Risk stratification of patients admitted to hospital with covid-19 using the ISARIC WHO Clinical Characterisation Protocol: development and validation of the 4C Mortality Score

Stephen R Knight,Antonia Ho,Riinu Pius,Iain Buchan,Gail Carson,Thomas M Drake,Jake Dunning,Cameron J Fairfield,Carrol Gamble,Christopher A Green,Rishi Gupta,Sophie Halpin,Hayley E Hardwick,Karl A Holden,Peter W Horby,Clare Jackson,Kenneth A Mclean,Laura Merson,Jonathan S Nguyen-Van-Tam,Lisa Norman,Mahdad Noursadeghi,Piero L Olliaro,Mark G Pritchard,Clark D Russell,Catherine A Shaw,Aziz Sheikh,Tom Solomon,Cathie Sudlow,Olivia V Swann,Lance CW Turtle,Peter JM Openshaw,J Kenneth Baillie,Malcolm G Semple,Annemarie B Docherty,Ewen M Harrison,J Kenneth Baillie,Malcolm G Semple,Peter JM Openshaw,Gail Carson,Beatrice Alex,Benjamin Bach,Wendy S Barclay,Debby Bogaert,Meera Chand,Graham S Cooke,Annemarie B Docherty,Jake Dunning,Ana da Silva Filipe,Tom Fletcher,Christopher A Green,Ewen M Harrison,Julian A Hiscox,Antonia Ying Wai Ho,Peter W Horby,Samreen Ijaz,Saye Khoo,Paul Klenerman,Andrew Law,Wei Shen Lim,Alexander J Mentzer,Laura Merson,Alison M Meynert,Mahdad Noursadeghi,Shona C Moore,Massimo Palmarini,William A Paxton,Georgios Pollakis,Nicholas Price,Andrew Rambaut,David L Robertson,Clark D Russell,Vanessa Sancho-Shimizu,Janet T Scott,Louise Sigfrid,Tom Solomon,Shiranee Sriskandan,David Stuart,Charlotte Summers,Richard S Tedder,Emma C Thomson,Ryan S Thwaites,Lance CW Turtle,Maria Zambon,Hayley Hardwick,Chloe Donohue,Jane Ewins,Wilna Oosthuyzen,Fiona Griffiths,Lisa Norman,Riinu Pius,Tom M Drake,Cameron J Fairfield,Stephen Knight,Kenneth A Mclean,Derek Murphy,Catherine A Shaw,Jo Dalton,Michelle Girvan,Egle Saviciute,Stephanie Roberts,Janet Harrison,Laura Marsh,Marie Connor,Sophie Halpin,Clare Jackson,Carrol Gamble,Gary Leeming,Andrew Law,Ross Hendry,James Scott-Brown,William Greenhalf,Victoria Shaw,Sarah McDonald,Katie A Ahmed,Jane A Armstrong,Milton Ashworth,Innocent G Asiimwe,Siddharth Bakshi,Samantha L Barlow,Laura Booth,Benjamin Brennan,Katie Bullock,Benjamin WA Catterall,Jordan J Clark,Emily A Clarke,Sarah Cole,Louise Cooper,Helen Cox,Christopher Davis,Oslem Dincarslan,Chris Dunn,Philip Dyer,Angela Elliott,Anthony Evans,Lewis WS Fisher,Terry Foster,Isabel Garcia-Dorival,Willliam Greenhalf,Philip Gunning,Catherine Hartley,Antonia Ho,Rebecca L Jensen,Christopher B Jones,Trevor R Jones,Shadia Khandaker,Katharine King,Robyn T Kiy,Chrysa Koukorava,Annette Lake,Suzannah Lant,Diane Latawiec,L Lavelle-Langham,Daniella Lefteri,Lauren Lett,Lucia A Livoti,Maria Mancini,Sarah McDonald,Laurence McEvoy,John McLauchlan,Soeren Metelmann,Nahida S Miah,Joanna Middleton,Joyce Mitchell,Shona C Moore,Ellen G Murphy,Rebekah Penrice-Randal,Jack Pilgrim,Tessa Prince,Will Reynolds,P Matthew Ridley,Debby Sales,Victoria E Shaw,Rebecca K Shears,Benjamin Small,Krishanthi S Subramaniam,Agnieska Szemiel,Aislynn Taggart,Jolanta Tanianis-Hughes,Jordan Thomas,Erwan Trochu,Libby van Tonder,Eve Wilcock,J Eunice Zhang,Kayode Adeniji,Daniel Agranoff,Ken Agwuh,Dhiraj Ail,Ana Alegria,Brian Angus,Abdul Ashish,Dougal Atkinson,Shahedal Bari,Gavin Barlow,Stella Barnass,Nicholas Barrett,Christopher Bassford,David Baxter,Michael Beadsworth,Jolanta Bernatoniene,John Berridge,Nicola Best,Pieter Bothma,David Brealey,Robin Brittain-Long,Naomi Bulteel,Tom Burden,Andrew Burtenshaw,Vikki Caruth,David Chadwick,Duncan Chambler,Nigel Chee,Jenny Child,Srikanth Chukkambotla,Tom Clark,Paul Collini,Catherine Cosgrove,Jason Cupitt,Maria-Teresa Cutino-Moguel,Paul Dark,Chris Dawson,Samir Dervisevic,Phil Donnison,Sam Douthwaite,Ingrid DuRand,Ahilanadan Dushianthan,Tristan Dyer,Cariad Evans,Chi Eziefula,Chrisopher Fegan,Adam Finn,Duncan Fullerton,Sanjeev Garg,Sanjeev Garg,Atul Garg,Jo Godden,Arthur Goldsmith,Clive Graham,Elaine Hardy,Stuart Hartshorn,Daniel Harvey,Peter Havalda,Daniel B Hawcutt,Maria Hobrok,Luke Hodgson,Anita Holme,Anil Hormis,Michael Jacobs,Susan Jain,Paul Jennings,Agilan Kaliappan,Vidya Kasipandian,Stephen Kegg,Michael Kelsey,Jason Kendall,Caroline Kerrison,Ian Kerslake,Oliver Koch,Gouri Koduri,George Koshy,Shondipon Laha,Susan Larkin,Tamas Leiner,Patrick Lillie,James Limb,Vanessa Linnett,Jeff Little,Michael MacMahon,Emily MacNaughton,Ravish Mankregod,Huw Masson,Elijah Matovu,Katherine McCullough,Ruth McEwen,Manjula Meda,Gary Mills,Jane Minton,Mariyam Mirfenderesky,Kavya Mohandas,Quen Mok,James Moon,Elinoor Moore,Patrick Morgan,Craig Morris,Katherine Mortimore,Samuel Moses,Mbiye Mpenge,Rohinton Mulla,Michael Murphy,Megan Nagel,Thapas Nagarajan,Mark Nelson,Igor Otahal,Mark Pais,Selva Panchatsharam,Hassan Paraiso,Brij Patel,Justin Pepperell,Mark Peters,Mandeep Phull,Stefania Pintus,Jagtur Singh Pooni,Frank Post,David Price,Rachel Prout,Nikolas Rae,Henrik Reschreiter,Tim Reynolds,Neil Richardson,Mark Roberts,Devender Roberts,Alistair Rose,Guy Rousseau,Brendan Ryan,Taranprit Saluja,Aarti Shah,Prad Shanmuga,Anil Sharma,Anna Shawcross,Jeremy Sizer,Richard Smith,Catherine Snelson,Nick Spittle,Nikki Staines,Tom Stambach,Richard Stewart,Pradeep Subudhi,Tamas Szakmany,Kate Tatham,Jo Thomas,Chris Thompson,Robert Thompson,Ascanio Tridente,Darell Tupper-Carey,Mary Twagira,Andrew Ustianowski,Nick Vallotton,Lisa Vincent-Smith,Shico Visuvanathan,Alan Vuylsteke,Sam Waddy,Rachel Wake,Andrew Walden,Ingeborg Welters,Tony Whitehouse,Paul Whittaker,Ashley Whittington,Meme Wijesinghe,Martin Williams,Lawrence Wilson,Sarah Wilson,Stephen Winchester,Martin Wiselka,Adam Wolverson,Daniel G Wooton,Andrew Workman,Bryan Yates,Peter Young

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1136/bmj.m3339

2020-09-09

BMJ

Abstract:Abstract Objective To develop and validate a pragmatic risk score to predict mortality in patients admitted to hospital with coronavirus disease 2019 (covid-19). Design Prospective observational cohort study. Setting International Severe Acute Respiratory and emerging Infections Consortium (ISARIC) World Health Organization (WHO) Clinical Characterisation Protocol UK (CCP-UK) study (performed by the ISARIC Coronavirus Clinical Characterisation Consortium—ISARIC-4C) in 260 hospitals across England, Scotland, and Wales. Model training was performed on a cohort of patients recruited between 6 February and 20 May 2020, with validation conducted on a second cohort of patients recruited after model development between 21 May and 29 June 2020 . Participants Adults (age ≥18 years) admitted to hospital with covid-19 at least four weeks before final data extraction. Main outcome measure In-hospital mortality. Results 35 463 patients were included in the derivation dataset (mortality rate 32.2%) and 22 361 in the validation dataset (mortality rate 30.1%). The final 4C Mortality Score included eight variables readily available at initial hospital assessment: age, sex, number of comorbidities, respiratory rate, peripheral oxygen saturation, level of consciousness, urea level, and C reactive protein (score range 0-21 points). The 4C Score showed high discrimination for mortality (derivation cohort: area under the receiver operating characteristic curve 0.79, 95% confidence interval 0.78 to 0.79; validation cohort: 0.77, 0.76 to 0.77) with excellent calibration (validation: calibration-in-the-large=0, slope=1.0). Patients with a score of at least 15 (n=4158, 19%) had a 62% mortality (positive predictive value 62%) compared with 1% mortality for those with a score of 3 or less (n=1650, 7%; negative predictive value 99%). Discriminatory performance was higher than 15 pre-existing risk stratification scores (area under the receiver operating characteristic curve range 0.61-0.76), with scores developed in other covid-19 cohorts often performing poorly (range 0.63-0.73). Conclusions An easy-to-use risk stratification score has been developed and validated based on commonly available parameters at hospital presentation. The 4C Mortality Score outperformed existing scores, showed utility to directly inform clinical decision making, and can be used to stratify patients admitted to hospital with covid-19 into different management groups. The score should be further validated to determine its applicability in other populations. Study registration ISRCTN66726260