Abstract:Marjorie Rubright, Doppelganger Dilemmas: Anglo-Dutch Relations in Early Modern English Literature and Culture (Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania Press, 2014). 342pp. ISBN 978 0 8122 4623 0.By proving the importance of proximity and similitude in the construction of national identity, Marjorie Rubright's study of the English social and literary productions of 'Dutchness' in the early modern period challenges the narrative of oppositional discourse so prevalent in early modern scholarship. Surveys of European exploration of the New World, accounts of English interactions in the Mediterranean, and analyses of England's confrontations with rivals France and Spain all subscribe, in one way or another, to 'meaning through difference'. Bypassing this dominant model, Rubright takes as her object of study the Dutch - a group concurrently England's political and military partner in Protestant solidarity and an assimilated migrant community actively participating in urban London life. Analyzing the varied manifestations of 'Dutchness' in England in the sixteenth and seventeenth centuries, Rubright accounts for a range of texts that negotiate the resemblances between England and the Low Countries. Political and historical material such as immigration policies, travel accounts, world atlases, and urban architecture are read alongside the more ostensibly literary: dictionaries, philological tracts, rhetorical treatises, popular print, plays and pageants. She marks 'a moment when knowledge of Anglo-Dutch linguistic proximity was actively produced in philological debates, in the performance and printed publication of London drama, and in bilingual and polyglot wordbooks' (p. 160). Tracing this shiftin the early seventeenth century, Rubright innovatively interprets English representations of social, economic, religious, political, and sexual identity by asking 'in what ways real and imagined proximity to one's neighbors - those who live just beyond and within England - shaped constructions of ethnic, and sometimes racial, self definition' (5). Indeed, Rubright proves that 'variations by degree' (p. 19) are far more powerful factors in identity formation than previously suggested.Focusing on London city dramas, Rubright outlines the poetics of social stratification and the representations of cultural assimilation of Dutch immigrants. She alerts us to the complexities of ethnic distinctions when they are applied to Dutch characters on the English stage, emphasizing the linguistic paratexts that complicate expected expressions of xenophobia. The Dutch Courtesan and other city comedies depict what Rubright terms a 'double vision analytic'; that is, Dutch accents, habits and tastes on the stage emerge as familiar and recognizable as English. She argues that the play 'traffics in discursive operations that open up a palimpsestic perception: one that sees Dutchness within, beneath and overlayed onto Englishness' (p. 55).While establishing the nuances of Dutch influence on the English imagination, Rubright provides a sustained - indeed unprecedented - study of the shared lexicon of both cultures in her first three chapters. By scrutinizing the linguistic debates that underwrite concepts of cultural heritage, she reveals that the metaphor of the assimilated foreigner - the denizen - when applied to philological debates 'expresses what the inkhorn disallows: the possibility of thinking in terms of transitioning along a continuum...in one instance an exemplar of cultural assimilation, in another an unwanted and deceptive stranger existing outside the laws of English grammar and the English realm' (pp. 62, 65). This continuum shifts in the early seventeenth century, according to Rubright, to accommodate the nuances of English incorporation, and even emulation, of Dutch language as a model of simplicity and verisimilitude. …

Of seals and siblings: Teresa/Matilda (d. 1218), queen of Portugal and countess of Flanders

Sisters of Saint George: female membership and material remembrance within the Crossbow Guild of late medieval Ghent

The chest of memory: the funeral rites of Maria Álvarez de Xèrica and her burial in the Convent of Santa Catarina in Barcelona

'I praie ye send for the courall': children's coral as the physical embodiment of parental hopes and fears in early modern England

Symmetries in Images on Ancient Seals

Medieval Clothing and Textiles

Capturing the fusion of two ancestries and kinship structures in Merovingian Flanders

Intimations of Infanticide in Little Women

Pleasure and Politics at the Court of France. The Artistic Patronage of Queen Marie of Brabant (1260–1321). Tracy Chapman Hamilton. Studies in Medieval and Early Renaissance Art History 64. Turnhout: Brepols, 2019. 328 pp. €140.

The Role of Mothering in Portuguese Women's Decision-Making within Abusive Relationships

Transfilial negotiations and palimpsestuous traces: queering postcolonial memory and intergenerational transmission

Restrained freedom? Widows, blended families and inheritance in eighteenth-century urban Sri Lanka

First Ladies

Memory and the kinship of writing and picturing in the early seventeenth-century Netherlands

Una posible paternidad para la tabla de la Sagrada Familia del convento de San Vitores (Burgos)

In nomine patris... Elements for a semantics of medieval paternity

Roy Porter Student Prize Essay Figuring Pictures and Picturing Figures: Images of the Pregnant Body and the Unborn Child in England, 1540- c.1680

Women’s Fashions and Politics in Seventeenth-Century Spain: The Rise and Fall of the Guardainfante *

Fulvia and Octavia: the female warrior's and the matron's coins

Doppelganger Dilemmas: Anglo-Dutch Relations in Early Modern English Literature and Culture

The Changing Perception of the Five Senses