methods to reduce homework stress**: The researchers hope to reduce the stress of homework through intervention measures, especially by increasing parents' adoption of supportive practices (i.e., practices that meet the above - mentioned basic psychological needs). ### Research Background Although homework is widely believed to help improve students' academic performance, motivation, and self - regulated learning ability, it may also bring negative emotions, such as dissatisfaction and stress, which affect not only students but also their parents. Research shows that when homework inhibits children's or parents' perceived ability, time, or skills, it may lead to stress. In addition, when parents feel powerless, have no choice, and are in a tense atmosphere during homework, homework may become a "battle", further intensifying stress. ### Research Hypotheses Based on the Self - Determination Theory (SDT), the researchers proposed several hypotheses: - **Hypothesis 1 (H1)**: The frustration of parents' basic psychological needs is positively correlated with homework stress. - **Hypothesis 2 (H2)**: The frustration of parents' basic psychological needs is positively correlated with the adoption of need - frustrating practices (such as yelling, using controlling language, etc.). - **Hypothesis 3 (H3)**: Parents' adoption of need - frustrating practices is positively correlated with the frustration of children's basic psychological needs. - **Hypothesis 4 (H4)**: The frustration of children's basic psychological needs is positively correlated with homework stress. - **Hypothesis 5 (H5)**: The frustration of parents' basic psychological needs indirectly affects children's homework stress through parents' stress, parents' adoption of need - frustrating practices, and the frustration of children's basic psychological needs. - **Hypothesis 6 (H6)**: Parents' stress and parents' adoption of need - frustrating practices indirectly affect children's homework stress through the frustration of children's basic psychological needs. ### Research Methods The research is divided into two parts: - **Part One**: Collect data from 171 pairs of parents and children, and evaluate the relationships between parents' and children's need frustration, homework stress, and parents' adoption of need - frustrating practices through questionnaires. - **Part Two**: Conduct four - time training for 55 parents, aiming to help them increase the adoption of supportive practices and reduce homework stress. At the same time, set up a control group (63 parents did not receive training) to compare the changes in homework stress and supportive practices between the two groups of parents and children. ### Conclusions The research results support the above hypotheses, indicating that the frustration of parents' basic psychological needs will lead to higher homework stress, prompt parents to adopt more need - frustrating practices, and then increase the frustration of children's basic psychological needs and homework stress. Through training, the homework stress of parents and children can be effectively reduced, and the ability of parents to adopt supportive practices can be improved. In general, this research not only reveals the mechanism of homework stress but also provides an effective intervention method to mitigate the negative impacts brought by homework.