Metalloenzyme Mimicry at the Nodes of Metal-Organic Frameworks
Qi Sun,Briana Aguila,Shengqian Ma
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.chempr.2018.11.017
IF: 23.5
2018-01-01
Chem
Abstract:In this issue of Chem, Dincă and co-workers show that the node of the metal-organic framework MFU-4l can be modified by anion exchange to serve as a biomimetic model of carbonic anhydrase given the similarity in their ligand fields. The resulting material, which has reactivity characteristics of the enzyme, gives great promise for CO2-related applications. In this issue of Chem, Dincă and co-workers show that the node of the metal-organic framework MFU-4l can be modified by anion exchange to serve as a biomimetic model of carbonic anhydrase given the similarity in their ligand fields. The resulting material, which has reactivity characteristics of the enzyme, gives great promise for CO2-related applications. Enzymes, nature’s creation of catalysts, show extreme activity and selectivity for a range of chemical conversions. However, even when an enzyme is identified as being useful for a given reaction, its extensive application is often hampered by its lack of long-term operational stability and also by difficulties in recovery and recycling.1Schmid A. Dordick J.S. Hauer B. Kiener A. Wubbolts M. Witholt B. Industrial biocatalysis today and tomorrow.Nature. 2001; 409: 258-268Crossref PubMed Scopus (2017) Google Scholar Advances have been made in biotechnology to allow for enzyme production at commercially acceptable prices and manipulation of them such that they exhibit the desired properties with regard to substrate specificity, activity, selectivity, and stability. Nevertheless, only a handful of successful paradigms that function properly have been synthesized. To overcome this ambiguity, biomimicry provides rational solutions through the incorporation of active-site synthetic analogs of enzymes in suitable matrices by taking advantage of the versatility of synthetic chemstry.2Sanchez C. Arribart H. Guille M.M.G. Biomimetism and bioinspiration as tools for the design of innovative materials and systems.Nat. Mater. 2005; 4: 277-288Crossref PubMed Scopus (1167) Google Scholar Metal-organic frameworks (MOFs) are envisioned as the most promising candidate for this purpose.3Chen Y. Ma S. Biomimetic catalysis of metal-organic frameworks.Dalton Trans. 2016; 45: 9744-9753Crossref PubMed Google Scholar, 4Nath I. Chakraborty J. Verpoort F. Metal organic frameworks mimicking natural enzymes: a structural and functional analogy.Chem. Soc. Rev. 2016; 45: 4127-4170Crossref PubMed Google Scholar, 5Doonan C. Riccò R. Liang K. Bradshaw D. Falcaro P. Metal−organic frameworks at the biointerface: synthetic strategies and applications.Acc. Chem. Res. 2017; 50: 1423-1432Crossref PubMed Scopus (391) Google Scholar MOFs are highly tunable nanoporous network compounds composed of inorganic nodes connected by organic linkers, and they offer tremendous potential for rational material design.6Zhou H.-C. Long J.R. Yaghi O.M. Introduction to metal-organic frameworks.Chem. Rev. 2012; 112: 673-674Crossref PubMed Scopus (5091) Google Scholar Their crystalline structures trace out topological backbones onto which desired functionalities can be introduced, either as functional moieties on the organic linkers or through the choice of metal nodes. The molecular-level structural control and modularity possible with MOFs allow for a hydrophobic or hydrophilic confined environment akin to natural enzymes, as well as offer an ordered distribution of highly dense substrate-accessible active catalytic sites throughout the architecture. In addition, the higher stability of MOFs than of enzymes potentially leads to the broader use of biomimetic chemistry in industrially relevant applications. Carbonic anhydrase (CA) is a ubiquitous zinc metalloenzyme that catalyzes the reversible hydration of CO2 with an exceptional turnover rate of 106 per second, one of the fastest rates in enzyme catalysis.7Parkin G. Synthetic analogues relevant to the structure and function of zinc enzymes.Chem. Rev. 2004; 104: 699-767Crossref PubMed Scopus (828) Google Scholar To expand their utilization, researchers have therefore employed a large variety of tridentate ligands in efforts to obtain synthetic analogs of CA. Among them, the hydroxide complex TptBu,MeZnOH (Tp = tris(pyrazolyl)hydroborate) has also been shown to be a functional analog of CA. Unfortunately, these systems lack heterogeneous analogs with similar activities, significantly hindering their industrial use. Given the similar ligand fields, the nodes of MOFs are attractive sites for mimicking metalloenzymes. In this issue of Chem, Dincă and co-workers took the lessons learned from these homogeneous systems and targeted the material MFU-4l (Zn5Cl4(BTDD)3, where H2BTDD = bis(1H-1,2,3-triazolo[4,5-b],[4’,5′-i ])dibenzo[1,4]dioxin).8Wright A.M. Wu Z. Zhang G. Mancuso J.L. Comito R.J. Day R.W. Hendon C.H. Miller J.T. Dincă M. A structural mimic of carbonic anhydrase in a metal-organic framework.Chem. 2018; 4: 2894-2901Abstract Full Text Full Text PDF Scopus (58) Google Scholar The secondary building unit (SBU) of this triazole-based MOF features facial coordination of Zn2+ by three nitrogen atoms and is a scorpionate unit shown to structurally and functionally emulate the Tp-like environments within this MOF (Figures 1A and 1B ). In this paper, the benefits of using MOFs as a biomimetic platform are at the forefront: pore environments and structural tunability, site isolation, high surface area, and periodicity are all highly sought-after attributes for any efficient heterogeneous catalyst. The crystalline nature of MOFs offers opportunities to use their nodes as structurally characterizable active sites where mechanistic details of a catalytic process can be teased out, allowing for rational design and thereby improved overall efficiency. Herein, the structure of MFU-4l lends itself perfectly as the platform for mimicking CA for two primary reasons: (1) the SBUs in this material feature four peripheral zinc chloride sites that are coordinated by three triazoles in C3 symmetry analogous to the Tp ligand and, accordingly, CA, and (2) the metal node of MFU-4l can be further modified by anion exchange to serve as a biomimetic model of CA. The original terminal N3Zn–Cl centers are quantitatively transformed to terminal N3Zn–OH units by treatment with tetrabutylammonium hydroxide to yield MFU-4l-(OH) with a conserved framework structure. After confirming the structure, Dincă and co-workers proceeded to probe the enzymatic reactivity of MFU-4l-(OH). Considering that the essential function of CA is to catalyze the reversible hydration of carbon dioxide and a critical step in this process is CO2 insertion into the Zn–OH bond, the authors thus studied its CO2 sorption behavior by collecting CO2 sorption isotherms. To gain more insight into the framework-adsorbate interaction, they calculated the isosteric heat of adsorption (Qst) as a function of the amount of CO2 adsorbed on the basis of the adsorption isotherms measured at three different temperatures (288, 298, and 308 K). Calculated with the virial equation, the Qst at zero CO2 coverage was 81 kJ mol−1, reflecting a strong chemisorption mechanism and agreeing with the reaction enthalpies determined for CO2 fixation by transition-metal hydroxide complexes (49–61 kJ mol−1). With increasing coverage, the Qst stayed relatively constant up to 0.5 equiv of CO2 per SBU and then steadily decreased from 62 to 35 kJ mol−1 for the second CO2 equivalent and from 35 to 20 kJ mol−1 for the third CO2 equivalent. To reveal the underlying mechanism, the authors carried out quantum density functional theory computations to understand the enthalpies required for CO2 insertion into different Zn–OH units. The trend of decreasing binding enthalpy along with the CO2 adsorption is consistent with the experimental data. These results suggest that with the conversion of the highly basic –OH to weakly basic –OCO2H (Figure 1C), the nucleophilicity of the remaining Zn–OH sites within a given metal node are weakened, thereby resulting in decreased Qst values. Given the significant uptake capacity (3.41 mmol g−1 at 298 K) and limited energy cost required for regeneration, this material gives great promise for CO2 capture and sequestration. To further prove the ability of MFU-4l-(OH) to perform CA-like reactivity, the authors investigated the reversible hydration of CO2 by studying the exchange of 18O-labeled H2O with gaseous CO2. The time to reach an equilibrium mixture of the three possible CO2 isotopologues (C16O2, C16,18O2, and C18O2) was significantly reduced from 10 to 5 hr after MFU-4l-(OH) was introduced. Also, MFU-4l-(OH) exhibited activity in the hydrolysis of 4-nitrophenyl acetate (4-NPA) with a 15% ± 2% conversion after 24 hr, in contrast with 1.7% ± 0.2% conversion of the blank control. These results thereby prove that the metal nodes of MFU-4l can be functionalized to serve as a high-fidelity biomimetic model of the CA active site. This contribution demonstrates an elegant example of functionalizing a MOF metal node to mimic the activity of an enzyme. Facilitated by the modularity of MOFs and the diverse toolbox of synthetic modification techniques that they offer, it is conceivable that MOF-based materials show great potential in the field of biomimetic chemistry.9Jin C. Zhang S. Zhang Z. Chen Y. Mimic carbonic anhydrase using metalorganic frameworks for CO2 capture and conversion.Inorg. Chem. 2018; 57: 2169-2174Crossref PubMed Scopus (46) Google Scholar, 10Bien C.E. Chen K.K. Chien S.-C. Reiner B.R. Lin L.-C. Wade C.R. Ho W.S.W. Bioinspired metal-organic framework for trace CO2 capture.J. Am. Chem. Soc. 2018; 140: 12662-12666Crossref PubMed Scopus (90) Google Scholar Taking inspiration from enzymes, it will be intriguing to see the advantages that MOFs can offer in advanced material design. As this paper shows, MOFs with enzyme-like active sites afford great opportunities to push the boundaries of numerous challenges faced nowadays, such as CO2 capture and sequestration. With high structural fidelity and reactivity, MOFs hold potential for future understanding of enzyme chemistry and also the potential to perform enzyme-inspired reactions in stable frameworks. As more and more stable MOFs are discovered, researchers are beginning to tap into the potential of this class of material for industrially viable applications. A Structural Mimic of Carbonic Anhydrase in a Metal-Organic FrameworkWright et al.ChemOctober 4, 2018In BriefThe nodes of metal-organic frameworks are attractive sites for mimicking metalloenzymes, primarily through their site isolation and similar ligand fields. In this article, the metal-organic framework MFU-4l is shown to mimic the active site of carbonic anhydrase with high structural fidelity and reactivity. The material adsorbs high quantities of carbon dioxide at low pressures and mimics critical features of carbonic anhydrase, such as isotopic exchange of oxygen atoms from water and carbon dioxide. Full-Text PDF Open Archive