Abstract:Clinical supervision plays a pivotal role in training the next generation of health service psychologists. Given the dyadic nature and multiple priorities of supervision, dilemmas are common; however, few data exist on the frequency and types of dilemmas, and more importantly, how they are navigated. Of the limited data that are available on this topic, few encompass the perspectives of both supervisors and supervisees. This study aims to address these gaps by surveying supervisor ( N = 29) and supervisee ( N = 65) responses to eight vignettes of supervision dilemmas. We use a mixed-methods approach to investigate quantitative ratings of perceived dilemma frequency and harmfulness, and content analysis to identify themes in qualitative responses assessing how participants navigate dilemmas. A supervisor failing to provide adequate critical feedback to a supervisee was perceived by participants as the most frequent and harmful dilemma. Strong consistency in frequency and harmfulness ratings of vignettes was found among supervisors and supervisees. Content analysis revealed four main themes among reported strategies: relational, reflective, direct, and indirect. The majority of strategies reported were direct, involving confrontation and problem solving. However, there were situational and temporal nuances in how participants described they would use strategies. Supervisees reported greater use of indirect strategies involving passivity and avoidance. Overall, our study underscores the potential for a decision-making framework that could help standardize supervision guidelines and recommends that such a framework incorporate an assessment of the severity, frequency, and temporal aspects of each dilemma. (PsycInfo Database Record (c) 2024 APA, all rights reserved)

Dilemma and Development: Research on Supervision of Social Work Practice

Review of Clinical Supervision Models of Psychotherapy

Research Supervision as a Spiritual Ministry: A Confluence of Object Relations, Psychodynamics and Grace

The Relationship Between College Student Advisors' Career Commitment and Job Satisfaction

Managing clinical supervision dilemmas: A mixed-methods vignette study.

The Impact of Social Work Supervision on Interns’ Employment Intention: New Evidence from Mainland China

The Role of Supervision in Professional Development of Social Work Specialists

SUPERVISION IN THE SOCIAL PRACTICE OF ART THERAPY AND COUNSELING

Development of the Psychotherapy Supervisor: Review of and Reflections on 30 Years of Theory and Research

Study of the Supervisor-Counselor Coordinative Mechanism for Ideological and Moral Education

Supervision and its Related Factors Among Chinese Mental Health Practitioners

Effect of Supervisor–subordinate Guanxi on Supervisory Decisions in China: an Empirical Investigation

What happens in child and family social work supervision?

The current status and prospects on the discipline of health supervision

Imagining Social Work: A Qualitative Study of Students' Perspectives on Social Work in China

Supervision in Occupational Therapy, Part 1: The Supervisor's Anxieties

A Research Into Accounting Supervision

Ethical practices in individual supervision of counseling in China

Professional Supervision: A Workforce Retention Strategy for Social Work?

Speaking of Supervision: A dialogic approach to building higher degree research supervision capacity in the creative arts