Reflections on Three Different High School Chemistry Lab Formats during COVID-19 Remote Learning

Elizabeth W. Kelley
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1021/acs.jchemed.0c00814
IF: 3.208
2020-08-26
Journal of Chemical Education
Abstract:Due to the COVID-19 pandemic, education at all levels has temporarily shifted to remote learning, hobbling an integral component of chemistry courses: the laboratory. The chemistry lab is crucial for developing student engagement and learning with hands-on, relevant experiments in a socially dynamic classroom setting. The transition to remote learning consequently presents additional obstacles for chemistry educators and students, supplemental to challenges experienced by all disciplines. This article conveys preliminary indications about various remote learning laboratory scenarios by comparing three different formats for high school chemistry laboratories from the 2020 spring semester, with the aim of informing preparations for hands-on laboratory instruction in the fall. The results tentatively support that hands-on laboratory instruction should ideally occur in the classroom or, if necessary, by sending home all requisite supplies in order to promote effective, equitable learning, engagement, and performance.The Supporting Information is available at https://pubs.acs.org/doi/10.1021/acs.jchemed.0c00814.Survey information (PDF, DOCX)Lab 18, Esterification of Unknown Carboxylic Acids (PDF, DOCX)Lab 18, Esterification of Unknown Carboxylic Acids (at-home alternative for students who missed lab) (PDF, DOCX)Lab 19, Polymerization from Potato Starch (at-home version) (PDF, DOCX)Lab 19, Polymerization from Potato Starch (at-home alternative without lab supplies) (PDF, DOCX)Lab 20, Solubility in the Kitchen (at-home version) (PDF, DOCX)Lab 20, Solubility in the Kitchen (at-home version rock candy and alternative balloon) (PDF, DOCX)Lab 20, Solubility in the Kitchen (at-home version balloon and alternative rock candy) (PDF, DOCX)Lab 20, Solubility in the Kitchen (at-home alternative without lab supplies) (PDF, DOCX)This article has not yet been cited by other publications.
chemistry, multidisciplinary,education, scientific disciplines
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is how to effectively provide high - quality high school chemistry experiment teaching during the COVID - 19 pandemic. Due to the school closures caused by the pandemic, traditional face - to - face laboratory teaching has become infeasible, which poses a major challenge to chemistry education. Chemistry laboratories are crucial for students' participation, learning outcomes, and the development of practical skills. Therefore, in a remote - learning environment, how to maintain the effectiveness of these laboratory activities has become a key issue for educators. Specifically, by comparing three different remote chemistry laboratory teaching models in the spring semester of 2020, the paper explores the following questions: - How to design and implement effective chemistry laboratory teaching in a remote - learning environment? - Which remote laboratory teaching model can best promote students' learning outcomes, participation, and performance? - In remote learning, is it more effective to send all the experimental materials required by families than other methods? - Should laboratory teaching be carried out face - to - face as much as possible, or be achieved by mailing materials to homes when necessary? The purpose of the paper is to provide guidance and suggestions for the preparation of chemistry laboratory teaching in the upcoming academic year, especially during the pandemic, on how to effectively and fairly promote students' learning, participation, and performance.