Oliver Freiberger, Considering Comparison: A Method for Religious Studies

Jens Schlieter

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1177/2050303220952843

2020-08-20

Critical Research on Religion

Abstract:Critical Research on Religion, Ahead of Print.

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

Claude Calame, Bruce Lincoln (Ed.), Comparer en histoire des religions antiques. Controverses et propositions. Liège, Presses universitaires de Liège, coll. « Religions », 2012, 146 p.

Benoît Vermander

2013-01-01

Abstract:Cet ouvrage, fonde sur une rencontre tenue en decembre 2010 dans le cadre de l’Atelier Chicago-Paris sur les religions anciennes, s’essaie a penser l’analyse comparative aujourd’hui sur le fond des tentatives qui ont marque l’histoire des sciences religieuses. L’exercice comparatiste est tout a la fois perilleux et necessaire. Les contributions du present volume decrivent donc les pratiques des chercheurs qui s’y essaient, pratiques ainsi mises en confrontation. Apres une longue introduction ...
Toward a Mutual Change of Religion and Urban Space: A Comparative Perspective

Joerg Ruepke

DOI: https://doi.org/10.15575/jw.v8i1.20139

2024-01-02

Abstract:From a historical perspective, cities have served as more than mere locations where religious practices are observed; they have consistently exhibited an elevated level of historical documentation. The claim advanced here is that the interrelationship between religious change and urban development necessitates thorough analysis. It is imperative to critically examine the significant developments in local and trans-local religions, particularly emphasising their distinct urban contextual factors. At the same time, such urban conditions, the practices, and discourse that shape the understanding of these conditions as urban are not independent variables in the study of religious change. Rather, they are influenced by religious practices and individuals, thereby forming a reciprocal relationship. The choice of areas is an assumption that the pertinent aspect in establishing a connection is the spatial character of religious practices and ideas and their material manifestation in physical space. The article concisely examines various aspects related to the transformation of urban spaces and religious practices. These include the process of monumentalising urban areas and gods, the public display and the articulation of communication with God and gods, the imaginative and widespread utilisation of scripture in religious activities and thought, the increasing division of labour and professionalisation, the emergence of individual urban actors who are not solely defined by their ancestral lineage, the formation of religious groups, the religious organisation of time and the influence of temporal concepts on religious ideas and practices, and lastly, the conceptualisation of alternatives to urban life through the religious exaggeration of rural and natural environments. Such a cursory review of religious changes in urban settings and their impact on urbanism does not yield any definitive assertions on these developments. However, the collective evidence confirms the effectiveness of the presented approach.
On Comparative Literature: an Interview with Joshua Scodel

Nie Zhenzhao

2009-01-01

Abstract:Joshua Scodel is Helen A. Regenstein Professor in English and Comparative Literature and the Chair of the Department of Comparative Literature at the University of Chicago. His publications include The English Poetic Epitaph: Commemoration and Conflict from Jonson to Wordsworth (Cornell UP, 1991) , Excess and the Mean in Early Modern English Literature (Princeton UP, 2001), and various articles on the 16th -17th century English literature and literary criticism in relation to the classical tradition. In this interview, Prof. Scodel discusses Comparative Literature as a discipline, with remarks about the goals of Comparative Literature, its relation to literary theory, the history of the discipline in the United States, the most important current developments in the field, some major past and present comparatists, and the Comparative Literature program at his home institution, the University of Chicago. The interview concludes with some reflections on Comparative Literature' s crucial role in the study of English Renaissance literature, Professor Scodel' s own major area of expertise.
Kiel evoluas interlingvistiko? Kompara studo

haitao liu

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1075/lplp.23.1.04kie

1999-01-01

Abstract:SUMMARY A comparison of two major German-language monographs on interlinguistics sheds light on the common basis of the discipline and on its two major theoretical orientations, the sociological and the linguistic. Although interlinguistics properly includes the scientific study and systematic improvement of international linguistic communication in general, the creation and use of planned languages (international auxiliary languages) remains its chief object of research. ZUSAMMENFASSUNG Ein Vergleich von zwei großen deutschsprachigen Monographien über Interlinguistik beleuchtet die gemeinsamen Grundlagen der Disziplin und ihre zwei wichtigsten theoretischen Richtungen, die soziologische und die linguistische. Obgleich die Interlinguistik eigentlich die wissenschaftliche Untersuchung und systematische Verbesserung der internationalen sprachlichen Kommunikation im allgemeinen einschlieBt, bleibt die Schaffung und Verwendung von Plansprachen (internationale Hilfssprachen) ihr wichtigster Forschungsgegenstand.
Functional equivalence and validity of religiousness indicators in cross-cultural comparative surveys

Franz Höllinger,Anja Eder

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1177/2059799115622756

2016-01-01

Methodological Innovations

Abstract:Cross-cultural comparative surveys have become an important tool to investigate social attitudes across different countries. However, this methodology is confronted with a number of challenges. One of the core problems is the functional equivalence of the concepts and indicators used. In this article, we study this problem in regard to the investigation of religiousness in three prominent surveys, the World Value Survey, the International Social Survey Programme, and the Religion Monitor. Our contribution starts with the fundamental question of the intercultural meaning of single items that are commonly used for the measurement of religiosity. From the comparison of the linguistic formulation of these items in different languages and across the three surveys, we obtain evidence of whether the concept of religiousness has the same meaning in different countries and to what extent the results depend on the formulation of the item. Subsequently, we use confirmatory factor analysis to test whether two religiousness scales derived from the International Social Survey Programme are structurally equivalent across countries. In the final step, we proceed to a substantive analysis, comparing religiousness scales from the three surveys in order to examine to what extent scales that claim to measure the same construct in fact produce similar results when applied to different countries. Our findings suggest that the paradigm of “asking the same questions” is difficult to apply and problematical with respect to some core indicators of individual religiousness and that questionnaires that are based on the Western concept of religion will lead to biased results when applied to worldwide cross-cultural comparison.
Comparative Classics And Intercultural Theology

Benoit Vermander

DOI: https://doi.org/10.2143/RTL.50.4.3287198

2019-01-01

Abstract:The history of interreligious encounters is marked by the cross reading of the Classics that, through their form and content, determine specific episte/ne and belief systems. <, Sacred books are inserted into larger canonical ensembles, and religious shifts caused by textual encounters do not originate in the reading of the former only. This article starts with one of these encounters, that between Chinese scholars and Jesuit missionaries in the 17th and 18th centuries. It relies on the teachings drawn from this case to sketch a path from Gadamer's hermeneutics to dialogic hermeneutics. in this light it reads the theological endeavor and not only Christian theology as marked by a migratory tension, which makes of any local theology the virtual space of an intercultural crossing.
On Comparative Literature

T. Eliot

Abstract:Comparison is a common technique we go through in our everyday life. It is rather a human psychology. Even each animal looks with this vision. But more specifically, human being is much more developed cerebrally than others. CL actually exists upon the two traditions, called Little tradition and Great Tradition. It is such a tool by virtue of which we can enrich our National Literature and hence this kind of literature is named as Universal literature, Global Literature or Welt literature. Intellectuals lik name this Visva Sahitya with a greater goal. Attempts have been made to bring out the methods, doctrines and perspectives of American, British, French, German, Japanese and other countries across the globe. What is Comparative literature, what are objectives and the modus operandiall these things are well discussed here.

Education,Art
Comparative education as cultural critique

Jeremy Rappleye

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/03050068.2019.1701247

2019-12-10

Comparative Education

Abstract:Relating my experience of becoming a 'foreign' comparativist, I offer a vision of comparative education that both extends and challenges the field. It continues the work of Bereday and Lauwerys who sought to make visible the 'contrasting colours of the world' in order to affect deep self-reflection and imagine alternatives. But it also challenges that earlier iteration: calling for a drastic widening of the imaginative kosmos, an exorcising of our enduring Hegelian worldview, and more skilled work in bringing differences 'home'. It underscores the need for new modes of engagement: earnestness, humility, self-overcoming. Our time of heightened transnational academic mobility makes this sort of work practically possible for the first time, but the field's full potential to affect intellectual paradigms will occur only when we become immigrants of being.

education & educational research
Methodological aspects of comparative studies: the context of Chinese philosophy

Magdalena Filipczuk

DOI: https://doi.org/10.5604/01.3001.0015.9914

2022-09-15

Tekstualia

Abstract:The claim that contemporary philosophy must be multicultural to be taken seriously may appear somewhat controversial. Nevertheless, the need to reevaluate classical Anglo-European philosophy in the context of the emerging contemporary philosophical canon is of great importance for a full understanding of the discipline today. Vital issues in philosophy cannot be addressed without recourse to conventions of intercultural philosophy. Comparative philosophy is among the most fruitful disciplines on a global scale. But to extend the philosophical curriculum, a new kind of discourse must allow for the accessible introduction of new ideas. This article presents an analysis of scholarly works on Chinese cultural works in literal and metaphorical translation/transmission for Western readers that have been undertaken by David Hall, Roger Ames and François Jullien, and will address the problematical nature of research within comparative studies in philosophy.
On the role of benchmarking data sets and simulations in method comparison studies

Sarah Friedrich,Tim Friede

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.2208.01457

2022-12-06

Abstract:Method comparisons are essential to provide recommendations and guidance for applied researchers, who often have to choose from a plethora of available approaches. While many comparisons exist in the literature, these are often not neutral but favour a novel method. Apart from the choice of design and a proper reporting of the findings, there are different approaches concerning the underlying data for such method comparison studies. Most manuscripts on statistical methodology rely on simulation studies and provide a single real-world data set as an example to motivate and illustrate the methodology investigated. In the context of supervised learning, in contrast, methods are often evaluated using so-called benchmarking data sets, i.e. real-world data that serve as gold standard in the community. Simulation studies, on the other hand, are much less common in this context. The aim of this paper is to investigate differences and similarities between these approaches, to discuss their advantages and disadvantages and ultimately to develop new approaches to the evaluation of methods picking the best of both worlds. To this aim, we borrow ideas from different contexts such as mixed methods research and Clinical Scenario Evaluation.

Methodology,Computation,Machine Learning
“Comparing” Jewish and Islamic Legal Traditions: Between Disciplinarity and Critical Historical Jurisprudence

Lena Salaymeh

DOI: https://doi.org/10.33137/cal.v2i1.22520

2015-03-15

Abstract:Common modes of comparing Jewish and Islamic legal traditions are limited by deep structural assumptions that may be traced to three comparative disciplines that emerged in post-Enlightenment Europe. Comparative philology, comparative religion, and comparative law emphasized linearity and genealogy, with prejudicial and essentializing implications. This article examines how certain disciplinary methods continue to shape the underlying conceptual assumptions of Judeo-Islamic studies through a case study on circumcision, a practice shared by Jews and Muslims. When late antique circumcision is situated within its socio-political, geographic, and intellectual contexts and when it is defined in relation to its correlative terms and concepts, it becomes clear that Jews and Muslims understood and practiced circumcision in distinct ways. These heuristics of critical historical jurisprudence clarify the non-linear and overlapping relationship between Jewish and Islamic legal traditions. The implication of critical historical jurisprudence for contemporary controversies surrounding circumcision is recognizing the inadequacy and limiting consequences of modern categories and concepts.

Law,History,Political Science
Comparing research topics in European and International Communication Association journals: Computational analysis

Oren Soffer,Dorit Geifman

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1177/1748048520928334

2020-06-02

International Communication Gazette

Abstract:This study uses diachronic computational analysis enhanced with a qualitative approach to examine ongoing changes in communication studies, comparing trends in two European media studies journals and three major International Communication Association journals. We analyze the titles, keywords, and abstracts of 2,585 articles published between 1994–2007 and 2008–2016. We find differences between topics in the two periods in each of the journals’ groups and between the two groups themselves. In the European group, we find centrality of topics related to media change and media logic. In the ICA journals, we find a strengthening of scholarly engagement with effects studies. At the same time, we find evidence of erosion of the place of cultural studies as a distinctive research stream.

communication
Comparative Philosophy and Practical Applied Ethics

Laura Specker Sullivan

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1163/15406253-12340128

2024-06-14

Journal of Chinese Philosophy

Abstract:Abstract Comparative philosophy is gaining traction in professional academic philosophy, with specialist journals, organizations, books, and public campaigns. These inroads have been made in canonical areas of philosophy, including epistemology, metaphysics, logic, and value theory. Yet comparative philosophy still plays little role in practical applied ethics, an interdisciplinary research area in which work with practice and policy implications are dominated by the anglophone world. In this article, I explain why comparative work might be especially difficult in this type of applied ethics, and I suggest how comparative philosophers might overcome these challenges to connect their theoretical work with contemporary practical issues.
Relativity in Social Cognition: Basic processes and novel applications of social comparisons

Christian Unkelbach,Hans Alves,Matthew Baldwin,Jan Crusius,Kathi Diel,Adam D. Galinsky,Anne Gast,Wilhelm Hofmann,Roland Imhoff,Oliver Genschow,Joris Lammers,Eileen Pauels,Iris Schneider,Sascha Topolinski,Mareike Westfal,Thomas Mussweiler

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/10463283.2022.2161043

IF: 5.652

2023-01-12

European Review of Social Psychology

Abstract:A key challenge for social psychology is to identify unifying principles that account for the complex dynamics of social behaviour. We propose psychological relativity and its core mechanism of comparison as one such unifying principle. To support our proposal, we review recent evidence investigating basic processes underlying and novel applications of social comparisons. Specifically, we clarify determinants of assimilation and contrast, evaluative consequences of comparing similarities vs. differences, attitudinal effects of spatial relativity, and how spatial arrangements determine perceived similarity, one of the antecedents of social comparisons. We then move to behavioural relativity effects on motivation and self-regulation, as well as imitation behaviour. Finally, we address relativity within the more applied areas of morality and political psychology. The reviewed research thereby illustrates how unifying principles of social cognition may be instrumental in answering old questions and discovering new phenomena and explanations.

psychology, social
The Spiritual Basis of Comparative Literature as a Discipline

Sihe CHEN

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1004-8634.2012.01.008

2012-01-01

Abstract:What on earth is the spiritual basis of comparative literature as a discipline? Never has there been any discipline whose research subjects embrace so many languages,cultures and disciplinary backgrounds.Proceeding from relevant discussions by earlier scholars of comparative literature,this paper is intended to resort out the proposition "Comparative literature means humanism".This proposition comes from a French scholar of comparative literature.Although judged from today's norms what the old generation of scholars of humanism have said sounds more or less empty and hollow,yet we should still return to the stand of that French scholar and reinterpret the meaning of "Comparative literature means humanism" by referring to new fruits of current scientific research.Let's take common stands of mankind and revive our confidence in literary expression of feelings of human life.
Comparison as a Method for Geography Education

Wilcke,Budke

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3390/educsci9030225

2019-08-27

Education Sciences

Abstract:Comparison is an everyday process of thinking, which is also frequently used in geography lessons. However, in geography pedagogy, the term ‘comparison’ remains vague and insufficiently defined. In this paper, we will propose a clear definition of what comparison is and introduce it as a systematic method for secondary school geography education. This definition and method is the result of our theoretical–conceptual approach, according to which we have analyzed the current academic discussion about scientific comparison and converted it into a method for teaching. We argue that applying comparison as a pedagogical tool may improve students’ skills to argue, reflect, solve problems, and promote good judgement.
A Companion to Observant Reform in the Late Middle Ages and Beyond

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1163/9789004297524

2015-06-02

Abstract:The Observant reform of the religious orders remains one of the most important yet understudied religious movements of the later Middle Ages. This volume provides scholars with a current, synthetic introduction to the field, and suggests new avenues for future scholarship.
Incurably Religious? Consensus Gentium and the Cultural Universality of Religion

Jakob De Roover

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1163/15685276-12341301

2014-01-01

Numen

Abstract:Abstract For centuries, the question whether there were peoples without religion was the subject of heated debate among European thinkers. At the turn of the twentieth century, this concern vanished from the radar of Western scholarship: all known peoples and societies, it was concluded, had some form of religion. This essay examines the relevant debates from the sixteenth to the twentieth century: Why was this issue so important? How did European thinkers determine whether or not some people had religion? What allowed them to close this debate? It will be shown that European descriptions of the “religions” of non-Western cultures counted as evidence for or against theoretical claims made within a particular framework, namely that of generic Christian theology. The issue of the universality of religion was settled not by scientific research but by making ad hoc modifications to this theological framework whenever it faced empirical anomalies. This is important today, because the debate concerning the cultural universality of religion has been reopened. On the one hand, evolutionary-biological explanations of religion claim that religion must be a cultural universal, since its origin lies in the evolution of the human species; on the other hand, authors suggest that religion is not a cultural universal, because many of the “religions” of humanity are fictitious entities created within an underlying theological framework.
Comparative Media Studies in the Digital Age: Taking Stock, Looking Ahead

Jun Liu,Xinchuan Liu,Klaus Bruhn Jensen

2020-01-01

International Journal of Communication

Abstract:This Special Section on "Comparative Media Studies in the Digital Age: Taking Stock, Looking Ahead" joins other initiatives to develop more refined comparative communication studies by expounding possible theoretical contemplation, elaborating methodological diversification, and exhibiting empirical interrogations. In this introductory article, we present the main discussions undertaken in the features and research articles, as well as some of their limitations. We further offer some thoughts on "context" in the digital age and promote contextual and context-aware approaches as one guide for comparative communication studies.
People Like Us: Mining Scholarly Data for Comparable Researchers

Graham Cormode,S. Muthukrishnan,Jinyun Yan

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1403.2941

2014-07-07

Abstract:We present the problem of finding comparable researchers for any given researcher. This problem has many motivations. Firstly, know thyself. The answers of where we stand among research community and who we are most alike may not be easily found by existing evaluations of ones' research mainly based on citation counts. Secondly, there are many situations where one needs to find comparable researchers e.g., for reviewing peers, constructing programming committees or compiling teams for grants. It is often done through an ad hoc and informal basis. Utilizing the large scale scholarly data accessible on the web, we address the problem of automatically finding comparable researchers. We propose a standard to quantify the quality of research output, via the quality of publishing venues. We represent a researcher as a sequence of her publication records, and develop a framework of comparison of researchers by sequence matching. Several variations of comparisons are considered including matching by quality of publication venue and research topics, and performing prefix matching. We evaluate our methods on a large corpus and demonstrate the effectiveness of our methods through examples. In the end, we identify several promising directions for further work.

Digital Libraries,Social and Information Networks

Oliver Freiberger, Considering Comparison: A Method for Religious Studies

Claude Calame, Bruce Lincoln (Ed.), Comparer en histoire des religions antiques. Controverses et propositions. Liège, Presses universitaires de Liège, coll. « Religions », 2012, 146 p.

Toward a Mutual Change of Religion and Urban Space: A Comparative Perspective

On Comparative Literature: an Interview with Joshua Scodel

Kiel evoluas interlingvistiko? Kompara studo

Functional equivalence and validity of religiousness indicators in cross-cultural comparative surveys

Comparative Classics And Intercultural Theology

On Comparative Literature

Comparative education as cultural critique

Methodological aspects of comparative studies: the context of Chinese philosophy

On the role of benchmarking data sets and simulations in method comparison studies

“Comparing” Jewish and Islamic Legal Traditions: Between Disciplinarity and Critical Historical Jurisprudence

Comparing research topics in European and International Communication Association journals: Computational analysis

Comparative Philosophy and Practical Applied Ethics

Relativity in Social Cognition: Basic processes and novel applications of social comparisons

The Spiritual Basis of Comparative Literature as a Discipline

Comparison as a Method for Geography Education

A Companion to Observant Reform in the Late Middle Ages and Beyond

Incurably Religious? Consensus Gentium and the Cultural Universality of Religion

Comparative Media Studies in the Digital Age: Taking Stock, Looking Ahead

People Like Us: Mining Scholarly Data for Comparable Researchers