SynBio 2.0, a New Era for Synthetic Life: Neglected Essential Functions for Resilience.
Antoine Danchin,Jian Dong Huang
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1111/1462-2920.16140
IF: 5.476
2022-01-01
Environmental Microbiology
Abstract:Synthetic biology (SynBio) covers two main areas: application engineering, exemplified by metabolic engineering, and the design of life from artificial building blocks. As the general public is often reluctant to embrace synthetic approaches, preferring nature to artifice, its immediate future will depend very much on the public’s reaction to the unmet needs created by the pervasive demands of sustainability. On the other hand, this reluctance should not have a negative impact on research that will now take into account the existence of the multiple transitions that cells face over time. The ages of life—birth, development, maturation, senescence and death—reflect specific key transitions and have, until now, rarely been taken into account in SynBio designs. This results in a mismatch between novelty and the very long evolutionary time that led to the existing chassis [remember that this is the common term used to describe the cellular framework as seen by synthetic biologists (de Lorenzo & Danchin, 2008)]. It also implies that, in general, transitions between growth stages will be taken into account with the appropriate embodiment of highly specific processes. This is particularly important when adapting new models to their host, whether natural or artificial. Adaptation follows two stages, short-term accommodation of new entities and long-term assimilation into the cell as a whole. This requires discrimination between classes of entities. We suggest that proteins playing the essential role of Maxwell’ demons, here named Maxwell’s discriminators (MxDs) to refer to their original function, will permit the assimilation and accommodation of artificial constructs. As a consequence, we can foresee that class discrimination, beyond mere recognition, will be implemented in SynBio 2.0, leading to an authentic paradigm shift (Kuhn, 1996), based on conceptions that embody information as a genuine currency of reality. The prevailing view of SynBio restricts the field to the implementation of the de novo writing or rewriting of genetic programs in model chassis, with two major aims: metabolic engineering and conceptual design of synthetic life. In practice, this takes the form of controlled circuits that manage the expression of genes of interest for pure knowledge exploration or, most often, for industrial purposes. These circuits are designed in a manner somewhat similar to that of microprocessors (Buecherl & Myers, 2022) and implemented in model organisms selected for their well-known physiology (Bernhards et al., 2022). The most common are bacteria such as Escherichia coli (Lynch et al., 2022), Bacillus subtilis (Zhao et al., 2022) and more recently Pseudomonas putida (Duque et al., 2022). In a minor but conceptually important trend, intended to illustrate how we can access the minimal set of functions that could (should) be assembled de novo to make a cell alive, Mycoplasmas’ chassis have also been used (Talenton et al., 2022). In these organisms, very elaborate experiments have been developed despite their restricted translation machinery based on a limited capacity to modify transfer RNAs and a somewhat limited use of the genetic code (UGA being translated into tryptophan, rather than signifying the end of translation). These engineering processes have been the source of two major standardization efforts: BioBricks (see for a recent illustration (Nguyen et al., 2022)) or SEVA (see (Nikel et al., 2022)), collecting essential pieces for the construction of new pathways. However, they have idiosyncratic properties that require better interoperability, a feature that is gradually being addressed (Damalas et al., 2020). In addition to this general trend, we can easily understand that the current way of building new life forms is still far from the complete synthesis of an Received: 12 July 2022 Accepted: 16 July 2022